Originally Posted by Hot Water:
Originally Posted by MTN:
Originally Posted by jaygee:
UP 6944 is in Conway, as we speak! 17:15 / Tues. PM. I like this fix 2156 talk; Hey it would be cheaper than fixing a GG1 !
Restoring the FT to running condition would be far more practical...
Yea right! First, the Altoona Works is NOT restoring the DDA40X to "running condition", only a cosmetic restoration as trade to the Saint Louis Museum for the loan of Y6a #2156.
Second, it would actually be more practical, and doable, to restore the 6944 to operation, that that piece of junk FT. Besides, would could one do with only one FT anyway?
Why is it junk? The PA being rebuilt as NKP 190 was in far worse condition than the FT-A in St. Louis; should Doyle McCormack have bothered restoring it because it was basically a rusted carcass consisting of a nose, windshield, and damaged frame, stripped of all mechanical and electrical parts, and most critically its trucks? The replacement trucks aren't identical to the original trucks - perhaps the restoration should stop because it's not authentic? There's only going to be one running PA in the U.S. for the foreseeable future - surely it will have other power running with it as back-up, as well as providing muscle to pull a train of more than a half dozen cars or so. That shouldn't cause folks to dismiss it because it's most likely not going to run solo on anyone's mainline.
The S-BC FT A unit in Mexico was rebuilt with parts from a later F unit - I posted a link to a clip of it awhile back where it was running on the point of a train (can't tell when it was shot, but it's pulling its B-unit). Here's a different video at the museum in Puebla where they're running it on a short stretch of track:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRleaRXh6uI
The shop folks in Mexico understood they had a rare engine in their hands, and did what was needed to make it capable of running. Perhaps the St. Louis FT could be brought back to operational status and paired with that S-BC unit someday, or mated up to the remaining B units in the U.S. acting as dummies. It's historically significant - part of the demonstrator set that showed railroads freight diesels were practical and more cost effective than steam. That alone ought to qualify it for restoration to running status. It's pretty much a carcass right now (more complete than the PA), but if the PA that's being rebuilt can be made to run, that FT could receive the same treatment.
Restoring diesels or steam that's sat for decades makes no practical sense whatsoever, but it's great to see something brought back to life. I love PAs and FTs and would enjoy a chance to see either of them run in the future - I'm not old enough to have seen a live FT, and PAs were in the wrong part of the country for me to have seen any in action.