Skip to main content

I'm wondering if it is feasible to modify an LW transformer control so that clockwise rotation increases speed, as on most other Lionel train transformers.

I'm using old RW and LW transformers which I restored to working order, and made my own control knobs to replace broken and missing plastic handles. LW replacement handles are rather expensive and possibly fragile.

A quirk of the LW is that the control knob rotates counter-clockwise to increase speed. The original control knob had a handle from the bottom, with the idea that you move the handle from left to right to increase speed. I find the opposite rotation inconvenient, especially when used next to my RW.

I have the wiring diagram for the LW and it appears possible to modify the wiring for opposite rotation. I realize it would change the fixed voltage taps. I'm electrically competent, I can figure how to rearrange the connections including the whistle control and circuit breaker.

Before I try this, I'm wondering if anyone else has done this and if there are any pitfalls to watch for. Specifically, do these transformers have tapered windings, or is there any reason why they wouldn't work right with opposite rotation?

Thanks for reading.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thank you both for the input, but I don't understand the comment about "I don't think the coil will fit backwards in the holder". I would be swapping the electrical connections around, not trying to flip over the coil. I would also have to swap the whistle control wires around somehow. I would get different variable voltage outputs. I haven't got to working on it yet; additional comments are welcome.
I think your problem will be getting access to the junction between the variable winding and the fixed winding. If you could isolate both ends of the variable winding, you might be able to reverse the rotation. Remember that flipping the ends of the variable winding will also flip the polarity of the voltage. When you wire in the fixed voltage windings, they must also be flipped.

Sounds like an interesting challenge! Keep us posted.
Yeah, I tried making a lever on the bottom of my home-made LW knob for left-to-right speed increase, but I still mess up with it, especially with an RW transformer next to it. Too many times I needed an emergency stop and turned it the wrong way!

Dale: I'm certain that the various connections are accessible inside the transformer case; I've done other work in there already. I reattached the frame with screws so I don't have to bend the four tabs again.

Original transformer information is available here:

http://pictures.olsenstoy.com/searchcd31.htm?itm=658
http://pictures.olsenstoy.com/cd/transfmr/pslw1.pdf

For other folks who might not have seen it, the Olsen's Toy Train Parts web site library has a wealth of excellent information.

My other project with this transformer is to reduce the amount of voltage boost on the whistle control. It makes most of my trains speed up noticably. I'll get to it eventually ...

I know most of those guys would just throw dollars at a new transformer, but part of my hobby is making the old things work!

There has been some other recent discussion of LW transformers so I though I would update this post.

 

I never did get around to modifying my LW transformer to change it from LH to RH operation, looked like it would be too much hassle. I acquired another RW transformer and use that instead, and now have two RW's side by side that both have RH rotation to increase speed.

 

I also acquired an old A transformer which has a case just like the RW except for no whistle button. I thought, great! similar to an RW, if I just add a whistle control. I took the whole thing apart to pound out the dents in the case, it was well used. Then I discover it has LH rotation. Well bummer. But then I discover I can turn the transformer around 180° in its mount to change it to RH rotation. I just had to extend some wires. So that worked out OK!

  

100_3086

 

Photo of Lionel "A" transformer circa 1947-48

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 100_3086
Last edited by Ace

I finally figured out for myself: yes, this modification can be done on an LW, and it's not too difficult.
 
With the top of the transformer core exposed, I discovered that the transformer core can be rotated 180-degrees (as viewed from the top), which effectively changes the transformer to right-hand rotation because the wiper arm will sweep across the exposed windings in the opposite direction. I had already done this on a simpler Lionel model "A" transformer, as noted previously in this thread. Using this method of modification on an LW, the various transformer taps will maintain their original values and there is no re-wiring of the whistle control circuitry.
 
Here is the general procedure for modifying an LW:
 
Open the case and remove the top frame from over the transformer core (this requires straightening 4 metal tabs). Next, drill out the rivet heads that secure the transformer to the base frame. The rivets are a long double-ended type that also hold all the transformer laminations together.
 
Next, drill out the other end on ONE rivet and remove the long shaft that goes through all the transformer laminations, and re-fasten with a 8-32x1.5" machine screw and one nut on the bottom, extra threads sticking down. Then replace the second long riveted shaft through the laminations the same way.
 
Re-orient the transformer core 180° (as viewed from the top), lengthening two wires as necessary (this will become self-apparent at this stage). Then re-fasten the transformer core to the base frame with a second set of nuts on the long machine screws. The first nuts serve as suitable spacers and the transformer core unit can be re-attached to the base frame with another nut on each screw.
 
The exposed top of the secondary windings will need to be polished lightly for the wiper arm to make good contact on its new, different arc. Then re-attach the top frame. One trick with reassembling an LW at this point: make sure the contacts for the direction button are correctly positioned when the top frame is reattached to the base frame. I used long machine screws to reattach the top frame to the lower frame, so I don't have to bend the four tabs if I work on it again.
 
As you can see in the photo, I have a home-made control knob on my LW, made from copper pipe and a piece of wood cut with a hole saw. The original plastic knobs and levers are prone to breakage and original replacements are somewhat hard to come by. I prefer my round home-made knobs, anyhow.
 
100_3322

100_3323

Now my LW has a control knob with right-hand rotation like the RW next to it, and it works fine this way. I used to have occasional mishaps in train handling with the control knobs operating in opposite directions on side-by-side transformers. No more of that! The FRA should establish some basic standards for train control equipment!
 
This LW is now a most-favored transformer, because it packs a generous 125 watts of rated power. That's good for about 90 watts continuous according to the old Lionel guidelines. It will effortlessly cruise two trains (with 3 motors) around my big mainline circuit, and blow whistles and horns.  

 

100_3325

Maybe I better add a safety disclaimer: don't work on these transformers unless you know what you are doing!

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 100_3325
  • 100_3322
  • 100_3323
Last edited by Ace
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×