Skip to main content

I became disabled a few years back and started refurbishing erector sets. Part of those sets/line were the 420  American Flyer Locomotives. I bought my first one and got hooked. Their copper/brass fittings and design for a "cheap" yet realistic locomotive impressed me. I now have a few of them Yes I realize their limited run, warping of the body, decomposition of the wheels, etc. I realize that they were never intended to last a hundred years. But am I the last of the Mohican's on this line? Are the locomotives relegated to end up as book ends? it seems every one is showing off either the super early, super rare, or the new modern. i have visited and inquired at "O guage" places and they politely say sorry we don't work with those (including the large shop in Saginaw Mi). Am I nuts to care? GILBERT GREG

THANKS, GREG J. TURINETTI FOR YOUR SUGGESTION AND COMMENT.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I think what Gilbert saw was an opportunity to build a new product line to add to his many other items. The guy even had a lead molding and uranium science type sets. Right after acquiring A.F. the next year or so  he was selling build your own kits as well as pre-finished. (even the locomotives) The cars were a dollar cheaper unfinished but the display box with brush and paint had to cost quite a bit you would think. Maybe this gives us a clue on issues. if you have kids (mind you they were more engineers than today) putting them together/ painting the items that might explain why there are issues esp. in the paint area.

As a side note you see common items like screws, fiber disks, rockets in usage. The huge advantage was  his cross marketing. Build a bridge that your train could go across. It took a larger set to build it. I build a few usually 1 to 2 feet section models for different train guys and it take an 8 1/2 set just to give you enough parts.

Thanks for you note. Here is a pic of one of the train kit ad 1939.

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0

Fascinating - I had no idea they offered these engines in kit form! Did the loco kits come in the Erector sets or were they sold separately or both? Gilbert was certainly a Renaissance man and a genius promoter of his many products. Even if he had not produced his remarkable postwar S gauge trains, he certainly deserved membership in the Pantheon of toy producers! Erector alone would have insured that!

Gary

Doesn't it seem strange to use 3  models in say 5 years in the same set(s). Changes with in the models with in the year as well. Then out side erector you have an entire train world growing, (expanding on/using the existing A.F) w/TRU-MODEL PIONEER,STREAMLINE , NORTHWESTERN, PATHFINDER, MOUNTAIN RED BALL, NORTHERN PACIFIC, YARD KING, SANTA FE, B & O, N.Y. CENTRAL, J-3a HUDSON (2 VARIANTS), AND THE TWO UNION PACIFIC. Then you have all the rolling stock, buildings. You could never acquire all of them just in the small window of 5 years. Even in today's relative cheaper climate you would need a ware house to display. Ever the marketer.

To my know ledge, the kits were only A.F. as a separate train option out side if the Gilbert Erector sets. When I got into the Erector sets I did not even know of trains other than the huge ads usually on both sides of back cover page of the building sets. Which by the way is the pic you see on some of the A.F. train billboards. In the building sets there were instructions on train bridges etc. but you would see pics of erector girder, boiler, stack,  and turret built locomotives that looked like a steam locomotive, Beginning in 1938 (a yr after he bought A.F.) you could buy 3315.then 39 the 420, and then in 40 the royal blue, with a few parts.They were only part of the largest building set which I have not personally ever touched fully complete.(Of course expensive) thus rare. 

There is one oddity. (using Greenberg's guide) In 1931-33  Gilbert came out with the Hudson locomotive, It came in a large #8 set and was the crowning jewel. Literally using many erector pieces he had a shell made and incorporated numerous standard pieces and it looked authentic but huge. You could buy it either assembled or build it your self. Same with the tender. This monstrous beautiful working set  was just out of most peoples reach. Included in the 10 set with an airplane etc, the box weighed 150 pounds and needed 2 people to lift. I think Gilbert had a seed for real trains was  planted here. 

 

 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×