Skip to main content

Here's another decoder install I did recently on an MTH 4-8-4 Greenbrier. This is a 2007 catalog engine, so it's PS-2 with the wireless tether (but not 3-2 convertible, despite the catalog description). I got this beast from a fellow forum member, and it's in really nice condition cosmetically and mechanically. Ready for some new electronics!

 IMG_7549

I like to start with a complete disassembly, both for purposes of planning the decoder install as well as for performing a complete mechanical overhaul. Here it is with the old electronics removed, shortly after arriving in the shop:

IMG_7567

With the compact size of the Loksound L decoders, it's easy to install them in the boiler, rather than in the tender, which really simplifies the wiring between the boiler, chassis, and tender. Here's the block diagram I worked up for this guy while planning things out.

diagram

As you can see, with the decoder and related electronics in the boiler, the only wiring that has to go to the tender is for the speaker and the reverse light. Similarly just the pickups and the motor need to be wired to and from the chassis.

The light gray box represents a polystyrene sheet that I cut to mount the decoder and other electronics on. It screws into a couple existing holes in the boiler, so it makes for a nice subassembly. The power board, regulator, and power switch are part of a standard approach I use for powering smoke units, and are described in detail in this thread. Here's a pic of the assembled electronics board, prior to snapping the decoder in:

 IMG_7582

Here are the power board, regulator, and power switch, with the two smoke unit connectors to the right. The red/black connector is for the track pickups from the chassis. The large harness to the bottom is one of the original MTH harnesses that I re-used for the speaker and reverse light connections.

IMG_7583

And here are the four connectors for the headlight, cab light, firebox light, and number boards.

IMG_7584

And here it is with the decoder and electronics board installed in the boiler:

IMG_7592

The tender was fairly straightforward, just the reverse light and new speaker. Lots of room for a nice big speaker in there now... I reused some of the existing 10 conductor harness again here. I didn't wire the electrocoupler, as I'll be replacing that with a kadee, however that could also be accommodated as described in the referenced thread above.

IMG_7575

The chassis was pretty easy also, just the motor leads and track pickups, as well as the harness to the tether.

IMG_7609

Next, I 'buzzed out' the wiring with an ohmmeter. To do this I hook up everything electrically between the boiler, chassis, and tender, and do continuity and isolation checks on the adapter board. This is a really good step to perform to ensure everything is wired properly and to avoid smoking a new decoder. Things to check include:

  • Isolation of ALL other connections from the track power and ground. This is vital, especially on older engines (including this one) where the chassis is also the electrical return to the track.
  • Continuity of the red lead to the track pickups.
  • Continuity of the black lead to chassis ground.
  • Speaker continuity (5-10 ohms depending on the speaker)
  • Motor continuity (anywhere from 25 to about 200 ohms)
  • Lighting continuity. If using incandescent, look for a few ohms. If using LED, you can test using diode mode.
  • Smoke heater (roughly 8 ohms)
  • Smoke fan (varies, 100 to 200 ohms)

In this particular case, I found I had wired one of the leads for the reverse light to an incorrect solder pad on a connector. Nothing would have blown up as a result, but it's nice to be able to fix any issues like that before powering up.

With all that checked out, I applied DCC power to the track pickups, still without the decoder installed, and set the output voltage on the regulator to 5 volts. This powers the smoke heater and fan.

Finally I popped the decoder in, and things are ready to close up at this point!

IMG_7611

After programming the decoder, as described in this thread, here's the end result. Amazing sounds (recording doesn't remotely do it justice, sadly), and enough smoke to fill the room, if you want.

 

How's the low speed performance you ask? Check it out on speed step 1...

Anyway, just bench tested so far, but this thing is going to be an awesome smooth puller on the layout. Just needs a kadee for the tender now... 

Attachments

Images (10)
  • IMG_7549
  • IMG_7567
  • diagram
  • IMG_7582
  • IMG_7583
  • IMG_7584
  • IMG_7592
  • IMG_7575
  • IMG_7609
  • IMG_7611
Videos (2)
IMG_7613
IMG_7622
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

 I really know very little about DCC. I visited a 2 rail scale layout yesterday that had a K-Line tank engine running. They did  make a 2 rail version. Not sure if it was TMCC equipped originally from the factory. This engine sounded and ran well. The operator had a DCC remote in his hand.  I inquired and was told it had Tsunami sound. I was impressed.

 Real interesting read. Love the step by step tutorial. I'm guessing I could run DCC equipped engines with TMCC at the same time. It would only conflict with DCS ?   The chuff rate seems perfect at 4 chuffs. How is this accomplished ?

Awesome to see another conversion.  Sadly my DCC days have been put on hold due to unemployment (Otherwise I would have been bugging you with my projects.).  But once I have a job again and rebuilt my savings (Glad I was saving for a rainy day.) I'll dive in again.

Dave_C posted:

 I'm guessing I could run DCC equipped engines with TMCC at the same time. It would only conflict with DCS ?

I can't speak for DCS as I don't have the system, but I can tell you that you can't run TMCC and DCC at the same time.  You can run Legacy and DCC, but I wouldn't due to some issues with Legacy equipment.  You can read about my experiment and findings here.

Dave_C posted:

Real interesting read. Love the step by step tutorial. I'm guessing I could run DCC equipped engines with TMCC at the same time. It would only conflict with DCS ?

I would not try to run anything at the same time with two different control systems. I'm not too familiar with TMCC, but analog conventional, DCS, and DCC are definitely not compatible, if you mean actually running them simultaneously on the same track.

You can achieve some 'compatibility' between systems on the same layout, if you are careful with what is powered where, get creative with switching systems with some DPDT switches and so on. I have not done this personally, however.

The chuff rate seems perfect at 4 chuffs. How is this accomplished ?

The chuff rate is controlled with a couple CVs in the decoder, and you can really get it dialed in nicely, as you say. The procedure is well documented in the manual. You can also use hall sensors or other sensors as a trigger, if you really want it dead on accurate, but that is not so easy to install in most cases. The CV approach has been more than adequate for my purposes.

What is not documented at all in the manual, is getting the smoke fan motor synced to the sound! I had to figure that out, reverse engineer style. See my other thread here for details on that.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×