Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Wow. I'll bet there is a story there. Clearly the ES44 is a rescue job as the P42 cab would be unusable. How did that windshield get destroyed, we wonder? You can see the window frame is actually bent and there are several dents in the sheet metal. The right-side wiper blade is all bent up. Something fell from overhead? Ice from an overpass? A vandal attempting murder by dropping something off the side of a bridge?

From Wiki:

US Airways Flight 1549 is a classic example of this. The engines on the Airbus A320 used on that flight were torn apart by multiple bird strikes at low altitude. There was no time to make a safe landing at an airport, forcing a water landing in the Hudson River.

Jet engine intakes are very delicate things (wrt bird strikes) compared with a locomotive windshield and especially the surrounding metalwork:

Jet engine ingestion is extremely serious due to the rotation speed of the engine fan and engine design. As the bird strikes a fan blade, that blade can be displaced into another blade and so forth, causing a cascading failure. Jet engines are particularly vulnerable during the takeoff phase when the engine is turning at a very high speed and the plane is at a low altitude where birds are more commonly found.

 It is the bent frame and several dents that make me think of heavy debris such as rocks/concrete/ice rather than bird strike.

geysergazer posted:

Because of crew safety I'd be surprised if the nose is aluminum.

The "skin" of the nose just may be aluminum, as all the structural strength is under that "skin". In fact, the units on the California Commuter trains out of LA have fiberglass nose pieces, for easy replacement when basing into vehicles.

That nose was designed to withstand a lot of impact energy, as in a loaded stone-truck crossways on a grade crossing.

As I just stated, above, the strength is all hidden under that nose "skin".

That is why those windshields are actually pretty small. In this pic it is easy to see the bolted-on quickly replaceable lower nose-piece (in case of the inevitable grade-crossing crash.

 

Looks like steel to me:

          P42 nose

This image is housed at Wikipedia and I have permission to Post it here under Creative Commons Rules. The photographer was S. Shankar of Dubai.

ON EDIT: Embiggened for better visualization of the dings:

            The_mighty_engine_is_pulling_just_three_cars!_[26262891823)

Really looks like steel to me. While those dings are on the lower nose-piece it would be bad engineering to switch to sheet aluminum for the upper nose because of galvanic corrosion.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • P42 nose
  • The_mighty_engine_is_pulling_just_three_cars!_(26262891823)
Last edited by geysergazer

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×