Skip to main content

In another thread, several offered the suggestion to purchase these instead of repairing the whistle buttons on some old post-war transformers.

 

In looking at these, they appear to be a single button.  Will a single button cover both the whistle and bell for a modern conventional engine?  Or, do I need two buttons per transformer, one for bell and one for whistle?  Are they programmable, meaning this one is for the bell, this one is for the whistle.  At $20-30 each on the used market, it could be pricey and I think then I'd be better off just attaching a powermaster at $40 each on the used market.  They do the job with whistles and bells plus give me Cab-1 control.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

At $20-30 each on the used market, it could be pricey and I think then I'd be better off just attaching a powermaster at $40 each on the used market.  They do the job with whistles and bells plus give me Cab-1 control.

         

I've been operating my small layout in this fashion for years - postwar ZW for power, a pair of Powermasters and a CAB-1 for control. I can even run/access basic features of my MTH PS-1/2 locomotives with this configuration.

Originally Posted by Lou Sessa:

..........- postwar ZW for power, a pair of Powermasters and a CAB-1 for control. I can even run/access basic features of my MTH PS-1/2 locomotives with this configuration.

That last part was always a little dicey for me. 

 

I was trying to use the bell and horn for the very specific sequences required to control subway sets though (auto mode under conventional control), so maybe it works better if you are just trying to blow the horn or ring the bell once in a while.  I could never easily get the required timing right using the CAB-1 for programming the subway sets.

 

-Dave

 

Last edited by Dave45681

"I could never easily get the required timing right using the CAB-1 for programming the subway sets."

 

CAB-1 can't generate the short pulses necessary to program PS-1 or PS-2 in conventional mode.  The TPC has "macro" sequences to accomplish this.  If you make up your own controllers or buy the sound activation buttons you can learn to jab the short pulse sequences with just a little bit of practice.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×