Skip to main content

I posted some pics of my new Lionel reefer here, so for brevity I won't post them again.  The car is NIB, and was built in the USA in the late 90s I guess.  It is nicely detailed IMHO.  I bought some Lionel end of train devices a while back and haven't used them.  While this car doesn't come with a collector, I was able to easily add a spare one I had lying around, so I can get power to the car.  While I know it's not prototypical for the era of the car, would it be so out of place as to look dumb?  I need to ask before I drill a hole to connect the ETD.

Last edited by texgeekboy
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well, it is certainly your RR, but your question is actually not whether you can do it, but rather should you do it. As you seem to be a modeler who does care about realism, or its approximation, my response would be no. And you asked for opinions, so that is mine.

Why not use a modern car and not waste the car or the device? Unless you wpuld then have to excuse not only the FRED but the entire modern car...

@harmonyards posted:

It’s your railroad, so the only person you gotta impress is yourself,…….if you want an ETD on that reefer, have fun,…….nobody that I know of would or should question it,…enjoy!…..

Pat

I know plenty of people who would question it, but they would not be welcome in my basement.

You're not destroying a rare antique; if you like the look, go for it.

Thanks @harmonyards, @Mallard4468, and @D500.  I've seen many of all of your posts and I do value your opinions.  Yeah, I was unsure about doing it, that's why I checked here first.  My yard (and I speak in virtual terms here since I don't have one yet), will be a mix of mainly 60s-70s, with some modern day stuff.  Kinda like the first Batman movie!

Last edited by texgeekboy

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×