Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

"...if it got a better sounding whistle..."

With a beautiful scale model like this, the proper question to ask is "how close to the real H-7 whistle is it?", not if it is "better-sounding" (whatever that is). And yes, the H-7 is rather under-appreciated.

Does anyone know how accurate this H-7 whistle is? I do not.

The Lionel N&W Y-3 2-8-8-2 has the N&W "hooter whistle" - pretty accurate to my ears, but I've never liked it. Thankfully the N&W did not use it on the 4-8-4 J.

Last edited by D500
D500 posted:

"...if it got a better sounding whistle..."

With a beautiful scale model like this, the proper question to ask is "how close to the real H-7 whistle is it?", not if it is "better-sounding" (whatever that is). And yes, the H-7 is rather under-appreciated.

Does anyone know how accurate this H-7 whistle is? I do not.

The whistle in the video, above, is not correct for either a UP version (should be the UP standard Star Brass freight chime whistle), nor a C&O version (should be the standard C&O "hooter" whistle, which was similar to the N&W "hooter").

The Lionel N&W Y-3 2-8-8-2 has the N&W "hooter whistle" - pretty accurate to my ears, but I've never liked it. Thankfully the N&W did not use it on the 4-8-4 J.

Also, for what it's worth, the famous C&O H-7 class locomotives, referred to as "Simple Simons" by the C&O, were not all that successful, and during WWII they were forced upon the UP, who simply hated them. As soon as WWII was over, and war traffic levels subsided, the UP quickly removed them all from service, sold off the tenders to the SP, and scrapped the engines.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×