Skip to main content

At this time of year with many embarking on well deserved vacation, long weekend or day trips, a visit to a tourist railroad might be part of your plans.

So, do you have a favorite tourist railroad and why is it your favorite?

Do you also have a favorite short line railroad and why is it your favorite short line?

Also, have any of these railroads spurred interest in or contributed in any way to the roads you collect or what you have included on your layouts?  

Edited June 16, 2013:

Thanks, Bob and Allan, for the book and website references you mentioned and while they certainly are worthwhile but first hand recommendations and personal experiences are what I am looking for plus whether any of those railroads have influenced what you collect or what you've included on your layouts. So everyone please keep them coming. Thanks.

BTW, Allan, that site you linked is an excellent resource.

 

Kenn

Last edited by ogaugeguy
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

These are a couple of my personal favorites out here on the West Coast:

 

 

California Western (aka "The Skunk Train")

 

http://www.skunktrain.com/

 

Beautiful ride between Ft. Bragg and Willits through the Mendocino redwood forests.  Looks like they had a cave-in in tunnel no. 2 and need to raise funds to repair it so operations to Willits can continue, although even the halfway trip to Northspur and back to Ft. Bragg is worth it too.

 

 

 

Yosemite Mountain Sugar Pine Railroad

 

http://www.ymsprr.com/

 

For a good Shay fix.

East Broad Top RR   (though its not running this year, hope things change next year)

 

My mother is from Robertsdale Pa ..... a Rockhill Coal & Iron Co/EBT company town. Her family immigrated from Italy to mine coal there.

 

Nothing available in O that I know of, so I did-up a few undecorated Weaver hoppers with EBT decals from the society. Thinking of doing the same with a Legacy red-roofed Mikado. (Narrow gauge notwithstanding)

 

Jim

Given one’s geographic limitations, you may find obtaining a copy of “Tourist Trains Guidebook – 4th Edition” published by Kalmbach Books very helpful for selecting something of interest within reach.

 

Not to slight other areas and offerings, but Colorado south and west of Denver may be the US gold standard of tourist excursion railroads. Having very recently been to Colorado, I strongly concur with Don’s suggestion of the Cumbres and Toltec RR. The recently restored and reconfigured parlor cars are exceedingly well done and recommended. A vintage narrow gauge steam excursion at its finest.

 

C and T

 

If you are in the general area, one must also strongly recommend the iconic Durango and Silverton. Currently, the track is in better shape on the C and T yielding a smoother ride, but the D and S has the even more spectacular scenery and offers a very interesting tour of the shop and museum. The significant other will likely find Durango more appealing than Alamosa.

 

D and S

 

 

D and S 2

 

While we are discussing Colorado rail sights, do take the Royal Gorge Route Railroad out of Canon City. The Royal Gorge offers smooth diesel service with available full dome cars with dining service and truly spectacular views of the route of the California Zephyr in its D & RGW glory days.

 

Royal Gorge

 

If you can also arrange to do so, the Pike’s Peak Cog Railway with its Swiss-built equipment is a must. Beware that is considerably cooler on top of the peak than in Manitou Springs. The views are breathtaking (literally) and some can briefly con themselves into believing that there really are prototypical 3-rail railroads. 

 

Pikes Peak

 

Steamtown in Scranton is always very worthwhile with its live steam train rides, museum, and working turntable and repair shop.

 

CN 2317 at Steamtown

 

 

While you are in Scranton, be sure to visit the Electric City Trolley Museum and take a ride on one of the Brills such as the beautifully restored Red Arrow Lines example shown below.

 

Red_Arrow_Brill

 

Enough for maybe two summers, hey?

 

Bob

 

Attachments

Images (7)
  • C and T
  • D and S
  • D and S 2
  • Royal Gorge
  • Pikes Peak
  • CN 2317 at Steamtown
  • Red_Arrow_Brill
Last edited by Bob Bubeck

Pretty big wildfire at the Royal Gorge if you haven't heard. Got an e-mail this morning that the train is running halfway up the canyon right now, hoping to restore the full trip next week. Have a new GP-40 engine. My best wishes go out to those who live and work in the region.

 

The narrow gauge railroad at Cripple Creek, CO is worth a look. The ride is peaceful, get a good history lesson during the excursion, and the scenery is breathtaking. Go when the Aspen's are turning in the fall and it's amazing.

Yes, Brian. Godspeed to those facing the wildfires in the Colorado area.
 
Below is the Cripple Creek and Victor NGRR No. 2 (an 0-4-0) departing Cripple Creek depot.
 
CC RR 1
 
Bob
 
 
Originally Posted by brr:

Pretty big wildfire at the Royal Gorge if you haven't heard. Got an e-mail this morning that the train is running halfway up the canyon right now, hoping to restore the full trip next week. Have a new GP-40 engine. My best wishes go out to those who live and work in the region.

 

The narrow gauge railroad at Cripple Creek, CO is worth a look. The ride is peaceful, get a good history lesson during the excursion, and the scenery is breathtaking. Go when the Aspen's are turning in the fall and it's amazing.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • CC RR 1
Last edited by Bob Bubeck
I second on the pike's peak train. However make sure you bring/wear a jacket because it will be freezing at the Summit. When I was there in October, it was about 60 on the ground but 29 at the top without wind chill.

Another good one is the Seminole Gulf Railway in Fort Myers Florida. In addition to a dinner train, daytime excursions, and a murder mystery train, they also operate freight service. I have not been on the dinner train (only on the daytime excursions) , but I have heard that the food is good.

Cass WV.....yes...I am bias living nearby......but before I moved here in 2002 I had gone there 25 times or more. My ride count is up to almost 50 with a ride schd in July. 

It is a unique place with 100 year old locos, Shay, Hiesler and Climax steam. The only state park in the world 10 feet wide and 12 miles long. Located in a county that 12 rivers flow out of but none flow in and when you get to the top of Bald Knob you often see planes flying below you! A good old time slice of life!! 

 

Remote for sure.....but so much to do and see in the area and almost all of it is FREE!!! A great place in these days and times. (and lack of cell service gets the kids off them things for a few minutes)

I have to kick myself at times like this. I grew up in Colorado and have not been on any of those trains.

 

Here in New Hampshire I have ridden the Conway Scenic several times now and the COG up mount Washington as well.

Remember your camera or you WILL regret it !

For the COG try to get the first run of the day, it's the only run with a steamer. Also be sure to take a heavy coat, hat and gloves.

It can be 70° at the bottom and below freezing at the top.

And the wind chill must be experienced to be believed.

You are welcome, Kenn, regarding the Tourist Trains Guide Book.

 

To address your question, rail fanning over the years has resulted in some additions to my collection. For example, I have on my roster a scale Lionel NW 611 and a scale PM 1225 Berkshire, having seen, heard, smelled, and felt the real beasts pass through Michigan. In part, I have a Lionel “Lindbergh” E6 No. 460 because of having both inspected the prototype in the Pennsylvania RR Museum and recollections of PRR E6’s on their way to New Jersey shore points. Some features observed on short lines have been incorporated -- in altered form --  into the layouts over the years. And, Richard Kughn’s Carail Museum layout did kick start me into tinplate.

 

However, the key motivation for many for going out of one's way to visit short lines, excursion steam railways, and other unique steam events is to, yet again, experience the visceral impact of the real thing.

 

For what it is worth.

 

Happy travels. 

 

Bob

 
 
Originally Posted by ogaugeguy:

Also, have any of these railroads spurred interest in or contributed in any way to the roads you collect or what you have included on your layouts?  

Edited June 16, 2013:

Thanks, Bob and Allan, for the book and website references you mentioned and while they certainly are worthwhile but first hand recommendations and personal experiences are what I am looking for plus whether any of those railroads have influenced what you collect or what you've included on your layouts. So everyone please keep them coming. Thanks.

BTW, Allan, that site you linked is an excellent resource.

 

Kenn

Last edited by Bob Bubeck
I would add the Valley RR in Essex CT. Several steamers and a nice matched heavyweight trainset all operated out of a great early industrial site along the Connecticut River. They have a new last year Chinese Mikado rebuilt as a New Haven steamer. Last year they had a really cool very well done Circus train they ran for photos.
The Saratoga and North Creek has 2 BL2s and several full dome cars. It runs inupstate NY and must be one of the fewtourist trains that meets Amtrak scheduled trains.
One last reply I promise.
Your second question. Yes. I have the Kline Plymouth painted as the Strasburg one. I also have the Lionel Service Station set NYC RS3 from the passenger/freight set. It has the same # as a unit that runs on the Adirondack Scenic RR near where I go in the summer. I have a NJ Central lines GP7 the same # as a unit that runs in Cape May in the summers. I'm sure I have others but these are fun.
Originally Posted by Silver Lake:
One last reply I promise.
... I also have the Lionel Service Station set NYC RS3 from the passenger/freight set...It has the same # as a unit that runs on the Adirondack Scenic RR near where I go in the summer...

Yes it does, and I live about 2 miles from it's winter resting spot.  Its up and running right now, in Thendara.

 

 

NYC RS-3 #8223

 

Lionel NYC RS-3 #8223

Attachments

Images (2)
  • NYC RS-3 #8223
  • Lionel NYC RS-3 #8223

For my choice The Saratoga and North Creek Railroad running from Saratoga Springs to North Creek, New York with it's E8, BL2, and 1950 era passenger cars is my current favorite. It is listed with New York State as a common carrier railroad meaning that it can pickup passengers at intermediate stations between it's two end points. They have built 6 stations along their route for this reason and plan to operate to Albany, NY. with an arrangement from Amtrak and the Canadian Pacific. All their equipment is kept in like new condition and they serve food and drinks on all trips in their full dome cars ex-Santa Fe (1956).

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×