Skip to main content

Hello switcher fans!!  Welcome to Switcher Saturday!!!  



Switcher Saturday ( SwSat ) is THE thread which celebrates all things switching locomotive related with discussion, sharing photos, videos, and information.   All is fair game as long as it's switcher related.  SwSat welcomes your input no matter what gauge you may model ... we welcome Z - G gauges as well as the real railroad 1:1 gauge!  If you are viewing this thread for the first time please feel free to post photos/videos and tell us a bit about your switcher (s) ... we'd love to have you as part of the SwSat community!  

SHOUT OUT TO STEAM CRAZY ( John ) whose photos of his beautiful Bangor & Aroostook BL2 shown on last week's SwSat were later posted on the OGR Facebook Page version of Switcher Saturday!  Three whistle toots ..... HURRAY JOHN!!!

We ask that anyone who posts to SwSat abide by OGR Forum Terms of Service found by clicking on TOS at the top of this page.  As a reminder please post only photos/videos  you have taken.  If you post someone else's photo/video/information be sure to have their written permission.  Posting copyrighted photos/ videos/ material is a violation of copyright law and violators are legally liable.  

As always, I'm excited to see what you all post!  We greatly learn from one another and you all have so much to share from rehab and upgrade projects, historical and technical information of both model and real switchers and switching railroads, to terrific photos of the latest high tech switchers, post and prewar switchers.  AND of course we as a community learn from all the content you provide.  So please feel free to post your photos and/or information!

Have a FUN-TASTIC weekend everyone!!!  Remember " Safety First"!  ... keep those switches aligned, attend to your switch lists, run your switchers this weekend and green signals to all!!  See ya next week right here at Switcher Saturday!!

The newest edition to my fleet of switchers is shown in the video and photos below.  

This week I present to the SwSat community my new ( to me ) BL1  EMD Demonstrator number 499.   It's an original Williams Electric Trains model and I'm loving it!  This model joins my switching fleet along side sister BL2 Western Maryland number 81 which is a MTH Premier model with Proto 2. I must admit that number 499 is much prettier than number 81!  Of course IMHO the Bangor and Aroostook had the most attrative livery of all the BL2s ever produced ... and again that is my opinion only.  None-the-less, I've wanted the BL2 demonstrator for several years now and  I'm thrilled to have this Williams engine join the Free State Junction Railway fleet!  

While some folks refer to the BL2 as an " ugly duckling", I find the BL2 to be an aesthetically pleasing locomotive whose smooth rounded curves are easy on the eye.  When wearing colorful liveries this locomotive really pops, thereby  lending itself to a genuinely unique class all its' own.  IMG_6215

As for the EMD BL1 prototype:  There was only one BL1 ever produced and it was the demonstrator locomotive number 499.  The number 499 is derived from the EMD project number 89499 for the BL1.    Originally equipped with an air throttle, number 499 did not have MU capability according to EMD marketing back in 1948, however it is said by some historians that photos of the ;locomotive showed it did come equipped with MU capability.  I've not been able to find the photos.     The BL1 is cosmetically identical to the BL2 models, all of which had MU capability.  A defining difference between the BL1 and Bl2 is the air throttle used on the BL1 while the BL2 had an electronic throttle.  The BL1/ BL2  production run was from February 1948 - May 1949 with only one BL1 and 58 BL2 units produced.  The BL1 was eventually upgraded to a BL2 with the installation of an electronic throttle.  

As ALCO was having great success with its' 1000 hp RS1 which began production in 1941 and the RS 2 which began production in 1946 with a 1,500 hp prime mover and a 1,600 prime mover in later models .. my hunch is ...  EMD management in 1948 thought it time to cash in on the ALCO success of "road switchers."  After all, in 1940  the Rock Island Railroad asked ALCO to design a locomotive for both switching and road assignments.   The following year of 1941, ALCO answered that request with its' ( now classic ) RS1.  It's worth noting:  The RS 1 enjoyed a 19 year run!  This  was the longest production run of a single model diesel locomotive of any kind ... not just diesel switchers.

With its' quest for a piece of the road switcher market EMD jumped into the game and the BL1 was born ( BL for branch line ).  The BL2 came along shortly thereafter.  The BL1/ BL2 produced 1500 hp and were built using some features/components of the highly successful F3 carbody type diesel locomotive.    F3s were not at all conducive to switching operations, with no sight lines to the rear of the locomotive for the engineer to see brakeman  on the ground and there was an absence of footboards.  Hence the design engineers at EMD came up with the BL1/BL2  by narrowing the carbody of the F3 and  giving a slanted shape along sides so the engineer could have a clear sightline to the rear of the locomotive through a rear cab window.     Foot boards were also included.  My thought is;  EMD design engineers wanted to retain a semi - streamlined aesthetic, as the BL1/2 also had optional passenger train capability.   EMD gave potential buyers the option of a steam generator for passenger train use.  Passenger equipped BL2 locomotives can be identified by the steam generator exhaust stack located between the cab's windshield panels.  

After EMD rolled out the BL2  ( 1948/49 ), U.S. railroad showed little interest in the BL1/ BL2 .  Only a few railroad purchased the BL2s.  Those railroads were C&EI, Monon, Boston & Maine, Bangor  & Aroostook, C&O, Western Maryland, Florida East Coast, Missorri Pacific, and Rock Island.    The locomotive had several drawbacks ... maintainence crews found it hard to work on, operating crews were not a big fan due to the lack of exterior side walkways, and sightlines were not optimal.   As a result, the sales were low with only one BL1 and 58 BL2 units produced.  

The C&EI purchased BL1 demonstrator 499 and  assigned it the number 1602.  This BL1 was upgraded to a BL2  as its' air throttle was replaced with an electronic throttle to match the BL2 throttle.  

The positive side to the negatives of the BL2 is ....  EMD turned the failures of the BL2 project into great lessons learned and wasted no time in creating a design  for a road switcher that became a railroad industry icon.    In May 1949 EMD rolled out the 1500 hp GP7 and  in 1954 the 1750 hp GP9 was introduced to railroads.  The GP 7 and GP 9 outsold the EMD competitors by far and became the best selling road switchers of the first generation diesel class!  Although it's never been said and certainly don't take my words as fact, however it's my humble opinion, we just may have the BL1/BL2 to thank, as they were a stepping stone to making the GP series of road switchers the most successful ever!   Just saying.

Number 499 has been testing out on the Free State Junction Railway pulling both passenger and freight trains plus doing a few switching chores on the industrial spur.  Shown here ... 499 running lite on the Mountain Division. IMG_6234

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_6234
  • IMG_6218
  • IMG_6215
Videos (1)
IMG_6213
Last edited by trumpettrain
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Boston & Maine Alco RS-3 #1506 is an MTH Railking model (30-21164) delivered in 2024 with PS3 at MSRP $389.95. Like my other MTH RS-3 diesels, the manufacturing quality is exceptional and it has the realistic sounds of a 12-cylinder Alco 244 motor. The excellent low-speed operation made it possible to take good videos of a slow-moving  milk train on my 10’-by-5’ layout.

B&M #1506 was built by Alco at Schenectady in April 1954 and equipped for passenger service. Alco produced 1,416 RS-3s between May 1950 and August 1956. They weighed 247,100 pounds, had 61,775 pounds tractive effort, 1,600 horsepower, and maximum speeds between 65 and 85 mph depending on gearing.

Videos show the engine running at 16 scale-miles-per-hour on my 10’-by-5’ model railroad pulling three milk cars – New Haven Dairy GICX 300, Bellows Falls Co-Operative Creamery MTC 1835, and Hood’s Milk GARE 819. The Boston & Maine Railroad transported milk from Bellows Falls, VT to the Boston area for Hood’s Milk and First National Stores (Brookside Milk), so those two cars in my train are probably realistic. Products for the New Haven Dairy would most likely have gone on the B&M to Springfield, MA and then into New Haven on the New Haven Railroad.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2025_0222_57_B&M_1506_10X5_JENKINSMELGAR_2025_0223_04_B&M_1506_10X5_BRIDGEMELGAR_2025_0223_17_B&M_1506_10X5_RR_CROSSINGMELGAR_2025_0223_21_B&M_1506_10X5_TRAINMELGAR_2025_0224_04_B&M_1506_10X5_JCTMELGAR_2025_0224_06_B&M_1506_10X5_BRIDGEPORT_METALSMELGAR_2025_0224_19_B&M_1506_10X5_NE

Attachments

Images (7)
  • MELGAR_2025_0222_57_B&M_1506_10X5_JENKINS
  • MELGAR_2025_0223_04_B&M_1506_10X5_BRIDGE
  • MELGAR_2025_0223_17_B&M_1506_10X5_RR_CROSSING
  • MELGAR_2025_0223_21_B&M_1506_10X5_TRAIN
  • MELGAR_2025_0224_04_B&M_1506_10X5_JCT
  • MELGAR_2025_0224_06_B&M_1506_10X5_BRIDGEPORT_METALS
  • MELGAR_2025_0224_19_B&M_1506_10X5_NE
Videos (2)
MELGAR_2025_0224_32V_B&M_1506_10X5_EAST_PORTAL_18S
MELGAR_2025_0224_36V_B&M_1506_10X5_EAST_30S_FEF
Last edited by MELGAR

Free State Junction Railway BL1/2 fleet. " The Beauty and the Beast"  

I've always thought the WM BL2 to be rather drab looking compared to the paint schemes of the other 7 prototype roads who purchased the BL2 locomotive.   However, Western Maryland is one of the 8 roads I model and of course WM was the only one of those 8 who purchased a BL2 ... they purchased two in fact.  The two WM B2s numbers 81 &82 stayed in this same livery throughout the entirety of their service years. Even after WM was absorbed into the Chessie System these two locomotive's  livery never changed from what you see here.  Both BL2 spent most of their years in the WM ( now CSX )  yards in Hagerstown, Md. The locomotives were retired at some point in the 1980s.  Number 81 resides at the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Museum in Baltimore, Maryland.  

IMG_1239IMG_6215

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_1239
  • IMG_6215
@G3750 posted:

Patrick, don't take this wrong, but which one is which?   

George

Hey George!  No offense taken .. lol! If I'm reading you correctly .. you might be one of many who may not have an affection for the BL2??  Only fans of the BL2 can tell the difference ... to everyone else all BL2s look all the same. LOL!  

Your S2 and slag cars look terrific!!!  .... as does your yard too!!

Good morning, SWSAT crew!

I'm switching things up this week. (Pun intended )  First the back story:  A couple years ago I got involved with a local HO group that focused on operations.  It was basically a large switching layout in one of the guy's basement.  This exposure to operations infected me with the operations bug.  While I can, and do, perform operating sessions on my O scale layout, it is difficult to do with more than two people.

After attending a local train show this past summer I hatched a plan to build a modular N scale switching layout.  I wanted a modular layout that could be easily transported, could be assembled in multiple configurations and had the capability of supporting several operating crews.  What I designed was a series of modules that are six feet long and one foot wide.  There is one module that is two feet wide that contains a yard.  Another has a spur that exits the side of the module.  There are three end modules with bumpers to prevent trains from running off the end of the layout.  I also constructed two corner modules.  There are six full size modules.  The track is centered on the module at each end and set back 2 1/2 inches to accommodate a connector track.  The modules are constructed of 1 1/2" extruded foam board supported by a wood frame.  Alignment pins and draw hasps secure the modules together and keep the track aligned.  Wiring is via a two wire cable that uses automotive flat connectors at each end.  Multiple power drops are included to ensure reliable power distribution.  Power is provided by a Digitrax Zephyr DCC system.  A UT6D handheld throttle is used for mobility.  All switches are manually operated.  All rolling stock is equipped with Micro-trains compatible couplers. There are currently no plans to add scenery, but I intend to add removable structures in the near future.

While I have had several "test" operating sessions in my garage with all modules in use, I have found that I can set up a single module on the dining room table and do some quick switching in the house.  One weekend, when my wife was out of town, I set up two modules in our family room and had an operating session while watching a college  football game.

This past weekend I gave the layout its first official appearance.  My wife and I went to our nephew's house in Michigan to help with the kids.  I took three of the six modules with us.  I set the layout up on the floor in the basement.  After going over the rules with the two oldest boys (ages 4 & 6) I  did some quick switching moves, showing them how the throttle operates.  I let one of the boys run the throttle while the other threw switches at my direction.  After switching the industries on the first module the boys traded places and we continued onto the second module.  The entire operating session took about 2 1/2 hours.  Their mother and my wife were extremely grateful for keeping the boys occupied for that long.

Here are some pictures of the layout while set up in Michigan:

IMG_1578IMG_1582IMG_1586IMG_1585

Before I disassembled the layout I let each boy run the locomotive from one end of the layout to the other and back again, no restrictions .

Both boys did an excellent job of running the trains. They played well together, which is highly unusual.  They both grasped the concept of how real railroads deliver and pick up goods.

Some things I learned:

- Clean track is a must

- Never set the layout up on the floor - that much crawling around takes a toll on this old body

- I didn't know a N scale locomotive could go so fast

- Bumpers are pretty strong

Sorry for rambling on.

Have a great weekend, everyone!

Tom

Attachments

Images (4)
  • IMG_1578
  • IMG_1582
  • IMG_1586
  • IMG_1585
Last edited by Tom Densel

Happy SWSAT All! Thanks for the start of this Saturday's Edition of a great thread Patrick. My operation today involves a PCR F40 PH and an EMD demonstrator SW8. The Dispatcher ordered the crew of the RB2 extra to drop their train just before the Keith Interlocking and move down the Main 7 car lengths. Holding until the EMD Demonstrator could add 4 more TOFs to their consist. Highly unusual to tie up both mains and the Main St crossing for a switching operation. The Junior Yard Master, Quinn caught H@&$ for giving the RB2 the green out of the yard before the 4 cars could be added.

Click the tube link

https://youtu.be/FzCSKsMFpz8?si=e1caJhb0iCRMGkyi

Last edited by pennsyfan

Good morning, SwSat Nation!  Patrick, thanks for telling me about the Facebook post, I didn’t know about it.  I got another surprise last night; I was looking at train videos on You Tube when I stumbled on an OGR video with my antique American Flyer 0-6-0.  I’m humbled to be in the company of some of the other fine modelers that contribute to this thread!

I enjoyed your BL2 history, you know it’s one of my favorite diesels, too.  You almost got my to “switch” from the switcher I planned to post today, but I’m sticking with another nice Williams model, my Canadian National RS3.  No. 3019 is seen hauling a long coal drag somewhere in the hinterlands of Ontario.

John

IMG_0952IMG_0953

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_0952
  • IMG_0953
Videos (2)
IMG_0957
IMG_0958

@Tom Densel  Your tale of modular switching and attracting young model railroaders is a very timely one.  That's very well done and something we can all learn from.  My NMRA division superintendent, the membership committee chair, and I are all involved in trying to boost membership and this is a story I intend to relate to them.  Getting young people involved via modules and handing them a throttle is terrific technique.  Thank you, and again - well done!

George

Well its a beautiful sunny day in the 70's here in Central Texas so I have been busy on "non-train" tasks today taking advantage of the warmer weather, but in keeping with SwSat here is a little Japanese lithographed tinplate 0-4-0 locomotive from the manufacturer "TN".  She is battery powered with the single "D" cell going in the boiler using the boiler front as a door.  Her consist is just one passenger car, which may qualify her as a "switcher" just moving a car into place to be hitched up to the next express coming along.  This loco is an example of the Japanese product era in the 1950's and early 1960's when their government decided that lithographed tin toys was a logical next step after inexpensive ceramic items in their post war recovery.  They made some really beautiful and elaborate tin plated trains and the quality was quite high.  By the 1980's all this stuff had migrated to China and the quality suffered greatly.  Anyway, here is my "switcher" for today, the 0-4-0 TN steam switcher and her single passenger car.

Japanese TN train loco top viewJapanese TN train loco front viewJapanese TN train side view

Best Wishes, hope your upcoming week goes well.

Don

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Japanese TN train loco top view
  • Japanese TN train loco front view
  • Japanese TN train side view
@G3750 posted:

@Tom Densel  Your tale of modular switching and attracting young model railroaders is a very timely one.  That's very well done and something we can all learn from.  My NMRA division superintendent, the membership committee chair, and I are all involved in trying to boost membership and this is a story I intend to relate to them.  Getting young people involved via modules and handing them a throttle is terrific technique.  Thank you, and again - well done!

George

Thank you, George.

I originally built the modular layout as a selfish experiment.  During the construction, one of our neighbor kids, who is autistic and LOVES trains, came over and I showed him what I was building.  I explained how the layout would eventually operate and theory of point-to-point operations.  He would often check in as construction progressed.  When I got things up and running I had him come over to do a simple switching session.  Later, I took him along to one of the HO operating session.  The owner of the layout had never met him before.  He handed him a throttle, explained how it worked, assigned him a locomotive and told him I was his conductor...MOVE IT OUT!  He had a blast!  His parents told me he talked about it constantly for several weeks and repeatedly thanked me for including him.  I have had a couple inquiries about publicly displaying the layout, especially during the holidays.  Based on the reactions I have gotten, I may have to seriously consider it.  It seems this selfish experiment has turned into a winning situation for all.

Tom

@Tom Densel posted:

Thank you, George.

I originally built the modular layout as a selfish experiment.  During the construction, one of our neighbor kids, who is autistic and LOVES trains, came over and I showed him what I was building.  I explained how the layout would eventually operate and theory of point-to-point operations.  He would often check in as construction progressed.  When I got things up and running I had him come over to do a simple switching session.  Later, I took him along to one of the HO operating session.  The owner of the layout had never met him before.  He handed him a throttle, explained how it worked, assigned him a locomotive and told him I was his conductor...MOVE IT OUT!  He had a blast!  His parents told me he talked about it constantly for several weeks and repeatedly thanked me for including him.  I have had a couple inquiries about publicly displaying the layout, especially during the holidays.  Based on the reactions I have gotten, I may have to seriously consider it.  It seems this selfish experiment has turned into a winning situation for all.

Tom

Tom - Wow! What a wonderful story!  Your kindness gave/gives this young man a thrilling experience.  Best wishes going forward with your switching layout and the community involvement!

A very nice discourse on EMD's BL1 and BL2 locomotives to start us off, Patrick. Over time, it seems this locomotive has  come to be considered by most railroad enthusiasts as anything but an "ugly duckling," including me! I guess the "resonance" we've experienced in our recent posts has not carried through to this week, though.

For my SWSAT Sunday Supplement, I present my almost finished ca. 1994 MTH (formerly PS-1) GP9 in NYC "Lightning Stripe" livery:

20250302_044619

20250302_044640

Here she is pulling a short NYC regional passenger consist of Lionel 60' semi-scale aluminum streamliners:

As the air tanks on the roof attest, the prototype #5946, built in December of 1955, had been fitted with a steam generator for passenger service so she is doing what she was originally built to do. I love "excuses" for pulling passenger trains whenever I can find them.

The model now has a Lionchief/Flyerchief GP7 board installed to replace the PS-1 electronics that, as I mentioned in a SWSAT post a few weeks ago, had been "fried" by the previous owner (and not mentioned by the seller). I'm working on a few "tweaks" under the hood that I think will assure long service life. I'll post the whole project on "Workbench" when I get done. Thanks to @RSJB18 for the idea of using these boards for switcher upgrades. BTW Bob, it's great when all of the functions available on the Lionchief board are already installed on the receiving loco!

Finally, here's my new cellphone with the LionChief app controlling the loco on idle:

20250302_044746

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 20250302_044619
  • 20250302_044640
  • 20250302_044746
Videos (1)
20250302_044338
Last edited by Bill Swatos
@Bill Swatos posted:

The model now has a Lionchief/Flyerchief GP7 board installed to replace the PS-1 electronics that, as I mentioned in a SWSAT post a few weeks ago, had been "fried" by the previous owner (and not mentioned by the seller). I'm working on a few "tweaks" under the hood that I think will assure long service life. I'll post the whole project on "Workbench" when I get done. Thanks to @RSJB18 for the idea of using these boards for switcher upgrades. BTW Bob, it's great when all of the functions available on the Lionchief board are already installed on the receiving loco!

Finally, here's my new cellphone with the LionChief app controlling the loco on idle:

20250302_044746

Looks and sounds great Bill. Yea- not having to do everything from scratch makes things simpler.

FYI- try the Cab 3 app. All the same functionality (and more) and the vertical screen makes is easier to navigate.

Bob

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×