Skip to main content

Originally Posted by SantaFeJim:

Guys,

 

I will be talking with Jerry Kimble and Rob Pisani in about an hour.  If you have any questions about the Atlas F7's I will be happy to try to get answers.  Just post them here.

 

 

Will the (2) road #'s 37 & 45 have Phase I and Phase II specific details, for example the #37 was delivered with 36" DB fans vs the #45 delivered with 48" DB fans?

 

Joe

Originally Posted by Scrapiron Scher:

If Atlas O does decide to do Super Chief cars, will I still be alive when the entire set is complete? That is very iffy . . . . One or two cars every twelve months . . . I would be 79?

 

...

Atlas has set a dubious record indeed for the length of time to deliver a complete passenger train.    I'm thinking the CZ domed observation is hopefully between Hawaii and California by now.  And if that shipment can clear the backup of containers stuck on ships at the West Coast docks, perhaps we'll have an observation car in our hands in 1H2015.  Any bets on the baggage car by year end?  Or will that drift into 2016?  Instead of celebrating the train's completion, it's gotta be pretty anti-climactic at this point.

 

When did Atlas announce the CZ?  It's been so long ago, I forgot.    Perhaps 2009??? WOW!!!  Has it really been almost 6 years???  

 

I hope they never try that approach again.  I know I wouldn't sign up if they did.  Who would???  

 

David

Last edited by Rocky Mountaineer

Highly unlikely Atlas would announce another passenger train set,they are at least a year away from completing the CZ cars and their current builder is still very slow on motive power production [one model a year at current rate] the TBA of 3 previously scheduled models seems to be freeing up the schedule for a "reasonable future delivery" of the much hyped F7s,think first half 2016.JMO Any future passenger trains will most likely come from Sunset.

Guys,

I just got home from the O-Scale show.  I was only able to talk with Jerry for a about five minutes.  I had a long line forming behind me and I did not want to be rude and read off a list of questions.

Jerry will re-visit this thread when he returns to work.  I am sure that he will address ALL your questions.  He is a Santa Fe modeler and he tells me SS matches the Athearn units therefore I have no reason to doubt his word.

I am all-in.
I agree.  Who cares if they get the SS look right when the fuel tank is too small!
 
That was the deciding factor for me not to pre-order these new f-7s.  (I was tempted by the rio grande)
 
 
Originally Posted by SANTIAGOP23:

A bit off topic but I think most, if not all of us, would appreciate new tooling for the fuel tanks in these F7's. The fuel tanks used for the F3's is awful.

 

Last edited by Martin H
Originally Posted by Martin H:
I agree.  Who cares if they get the SS look right when the fuel tank is too small!
 
That was the deciding factor for me not to pre-order these new f-7s.  (I was tempted by the rio grande)
 
 
Originally Posted by SANTIAGOP23:

A bit off topic but I think most, if not all of us, would appreciate new tooling for the fuel tanks in these F7's. The fuel tanks used for the F3's is awful.

 

 

 

I raised this same point on January 28th when the new Atlas F7's were announced and nobody else jumped in so I figured maybe I was wrong.

 

Here is a link to page 2 of that topic, where my post appears:

 

https://ogrforum.com/t...der-pricing-1?page=2

Last edited by SantaFeJim

Will the (2) road #'s 37 & 45 have Phase I and Phase II specific details

Joe- They have 37 & 41 listed on their website which is more recent than the catalog.  I think they may have changed to 41 so they don't need to go with the larger d/b fan.

 

A bit off topic but I think most, if not all of us, would appreciate new tooling for the fuel tanks in these F7's. The fuel tanks used for the F3's is awful.

This would be a good time to correct the fuel tank.  Didn't you correct that on your F3's?

Last edited by marker
Originally Posted by marker:

A bit off topic but I think most, if not all of us, would appreciate new tooling for the fuel tanks in these F7's. The fuel tanks used for the F3's is awful.

This would be a good time to correct the fuel tank.  Didn't you correct that on your F3's?

I did, but it was $60 plus shipping for an ABA. I used Lionel tanks from their recent F7's. The installation wasn't fun either

 

 

I want to thank everyone who has posted on this thread especially “Hot Water” and “Santa Fe Jim” who both came by to visit with me at the Chicago O Scale Meet with your thoughts and suggestions for our F7 diesel locomotive.

 

We realize the passion that exist from all of you on getting things right and we’ll try our best to meet those expectations.

 

I won’t be making anymore post on these suggestions unless something comes up that we may need clarification on so in the mean time if you’re leaning towards ordering one of these locomotives make sure you do so before the deadline, which is April 8th, 2015.

 

Jerry Kimble

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Originally Posted by Pingman:
Originally Posted by Erik C Lindgren:
I wish jerry would have posted this in 2 rail I would not have missed it for 24 hours.

Erik, it speaks volumes about where the market is that he posted it in "Hi-rail" and not 2RS or 3RS IMO; of course, I may be reading too much into it.

 

I've learned to click on the "Forums" segment below the banner ads, and then click "all topics" to avoid missing something I may be interested in.

 

 

 

 

For Atlas and this particular model they will need to make their reservation number from the 3 rail market. Sunset will bring in their F7 by the fall and it will probably be sold out mostly to 2 railers willing to pay more for better drives rd names with specific details.Bear in mind Atlas will most likely need 3 times the reservations for 5 or 6 rd names to make this run happen[much lower "street price"will help] every F7 2rail and a small amount of 3 rail engines that Sunset sells is one less for Atlas.Not knocking either product,just a market reality.JMO

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The 2R and 3RS guys like these units because they have body mounted steps, fixed pilot option, and Kadee adaptability right out of the box. I wouldn't be surprised if 2R out sells the 3R versions, just like the 3rd Rail models. Like I said, this forum may be dominated by 3 railers, but it's only a fraction of the O scalers in general, and the Atlas Master Line stuff really appeals to model railroaders.

LOS, no offense intended--you have been a great help via email since my return to the hobby.

 

How do you combine 2RS and 3RS as a single voice?  My take is that 2RS is the red-headed stepchild.  Which is what has  been said previously.

 

In other words, 2RS lives because 3RS and Hi rail are the buyers.  Said another, less polite perhaps, is simply this:  2RS is dead; and, unless its proponents can presell models. 

 

 

Last edited by Pingman

 Who cares if they get the SS look right when the fuel tank is too small!

Martin - I have to say I do.  I can replace the fuel tanks easily enough.  It would be impossible for me to replicate the stainless. 

 

From Santa Fe Jim about Jerry Kimble:

He is a Santa Fe modeler and tells me the SS looks just like the Athearn units therefore I have no reason to doubt his word.

I missed that post on the 14th, thanks Jim!  That just cost me the second set.



 

Last edited by marker
Originally Posted by marker:

 Who cares if they get the SS look right when the fuel tank is too small!

Martin - I have to say I do.  I can replace the fuel tanks easily enough.  It would be impossible for me to replicate the stainless. 

 

From Santa Fe Jim about Jerry Kimble:

He is a Santa Fe modeler and tells me the SS looks just like the Athearn units therefore I have no reason to doubt his word.

I missed that post on the 14th, thanks Jim!  That just cost me the second set.



 

I would suspect the fuel tank will not be changed on the F7 the basic shell is virtually identical to their previous Phase2 F3, the tank is a part of the shell mold, the fans and grilles are piece parts.While it is possible Atlas could modify the tooling for a correct tank, I would be suprised if they did.JMO

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×