Skip to main content

Nowadays with the evolution of computers now having catalogs online there are few people that like the old paper book catalogs. I keep old ones if my locomotives that I have are in that catalog. Some use it such as Eric Siegel because when I watch his webcams, he most likely uses it to help make his review go from good to excellent. So do you like reading catalogs online, ore getting paper printed and why.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I store mine in the archival polyethylene sleeves and keep them in a box.  I have from 1930-present; most in "mint" (realizing there's no mint for paper) conditions; the older ones are almost flawless.  Started collecting them in 1975 then took a break for a few decades.

 

I'd love to have DVD copies of all the catalogs, cuz I really really really don't want to dig out a 1937 catalog just to check something on the scale Hudson.  I understand there were copyright issues with some of the catalogs hence they cannot be electronically scanned.

 

Funny thing is that the newer items have such desire to operate, I often find myself scanning catalogs from 6-8 years ago to find out when a given item was originally made.

I have a file cabinet with hanging basket files.....every Lionel catalog from 1946 through 2000 is represented. Every MTH catalog from 1994-2000 is there, too.....Since 2000, I use the Internet for my catalogs and bring the extra paper catalogs (after a year or so) to modular set-ups to give to kids.

 

I have ditched my Atlas and Williams catalogs (gave them away to kids at set-ups). I have a large pile of KLine catalogs for when/if John of HSL does a KLine archive.

 

I have an large ROW catalog that is neat......saving it for no good reason other than it is a talisman of a different era.

 

 

Peter

Last edited by Putnam Division

I keep all of my Lionel Post-war catalogs from 1946 to 1959 in plastic envelopes which I store in a glass enclosed bookcase.  I do the same for all of my American Flyer catalogs from 1950 to 1959.  I still take them out quite often and page through them.  Its like a walk through history and I still enjoy them.  I have kept only a few of the modern catalogs such as Lionel's 2000 catalog and the first couple of the Lionel Tinplate catalogs from MTH.  I am a digital subscriber here on the forum but for pure relaxation purposes I still prefer to leisurely thumb through a hard print catalog or magazine.   

There is nothing like the Real Lionel Catalog, or AC Gilbert Catalog, or The MTH Catslog, or The Weaver Catalog,or the Atlas O, or k-Line Catalogs, or Ives, or Dorfan, or What ever.....I like sitting in an easy chair and just thinking about the Good Ole Days of wishing I had that Lionel F3 Sante Fe or NYC F3 ABA......Dreams came true many Years Later....This is the Best of Times, yes This the Very Best of Times.

From one mans Imagination way back before the Year 1900---Through 2015, it's simply Just Gotten Better.....Wow, the trains of this Era are Simply the Most Fun, the Most Realistic, (most Expensive) The Next Thing to standing beside a Real Train.

Originally Posted by Putnam Division:

I have a file cabinet with hanging basket files.....every Lionel catalog from 1946 through 2000 is represented. Every MTH catalog from 1994-2000 is there, too.....Since 2000, I use the Internet for my catalogs and bring the extra paper catalogs (after a year or so) to modular set-ups to give to kids.

 

I have ditched my Atlas and Williams catalogs (gave them away to kids at set-ups). I have a large pile of KLine catalogs for when/if John of HSL does a KLine archive.

 

I have an large ROW catalog that is neat......saving it for no good reason other than it is a talisman of a different era.

 

 

Peter

 

Don't part with those K-Line catalogs Peter! "or at least talk to me first"  I would love those on a digital format! 

This hobby is great - one can study/concentrate/operate in just about any niche they desire - there's no problem as long as you have fun.

 

Let me just clarify my position on things. I buy trains to operate. Every one of 'em has been on the rails. Yes, I run my scale Hudson remake, but it does sit under a glass case on the mantle.  But I "collect" paper. Stock certificates, catalogs, etc. I collect not so much to collect, but to have a source for reference.

 

I find it odd that so many of the replies thus far have talked about disposing of the catalogs. True, the newer versions will probably never amount to much of a dollar value, but as I noted in a prior post, even *I* use them for reference purposes.

 

All that said just to tweak the survey just a little: Do those of you who toss the catalogs also toss your boxes?  As in, I would find it intellectually curious if you toss the catalogs but save your boxes. To me, it's one and the same...

I personally hate the online/digital catalogs.  I have yet to find a computer that they work well on.  And the downloadable PDFs aren't much better.  Plus you can't just flip through them like you can with a paper one.  Plus, once I'm done with the paper one, I put it on a low book shelf so that the kids can look at them.  I remember "drooling" over things in catalogs as a kid, why should I deny today's kids the same experience?

 

quote:
All that said just to tweak the survey just a little: Do those of you who toss the catalogs also toss your boxes?  As in, I would find it intellectually curious if you toss the catalogs but save your boxes. To me, it's one and the same...



 

Interesting question. If I have an original box for a train, it is kept, regardless of the value of the train or the age of the item / box.

Keeping the boxes / packing may not enhance the resale value of an item, but they certainly do make them more saleable and easy to store


I stopped saving catalogs issued after a certain date because:
the product described within doesn't interest me
they have little to no value

I am out of space (most important reason)

Last edited by C W Burfle

I have liked printed catalogs all my life. I like looking at them and reading them. I think it all started with the Sears Christmas toy catalogs back in the '50s when I was a kid and I am too old to change now. There are some old electronics catalogs (Heathkit, Laffayette (SP), etc.) from the '60s or so that I wish I had kept. Would be fun to go back and look at them now.

 

So, I think this thread has now got me keeping all my train catalogs. Even if the stack does get out of hand as I mentioned earlier. If I make it another 20 years or so (which I am hoping for) it will be fun to go back and see the changes that have been made since I re-entered the hobby in 2011. Look how far things have come in the last 20 years. Can't imagine what the trains will be like in another 20 years or so if it continues this way? As long as there is competition I think we still have many new features to look forward to.

Dont want or need new MTH or Lionel catalogs anymore. Keep old MTH up to about 2001, Sold off the MTH trains. Only really keep my Lionel catalogs up until 2001. I sold off all but a few postwar Lionel trains and I switched to S scale a couple years ago. I lost interest in O gauge and all the pre-order nonsense.  Also cant justify paying up $50 to $60 bucks for one freight car that came out of the same exact mold/ tooling that was developed in the 50's

 

 

I had a pile of old catalogs - 1950s - 1980s.  They were in good shape.  I put them out at Cal-Stewart and other 3-rail train shows to sell for $1 each or 6 for $5.   Only a couple of them sold.

 

I have tried giving the newer ones away at train shows without success.  As far as I can determine the only people who want them are the recycle people.  That is where they will probably end up.

 

NH Joe 

 

 

Originally Posted by Carl Orton:

This hobby is great - one can study/concentrate/operate in just about any niche they desire - there's no problem as long as you have fun.

 

Let me just clarify my position on things. I buy trains to operate. Every one of 'em has been on the rails. Yes, I run my scale Hudson remake, but it does sit under a glass case on the mantle.  But I "collect" paper. Stock certificates, catalogs, etc. I collect not so much to collect, but to have a source for reference.

 

I find it odd that so many of the replies thus far have talked about disposing of the catalogs. True, the newer versions will probably never amount to much of a dollar value, but as I noted in a prior post, even *I* use them for reference purposes.

 

All that said just to tweak the survey just a little: Do those of you who toss the catalogs also toss your boxes?  As in, I would find it intellectually curious if you toss the catalogs but save your boxes. To me, it's one and the same...

Earlier this year I dumped years worth of magazines that rarely ever got a second look. It gave me a little pause in the moment, but within an hour I was feeling great about the reclaimed space and the prospect of less dust. My stacks of catalogs are next to go. I will scan the sections I want to keep and then walk the paper to the bin. Maybe I will keep one or two that I really like; I did the same with my magazines.

 

I still hold on to boxes for rolling stock and larger accessories for the simple practical reason that it will facilitate selling and shipping when that time eventually comes. 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×