Skip to main content

New book out by Keith Wills "American O Scale" 1927-1965 ( A Brief History of the companies, people and products)  published  by White River Productions.  $19.95

Keith Wills has written  for Railroad Model Craftsman with his column Collectors Consist 1982-2014,  has penned  a very nice but  "Brief"  history of O Scale.     

Keith has done an excellent job pulling facts about the real world economy , other influences , and distractions most important when conveying the  history of any subject.   Keith is very knowledgeable pulling many of the obscure O scale players and giving them a voice.   The history begins in the mid twenties with the economy booming, leisure time and money to take former boyhood tinplate train  enthusiasts to the flange  world of realism and scale.   Ride the train to the depths of the depression, only to receive  a huge shot of adrenaline for the fledgling hobby with corporate O scale miniature  railroads seen by millions at the Chicago Century of Progress.  Learn how the newly formed  NMRA in 1935 settled the 1/4" vs 17/64th"  and outside 3rd rail vs 2 rail   debates ( at least on paper).   Learn about the  big boys of the tubular rail and deep flanges ( Lionel & American Flyer)  throwing  their weight around pushing into the "scale scene"  forever changing the look of tinplate "toy" trains.

Keith brings in the little gauges and how they nip at the heels of O scale and ultimately  win the sales race with the masses. 

The little book is packed with lots of information but I wanted more.  The book is illustrated with primarily manufactures catalog pages / ads but with a lack of any captions to the illustrations !  As a history book one would like to know what year catalog is being shown , and the reader is left guessing what illustration goes with which manufacturer.  

The book is laid out with the rise and fall of the hobby : Pioneer Years, Dynamic Growth, Post War, and Decline ( covering   engines only ) , the prewar and post war are covered again later with the   rolling stock , so to get a history on one company, you need to search two locations in the book. 

I'm old to the toy train world but new to the O scale world and was hungry for knowledge on the history of the various O scale manufactures  and how they influenced the overall direction of toy/ model train world.  The book is a great reference but leaves one hungry for more.  

Well worth the price to have a guide to the early O scale world ....  but I'd be happy to have paid double for double the information.

Thank you

Carey Williams

 

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_9428
  • IMG_9429
Last edited by OGR CEO-PUBLISHER
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I thumbed thru the book at the Indy meet but was out of cash by the time I found the book. I will have to get one thru Amazon.  It is nice brief history but others are right, a nice complete history of each company, what they have produced.  Espically while many are still alive to recount the companies of days past.  Hopefully the author will follow up with an expanded version if this book sells well and enough folks help out with thier accounts of companies of years ago.   Maybe add in some of the more prominant hobby shops like All Nation, Trost, Madison Hardware ect, that have had a huge impact on O scale in general.  Either way, this book is on my short list to pick up as soon as funds permit   Mike

Just saw this reviewed in OGR, and comments above do not make it sound to be the comprehensive catalog of O scale companies, kits, rolling stock, and structures produced over time that l hope for. Keith Wills was thought to be exactly the guy who could have produced that.  Those brass importers, that brought in McKeens, and Mack's are very important.  They are hope for finding something not presently available, IF IT EXISTED. This is true for the one ad in the back of MR kitbuilder...poof, he, and what he made, was gone.  I want to know about him and everything he offered.

I really have liked Kieth's columns over the years but was really disappointed with the many errors and omissions in the book.  In fact, I was looking for Kieth's email address just to send him some corrections (if he is interested).  He gets an awful lot wrong about Scale-Craft, Faber, Lobaugh and other old time manufacturers based on information both from their catalogs which I possess and from direct participants I have met through the years.  I have info originally from Bob Smith (CLW) and Henry Pearce (Pearce Tool) among others as well as articles in the old O Scale News/48 to the foot.  That all being said I still have a copy of the book and enjoyed the reprinted ads and catalogs.  

J2M

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×