Skip to main content

Yet another Help thread from me... sorry.

 

Okay so I have this other thread (here) going where my 2-6-6-6 classification light was out/dim.  I had the housing off of the LED and was fooling with the light holding it out while pressing the housing onto it.  I tried this for about 15 minutes with the engine off but sitting on the track and the TIU unplugged.  After I would get it together, I'd fire it up, still dim, shut down.  Did this probably about 5 or 6 times without any issues.  The last time I was lazy and left the engine powered up.  Messed with it probably 3 more times, no issues.  The last time, while holding the wire (its insulated) and pushing the housing on, I heard a click (I hear it every time I plug the Z-500 in).  Now I get nothing from the loco, only "check track" on the DCS remote.

 

I put my SD70 on the track and it works fine, so its the loco.

 

What could I have done???


Would an engine reset do anything?

Last edited by mjrodg3n88
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Mike, If the insulation got nicked and touched chassis, your putting AC on the DC circuits and that can be fatal for PS-2 boards.  If the markers are LEDs they are on the 5VDC circuit.

 

If the marker remained dim, something else must have been wrong. Did you look at it with the classification light off?

Does the engine run in conventional?  If not, the boards need to be tested outside the engine.  They may be repairable at the component level.  The LED needs to be checked also.  G

Originally Posted by GGG:

Mike, If the insulation got nicked and touched chassis, your putting AC on the DC circuits and that can be fatal for PS-2 boards.  If the markers are LEDs they are on the 5VDC circuit.

I was using round part (shaft) of a small screw driver to hold the light out of the shell.  They are definitely LEDs.  What does that mean with the 5VDC circuit?  I have to admit, I don't fully understand this aspect of the hobby, but I do understand basic wiring, positive, negative..etc (and never to cross them).

 

If the marker remained dim, something else must have been wrong. Did you look at it with the classification light off?

Does the engine run in conventional?  If not, the boards need to be tested outside the engine.  They may be repairable at the component level.  The LED needs to be checked also.  G


The marker was only dim because it was not fully in the housing.  I had the engine powered up and the housing off and the LED was shining bright.  I'm not sure how to run it in conventional (I'm sure thats in Barry's book though?).  This sounds like its going to get expensive and was not worth a bright classification light at all.  If it is, this thing will be sitting for a very long time.

 **Edit - just went and looked at it closer, the insulation on the LED is still fully intact, only one small imperfection, but not a penetration.  Also, one thing I noticed is that the insulation slides down (not easily) from the LED.  The housing was difficult to push on, so it may be possible (although I don't think it did) that the insulation slid down, the housing touched a lead, then the shell.  The lead is pretty far under the insulation though which is why I don't think the housing could've touched it.

 

I guess I could take the shell off and look underneath, but in reality, I'm assuming it probably needs to go somewhere to get tested.  If thats the case, I have no idea where that would be.  

 

Also, I have no idea if this affects both the loco and tender or just the loco. 

Last edited by mjrodg3n88

G,

 

Ugh, this is so frustrating.  No, I did not try it conventionally.  Honestly, I dint even look into how I would try it that way (I skipped over those parts in the manual because I never planned on running it that way).  Was pretty disappointed in myself so I put it in a dresser drawer (out of sight, out of mind?).  


I will send you an email.

 

Gregg,

 

I will try that tonight when I get home, thank you.

John,

 

Hear the click when?  When powering up the Z-500?  If thats the case... I do not hear it.  That was the first thing I noticed last night after it happened.  When I plugged the Z-500 in, I didnt hear that usual click and at first thought "oh no, I ruined the TIU."  Heard it though when I put my SD70 on it so that confirmed it was the steamer.

 

Mike

As I stated it is better to try in conventional and eliminate the DCS.  That will prove if boards are ok.

 

Mike, conventional is easy as long as you have a transformer.  Just remove TIU and power it up with the transformer.  IF it starts up, you can do a conventional feature reset with the W and B.  Than go back to DCS and do the recovery engine.

 

But without the engine relay clicking, most likely the LED short damaged the boards.  If so, it is better not to power it up unless you can monitor current.  More times the board gets powered up with a short on the circuit board less opportunity of a repair at the component level.  Which saves you $$$$.   G

Originally Posted by GGG:

Mike you can send them to me, I am an ASC.  Probably need both, I am assuming the board is in the tender and the shell needs to come off to examine the LED.

 

Did you try it conventionally?  G

G, with all respect this reminds me a sign I saw hanging in a automotive garage.

 

"Why is there never time to do it right but always time to do it again?"

 

Sometimes you get lucky taking shortcuts but there many times you will get burned.

Hopefully in this case its not too serious.

 

Pete

 

John, thanks for those pictures, hopefully I'll get it apart tonight or tomorrow.

 

GGG, thanks.  That conventional is clear enough, I was assuming you meant with the DCS.

 

Pete, I hope its not serious either, but those hopes are not all that high.

 

Thanks Dave, but I think I'm going to avoid trying that with concerns it could get damaged even more.

Originally Posted by Norton:
Originally Posted by GGG:

Mike you can send them to me, I am an ASC.  Probably need both, I am assuming the board is in the tender and the shell needs to come off to examine the LED.

 

Did you try it conventionally?  G

G, with all respect this reminds me a sign I saw hanging in a automotive garage.

 

"Why is there never time to do it right but always time to do it again?"

 

Sometimes you get lucky taking shortcuts but there many times you will get burned.

Hopefully in this case its not too serious.

 

Pete

I don't understand your point?  What shortcut?  G

Ok, but that is what I said. I NEVER said this can be fixed without taking the boiler shell off.  Here is what I said:

 "Probably need both, I am assuming the board is in the tender and the shell needs to come off to examine the LED."

 

The end of the sentence clearly states the shell needs to come off to examine the LED.

 

 Certainly there is the option that he takes the boiler off and fixes the LED and I can certainly fix the board without the engine.  But Based on his experience, I "probably" should get both and do it.

 

I respect that some folk don't want to ship whole engines if not necessary, but I do warn them of the consequences.

 

Via separate e-mail he vacations near me so he can deliver it and I can repair before he goes home.  Which saves on the shipping both ways.  G

Last edited by GGG
Post
The DCS Forum is sponsored by

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×