Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I've grabbed my popcorn and I'm just waiting for the entertainment to start. Anything with the UP steam program, you just know the thread will get locked eventually!

But now that 844 has actually run and can steam now, I truly believe this project is going to get moving, and moving fast. What was a "never will happen" thing we all used to dream about in bull sessions is actually looking like we can really, truly, see a 4000 under steam again.

I never thought I'd see the day where I could type/write that and not have it be a joke.

No much info, but really cool all the same.  I would say that maybe the 844 success would quite some of the naysayers, but I am sure it won't. 

Thank you Union Pacific for your renewed dedication to steam operations and restoration. .Congratulations to the UP steam crew on a job well done on the 844 and looking forward to witnessing your next success with 4014.

Yes, they will have it running in a while, just like they did 844............I hope this thread won't get cut/butchered like the others, but we got more judges than jury on this forum!........I'd say that the Union Pacific has very deep pockets, and can throw man power, and dollars for parts at it, where other railroads can not or will not, everything viewed as an  "ROI".......Not one company has more money than the other, it's difference in business philosophy....I would have been tickled to death, to see the "765" run through the Ashland-Huntington-Ironton Tristate area this year, but NS says "NO", and it is their railroad....  

Last edited by Brandy
AGHRMatt posted:
Dominic Mazoch posted:

Getting the UPP 4014 to fire correctly with OIL is going to be the trick!

When I talked to them before 4014 left Los Angeles, they said they didn't see much of a problem. The Challenger was originally coal-fired and burns oil now. Don't recall if 844 originally ran on coal.

All of the UP 4-8-4's were built as coal burners, but by the end of the 1940's they had been converted to oil firing.

Stuart

 

I enjoy reading the news and the dialogue on this Forum about the Big Boy restoration. I think, for the most part, it is a healthy discussion. The bottom line for me is this. When the Big Boy runs again we should all be happy because that means someone, somewhere, has taken the bull by the horns and is leading us in the right direction. Let's bring back the remnants we have of the age of steam. For goodness sakes, let's celebrate all of this instead of beating each other into smithereens. 

When the Big Boy runs, I WILL be there. Not exciting enough for you ("yawn), then you need to look into therapy for the steam jaded.

Scrapiron Scher

A #4000 back in steam is pretty much as good as it will ever get for US preservation. Any steam person with an ounce of marketing smarts can see that this will have positive spill over to the rest of the steam world. Then again, we could just squander the opportunity while bickering and mudslinging. Anyone care to bet on what happens?

It would be interesting to speculate Ed's medium to long term goal/plans. Having now secured a 15  year "ticket" on 844 his next project as announced is 4014 which will take I guess a few years. Once that is done his next goal surely has to be 3985 and if he plans it right he could end up with all three in steam at the same time.

Is this a plausible plan if you were Ed?

Ukaflyer posted:

It would be interesting to speculate Ed's medium to long term goal/plans. Having now secured a 15  year "ticket" on 844 his next project as announced is 4014 which will take I guess a few years. Once that is done his next goal surely has to be 3985 and if he plans it right he could end up with all three in steam at the same time.

Is this a plausible plan if you were Ed?

No, because he will have NOTHING to do with 3985! In fact, he has been removing various appliances and components (all the superheater units have been destroyed), so as to make 3985 inoperable for the future.

 

Hot Water posted:
Ukaflyer posted:

It would be interesting to speculate Ed's medium to long term goal/plans. Having now secured a 15  year "ticket" on 844 his next project as announced is 4014 which will take I guess a few years. Once that is done his next goal surely has to be 3985 and if he plans it right he could end up with all three in steam at the same time.

Is this a plausible plan if you were Ed?

No, because he will have NOTHING to do with 3985! In fact, he has been removing various appliances and components (all the superheater units have been destroyed), so as to make 3985 inoperable for the future.

 

If HW is correct, somebody in Omaha should be concerned.  In other places, destroying company property ON PURPOSE could get one fired, or worse, arrested!

Does anyone know if Dickens ever engineered/ran the #3985, before it was taken out of service???

I just wonder what his beef with engine #3985 is,  other than having it on his "Tombstone" that he was the one who resurrected shopped/overhauled the #4014 back into service for the UP.................................Just Sayin!

Brandy posted:

Does anyone know if Dickens ever engineered/ran the #3985, before it was taken out of service???

I just wonder what his beef with engine #3985 is,  other than having it on his "Tombstone" that he was the one who resurrected shopped/overhauled the #4014 back into service for the UP.................................Just Sayin!

His beef with 3985 is that it is always been associated with Steve Lee and the old crew. He constantly has made excuses on why it isn't running with his latest excuse that it's "too slippery". I'm sure HotWater can give more info on this. 

Brandy posted:

I just wonder what his beef with engine #3985 is,  other than having it on his "Tombstone" that he was the one who resurrected shopped/overhauled the #4014 back into service for the UP.................................Just Sayin!

As mentioned in previous threads (all of which got locked eventually, as will this sooner or later, you can count on that), I think it was said that there was a commonality of parts between Challengers and Big Boys and there might have been something about yanking some parts of 3985 to eventually use on 4014.

I'm not 100% sure of that, but I think I read that on one of the all-long-since-locked threads on this subject.

Perhaps it is time to press the reset key on opinions related to the UP Steam Program now that 844 is back on the rails and performing well.   I'm going to follow future 844 operations and the 4014 restoration with great interest on this forum.  The die has been cast in favor of near term investment in 4014 over 3985 -  second guessing that decision achieves nothing positive but results in further animosity.  Hopefully the UP Steam Shop people will build on their recent success with 844 and management has learned from past experiences - both positive and negative - time will tell. 

Last edited by Keystoned Ed
J Daddy posted:

At least the NS has a steam program... the CSX needs to take note!

NS does not have a steam program. It ended in 2014.

J Daddy posted:

Scher - I think Rich's "Yawn" is the useless banter we will have to endear...

Not quite. The "yawn" indicates my complete lack of interest in the 4014 project.

p51 posted:

...As mentioned in previous threads (all of which got locked eventually, as will this sooner or later...

It will stay open as long as the discussion remains civil. That's in YOUR hands, not mine. If the discussion degenerates into name-calling, as the other UP threads have done, then yes, it will be locked.

Then you can start it all over again.

Last edited by Rich Melvin

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×