Skip to main content

Welcome to Switcher Saturday!!

IMG_9414A weekly celebration of the little engines that CAN and DO all things railroading!

NOTE :  Since Monday is Veterans Day why not post some veteran themed switchers if you have them and if not .. noworries .. please post whatever switcher content you wish.  Thank you  to all who served!!  Your service is greatly appreciated!!

If you love those do all do anything locomotives that are the backbone of a railroad, you have clicked on THE thread that celebrates all things switching locomotives!   If you are new to this thread please consider posting a photo of your favorite switcher from your layout.  We'd love to see what you have!

A vast majority of us who frequent this thread love those small ( and not so small ) locomotives that can perform all the tasks given by any railroad.   Yep!  Switchers do it all ... switching in yards, at the point of way freights, industrial switching, switching at larger passenger stations, heading a MOW train ... including pushing snow plows, switching tight curvature on city streets & harbor areas, at the point of both commuter passenger trains and long distance passenger trains.  

Switcher Saturday  (SwSat)  welcomes  your photos, videos, and information/discussion  regarding switching  locomotives, steam, diesel, and electric  of all gauges and scales from Z - G  ... and even real life 1:1 scale too!  We'd be honored to have you join us by posting pics and videos of your switchers.  We'd also love reading any information regarding toy, model, or prototypical switchers.

I hope everyone had a great week!  It's been yet another busy week for me, but I do manage to get some layout work done daily even if only 10 minutes.  Got to keep the layout building muscle flexed .. lol!  

I'm looking forward to see what you all post.  SwSat is such a great thread for learning about switching locomotives.  So have at it everyone!  Post away!

REMEMBER to post only photos that you have personally taken.  IF you post someone else's photo, make sure you have their express written permission to post their photo.   Posting copy righted photos without permission is unlawful and you will be held legally liable.  Refer to the OGR Forum TOS for further details.  

This week on the Free State Junction Railway a B&O Fairbanks - Morse H-10-44 and a Canton Railway SW1500 team up pulling a short transfer job through Butler Junction.   At the moment the consist has stopped to change crews.  It seems the now off duty crew is somewhat sentimental as they face the consist as it runs by.  Both the H-10-44 and SW1500 are MTH PS 3 products.  I must say the H-10-44 has by far the best diesel engine sound on my roster !  

The B&O rostered about 6 FM H-10-44 locomotives.  H stands for high hood .. 10 stands for 1000 hp. ... 44 represents 4 axles, 4 powered axles.   The Canton Railroad is Baltimore's oldest railroad and operates in east Baltimore's Canton area serving industry and the docks.

IMG_5281

Virgil Banks, Flat Top Wiggins , and Manny Lucio just got off duty but seem to be a bit sentimental.   Turns out that Flat Top left a whole box of Krispy Cream Donuts behind in the cab of 9709.   Well too late now, the consist has started to move out.  I'm sure the new crew will be appreciative!  

IMG_5280

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_5281
  • IMG_5280
  • IMG_9414
Videos (1)
IMG_5265
Last edited by trumpettrain
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Happy Switcher Saturday! Thanks for running things Patrick.

Happy Veterans Day to all of our veterans!

I have not posted here lately with any new items. I've been dabbling lately with some HO purchases. One is a beautiful PRR B6sb that I bought off of eBay. It was built from a Bowser kit.

20241108_19154620241108_19112420241108_190900

Tom

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 20241108_191546
  • 20241108_191124
  • 20241108_190900
Last edited by PRR8976

The latest dent in my credit card was caused by an MTH Premier model (20-21845-1) of New Haven Railroad GE U25B #2507. MTH is doing an excellent job on its locomotives. The video shows the model running smoothly under conventional control at 10 scale miles-per-hour on my 10’-by-5’ layout. The diesel engine sounds are noticeably different than on MTH models of Alco locomotives.

The U25B was introduced in 1960 and had a 2,500 horsepower four-cycle V-16 diesel powerplant. Its weight was 252,000 pounds with a tractive effort of 75,000 pounds for starting and 64,000 pounds continuously. GE produced 478 U25B’s between 1959 and 1966. The New Haven ordered 10 U25Bs (class DERS-7) in 1964 at a cost of $170,068 each. They were known as “U-boats” and went into service on the New Haven’s Maybrook Line in October and November of 1964 running in three- and four-unit sets. Sixteen more were ordered a year later. Road numbers were 2500 to 2525 and referred to the 2500 horsepower rating. Road numbers 2500 to 2509 had a one-piece windshield and the others had a split windshield. The MTH model of #2507 has a split windshield that should be one-piece – but it’s otherwise accurate as far as I can see.  #2525 was the last locomotive built for the New Haven Railroad and is preserved at the Railroad Museum of New England/Naugatuck Railroad in Thomaston, CT.

I must also say that although this engine is technically a "road switcher," it really seems too large to meet @trumpettrain's description of "little engines that CAN and DO all things railroading!" But maybe it's OK for Switcher Saturday...

And thank you to all veterans who have worn the uniforms of the United States - including my father - a veteran of World War 2.

MELGAR

MELGAR2_2024_1104_06_NH_2507_10X5_BRIDGEMELGAR2_2024_1104_16_NH_2507_10X5_JCTMELGAR2_2024_1104_36_NH_2507_10X5_SOUTHMELGAR2_2024_1104_46_NH_2507_10X5_SOUTH_PORTALMELGAR2_2024_1104_55_NH_2507_10X5_TRESTLE

Attachments

Images (5)
  • MELGAR2_2024_1104_06_NH_2507_10X5_BRIDGE
  • MELGAR2_2024_1104_16_NH_2507_10X5_JCT
  • MELGAR2_2024_1104_36_NH_2507_10X5_SOUTH
  • MELGAR2_2024_1104_46_NH_2507_10X5_SOUTH_PORTAL
  • MELGAR2_2024_1104_55_NH_2507_10X5_TRESTLE
Videos (1)
MELGAR2_2024_1104_94V_NH_2507_10X5_BRIDGE_TUNNEL_48S
Last edited by MELGAR

Thanks for starting this weeks edition of this great thread Patrick.
In regard to your note about a military theme; I’m providing a link to my earlier post this week. https://ogrforum.com/topic/733...1#185988372774093571

Now I have another switcher. The Harlem Transfer Company Boxcab #2 was tagged to pickup this section of a circus train with an array of animals. Engineer Harold and Conductor Pete were very happy to pull this assignment. There will be a lot of down  time while the handlers take care of the animals. There is also a good probability of overtime. The first stop will be a siding where the handlers can close up the hatches before they go in the tunnel.

Attachments

Videos (2)
IMG_3609
IMG_3610
@pennsyfan posted:

Thanks for starting this weeks edition of this great thread Patrick.
In regard to your note about a military theme; I’m providing a link to my earlier post this week. https://ogrforum.com/topic/733...1#185988372774093571

Now I have another switcher. The Harlem Transfer Company Boxcab #2 was tagged to pickup this section of a circus train with an array of animals. Engineer Harold and Conductor Pete were very happy to pull this assignment. There will be a lot of down  time while the handlers take care of the animals. There is also a good probability of overtime. The first stop will be a siding where the handlers can close up the hatches before they go in the tunnel.

You gotta love those Giraffe cars!

Peter

One of my favorite railroads was the original Norfolk Southern.  They had an affinity with the last of the Baldwin road switchers.  The AS-16 was their 4 wheel truck version. Their AS-416 line was a 6 wheel truck, but only 4 wheels powered.  The last was the AS-616, with 6 powered wheels.  Norfolk Southern was the largest buyer of the AS-416 model.  They appreciated the relatively light weight and 6 wheel trucks that were more forgiving on the flat but sandy soil of their lines.

Railking made a couple of models of the AS-616 in Norfolk Southern paint. It’s not a 416, but very close in appearance. Already had the grey version but recently found the more colorful version .  

IMG_5598IMG_5597

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_5598
  • IMG_5597
Videos (1)
IMG_5553
Last edited by jstraw124

Good morning, SwSat nation!  A few years ago I decided to “fill a hole” in my collection by adding some Northern NE and  Canadian locomotives.  I added examples of Rutland, MEC, BAR and CP power, but lacked a Canadian National model.  Today I’m happy to say I’ve filled that “hole” with a new CN ALCO RS3 road switcher!

No.  3019 is a Williams model.  It has a nice level of detail I would call equivalent to my MTH ALCO RS1.  The “TrueBlast Plus” sound system isn’t up to Lionel and MTH standards, but good enough to enhance the operating experience for me.  It’s too bad Bachmann seems to be exiting the O gauge business (based on diminished model selection), because the latest Williams models are a great low cost alternative for conventional operators.

John

IMG_0776IMG_0775

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_0776
  • IMG_0775
Videos (2)
IMG_0774
IMG_0773

Happy SWSat!

Pulling from the archives once again this week. Been too busy and haven't had much train time. I have a bunch of new purchases to get unpacked too including my long awaited RMT LIRR Ore cars.

Two trips to Trainland in the past two weeks so I'm not complaining......

Since @Steam Crazy John, mentioned Williams/ WbB I'll share my two. They are a great value with nice details and sound. A crew in the cab too!  Even MTH doesn't put figures in their Railking diesels any more.  They have fixed pilots which is nice but not typical at this price point. The plastic handrails are my only complaint.

First up is my Rutland 70 ton. When I first saw them I didn't see a road name that I thought would fit my Northeast theme until I did a bit if research and found out that you can't get more northeast than Vermont!

2022-08-13 07.24.542022-08-13 07.21.06

And PRR 44 ton. I wanted a scale MTH PS model but the prices on them are crazy. This one fills the bill for it's scale size and details. I'm going to put a LionChief/BT board in this one (soon if I can clear my bench of the other 2 upgrades in the works).

2022-10-14 21.10.352022-11-12 08.18.07

Hope everyone has a great weekend.

Happy Veteran's Day to all the vets out there and thank you for your service.

Bob

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 2022-08-13 07.24.54
  • 2022-08-13 07.21.06
  • 2022-10-14 21.10.35
  • 2022-11-12 08.18.07

Well following @trumpetrain 's guidance, here are some "veteran" loco's in honor of Veterans' Day on Monday.  First a USAF RMT "BEEP" switcher with a flat car full of missiles and a tank car full of missile fuel.  They are on their way to McGuire AFB in New Jersey.  OBTW McGuire AFB - Ft. Dix - NAS Lakehurst are now administratively combined and the combination is considered a Joint Service Base, still all in central N.J.

Beep AF with Rockets

Here is a Navy BEEP switcher from Philadelphia Navy Yard, where they still keep parts of the "Ghost Fleet" ready for action that we all hope never comes.  She is pulling a Cessna 150 observation aircraft that will soon be in the air looking for targets, she will operate our of Naval Air Station Lakehurst in N.J.

Beep Navy with aircraft

Here is the Army, turbine powered switcher pulling a box car full of supplies for the troops.  Must be ammunition given the presence of the MP's guarding the train.  Their destination is Fort Dix, along with the other trains pictured here...all in N.J.

Army Switcher

OK but given the emphasis on our Military, we can't forget our Space Force...illustrated here with a NASA re-entry capsule just home from Orbit.

Astronaut Capsule at McD 2

Best Wishes and Happy Veterans Day to all my fellow Vet's and their families.

Don

Attachments

Images (4)
  • Beep AF with Rockets
  • Beep Navy with aircraft
  • Army Switcher
  • Astronaut Capsule at McD 2

Well following @trumpetrain 's guidance, here are some "veteran" loco's in honor of Veterans' Day on Monday.  First a USAF RMT "BEEP" switcher with a flat car full of missiles and a tank car full of missile fuel.  They are on their way to McGuire AFB in New Jersey.  OBTW McGuire AFB - Ft. Dix - NAS Lakehurst are now administratively combined and the combination is considered a Joint Service Base, still all in central N.J.

Beep AF with Rockets

Here is a Navy BEEP switcher from Philadelphia Navy Yard, where they still keep parts of the "Ghost Fleet" ready for action that we all hope never comes.  She is pulling a Cessna 150 observation aircraft that will soon be in the air looking for targets, she will operate our of Naval Air Station Lakehurst in N.J.

Beep Navy with aircraft

Here is the Army, turbine powered switcher pulling a box car full of supplies for the troops.  Must be ammunition given the presence of the MP's guarding the train.  Their destination is Fort Dix, along with the other trains pictured here...all in N.J.

Army Switcher

OK but given the emphasis on our Military, we can't forget our Space Force...illustrated here with a NASA re-entry capsule just home from Orbit.

Astronaut Capsule at McD 2

Best Wishes and Happy Veterans Day to all my fellow Vet's and their families.

Don

Well following @trumpetrain 's guidance, here are some "veteran" loco's in honor of Veterans' Day on Monday.  First a USAF RMT "BEEP" switcher with a flat car full of missiles and a tank car full of missile fuel.  They are on their way to McGuire AFB in New Jersey.  OBTW McGuire AFB - Ft. Dix - NAS Lakehurst are now administratively combined and the combination is considered a Joint Service Base, still all in central N.J.

Beep AF with Rockets

Here is a Navy BEEP switcher from Philadelphia Navy Yard, where they still keep parts of the "Ghost Fleet" ready for action that we all hope never comes.  She is pulling a Cessna 150 observation aircraft that will soon be in the air looking for targets, she will operate our of Naval Air Station Lakehurst in N.J.

Beep Navy with aircraft

Here is the Army, turbine powered switcher pulling a box car full of supplies for the troops.  Must be ammunition given the presence of the MP's guarding the train.  Their destination is Fort Dix, along with the other trains pictured here...all in N.J.

Army Switcher

OK but given the emphasis on our Military, we can't forget our Space Force...illustrated here with a NASA re-entry capsule just home from Orbit.

Astronaut Capsule at McD 2

Best Wishes and Happy Veterans Day to all my fellow Vet's and their families.

Don

Nicely done Don.

@RayKay posted:

Happy Switch Sat!

Today I have a K line B7A 4-6-6T Tank Engine, I know that they were used mostly for commuter trains, but I'm told they did some switching.  If anyone can confirm that and or any other history I would appreciate it.

Thanks and Take care, Ray

11 09 015


@RayKay,

I don’t know the answer to your question about switching, but here is some additional information:

The Boston & Albany 4-6-6T tank engines were Class D-1a.

In 1928, Alco built five D-1a 4-6-6T bi-directional steam locomotives (road numbers 400 to 404) for the Boston & Albany Railroad to use in commuter service around Boston. These engines ran in a circuit – outbound on the main line to Riverside, inbound on the Highland Branch back to South Station, and also in the reverse direction. Since they were double-ended, it was unnecessary to turn them before the next run.

The first O gauge model, with road number 403, was made by K-Line in 2005. The tooling was later acquired by Lionel, and a Legacy version with road number 400 was produced in 2020.

The D-1a tank engines had 63-inch drivers, ran at 215 psi boiler pressure, weighed 352,000 pounds, and developed 41,600 pounds of tractive effort. They were the largest tank engines ever to run in the United States and were designed for rapid acceleration. Their tractive effort was almost equal to that of a Boston & Albany 4-6-2 Pacific. They were retired in 1951.

MELGAR

MELGAR2_2024_0529_06_B&A_400_12X8

Attachments

Images (1)
  • MELGAR2_2024_0529_06_B&A_400_12X8
Last edited by MELGAR
@MELGAR posted:

@RayKay,

I don’t know the answer to your question about switching, but here is some additional information:

The Boston & Albany 4-6-6T tank engines were Class D-1a.

In 1928, Alco built five D-1a 4-6-6T bi-directional steam locomotives (road numbers 400 to 404) for the Boston & Albany Railroad to use in commuter service around Boston. These engines ran in a circuit – outbound on the main line to Riverside, inbound on the Highland Branch back to South Station, and also in the reverse direction. Since they were double-ended, it was unnecessary to turn them before the next run.

The first O gauge model, with road number 403, was made by K-Line in 2005. The tooling was later acquired by Lionel, and a Legacy version with road number 400 was produced in 2020.

The D-1a tank engines had 63-inch drivers, ran at 215 psi boiler pressure, weighed 352,000 pounds, and developed 41,600 pounds of tractive effort. They were the largest tank engines ever to run in the United States and were designed for rapid acceleration. Their tractive effort was almost equal to that of a Boston & Albany 4-6-2 Pacific. They were retired in 1951.

MELGAR

MELGAR2_2024_0529_06_B&A_400_12X8

MELGAR, thanks for the info.

Thanks Patrick for opening us up on the Veterans' Day theme for this SWSAT. For this special SWSAT Sunday Supplement, then, here are a couple of my favorites, proudly representing the US Army Transportation Corps. First , of course, is Lionel's venerable PW version of the experimental Davenport gas turbine switcher that served on the Army's Fort Eustis, VA base:

20241110_014503

Next is Lionel's latest edition of their Sperry speeder:

20241110_014542

Here's that speeder zipping around under conventional power:

And now, after the boys on the Fort Eustis base made a few tweaks to those 175 hp Boeing 502E turbines, the Davenport's doing a big job:

Never underestimate the US Army! Thanks to all veterans in all our armed forces who've served to keep us and the world safe for freedom and democracy!

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20241110_014503
  • 20241110_014542
Videos (2)
20241110_013659
20241110_015228
@MELGAR posted:

@RayKay,

I don’t know the answer to your question about switching, but here is some addition information

The Boston & Albany 4-6-6T tank engines were Class D-1a.

In 1928, Alco built five D-1a 4-6-6T bi-directional steam locomotives (road numbers 400 to 404) for the Boston & Albany Railroad to use in commuter service around Boston. These engines ran in a circuit – outbound on the main line to Riverside, inbound on the Highland Branch back to South Station, and also in the reverse direction. Since they were double-ended, it was unnecessary to turn them before the next run.

The first O gauge model, with road number 403, was made by K-Line in 2005. The tooling was later acquired by Lionel, and a Legacy version with road number 400 was produced in 2020.

The D-1a tank engines had 63-inch drivers, ran at 215 psi boiler pressure, weighed 352,000 pounds, and developed 41,600 pounds of tractive effort. They were the largest tank engines ever to run in the United States and were designed for rapid acceleration. Their tractive effort was almost equal to that of a Boston & Albany 4-6-2 Pacific. They were retired in 1951.

MELGAR

MELGAR2_2024_0529_06_B&A_400_12X8

Mel - as this question will demonstrate, my knowledge of 1’ : 1’ operations is less than minimal, but I’m assuming (insert ***-u-me here) that these locos used a run-round loop (aka headshunt*) to return to the “head” of the now outbound train? That the entire train wasn’t pushed by a loco in the rear, operated in reverse, the entire reverse trip distance?

Heber Valley Scenic RR uses a run-round loop on their excursion train.

*there is a picture of, and a written step by step description, on Wikiwand of how a headshunt operates. I couldn’t drop a link here.

Last edited by Mark V. Spadaro

I've gotten side tracked trying to better consolidate my rolling stock into cases of the same road name so the 4x8 is still consumed by intermodal so I have no military train to honor our vets but I will make certain to fly my flag in their honor tomorrow.  Thanks to all here that have served our great country.

@trumpettrain, Patrick Thank you for keeping this wonderful thread running down the tracks every week.

@PRR8976, Tom that HO switcher is a beauty.

@MELGAR, Mel a post full of information as usual.  Do you research an engine's prototype before you buy or do you buy because you're attracted to the model and then do the research to see how the model stacks up to the prototype?

@Don McErlean,  you're correct about McGuire Air Force Base, it's now Joint Base MDL.  My daughter spent two years checking IDs at the gate.  Her second post in the USAF.  Coming from Long Island she was originally excited to be so close to home, I believe it was NYC not Massapequa, that she was excited about, but in the long run I believe that duty is what made her a one and done without re-enlisting because she has contemplated returning to Kuwait, Ali Al Salam was her last post, as a contractor.

Wonderful photos, videos, and information everyone!  Lots of Veteran's Day salutes with switchers and critters from various branches of the military.  Unfortunately I don't have any military locomotives but just this moment realized that in my home state of Maryland Ft. George G. Meade and Aberdeen Proving Grounds each had their own on base trackage!  I remember seeing GP 7 or 9 locomotives at the Proving Grounds and a center cab ( probably a 70 ton ) at Ft. Meade.   Hmmm .. perhaps I'm not yet finished with representing all of Maryland's Transition era railroads on my layout   Keep the content coming everyone!!  The switcher party continues all week long!  

I posted this photo on the  2024 Memorial Day Weekend edition of SwSat.  Although it shows Navy personnel in the photo, my gratitude goes out to all who served in all the branches of the military.  

IMG_4143

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_4143
Last edited by trumpettrain
@coach joe posted:


@MELGAR, Mel a post full of information as usual.  Do you research an engine's prototype before you buy or do you buy because you're attracted to the model and then do the research to see how the model stacks up to the prototype?

Joe,

Years ago, I began to focus on five railroads - New Haven, New York Central, Boston & Albany, Boston & Maine, and Long Island - so I'm familiar with the types of engines and rolling stock they had, and I buy whatever is prototypical or close. But, to answer your question, yes, I consult my large library of railroad books before I buy anything. If a model isn't close to prototype, I don't buy it. An example is Lionel's recent offering of "New Haven" 4-4-2 Atlantic steamer #1111 with Legacy (SKU: 2231420). The model didn't look anything like the picture of the real #1111 in "New Haven Power 1838-1968", so I didn't buy. And I would certainly like to have a model of a New Haven 4-4-2.

MELGAR

Mel - as this question will demonstrate, my knowledge of 1’ : 1’ operations is less than minimal, but I’m assuming (insert ***-u-me here) that these locos used a run-round loop (aka headshunt*) to return to the “head” of the now outbound train? That the entire train wasn’t pushed by a loco in the rear, operated in reverse, the entire reverse trip distance?

The B&A 4-6-6T tank engines were designed to operate equally well in reverse and forward in mainline commuter operations around Boston. The commuter zone ran between Boston South Station and Riverside (about 10 miles) and there likely were “run-around” tracks at both locations. However, I’ve never seen a photo showing one of these engines pulling a train in reverse.

The running gear of reciprocating steam locomotives theoretically can be operated at speed in either direction, as demonstrated by Southern Pacific’s cab-forward 4-8-8-2 locomotives, in part because steam is admitted alternately to both sides of each piston. One reason it wasn’t done with conventional engine/tender steam locomotives was rearward track visibility for the engineer.

Rear views of my K-Line model of B&A #403 show provisions to facilitate operation in reverse. There are marker lights, a pilot (cowcatcher), and a headlight at the rear of the locomotive, in addition to rear-facing cab windows and a narrow coal bin.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2024_1110_02_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLYMELGAR_2024_1110_03_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLYMELGAR_2024_1110_04_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLYMELGAR_2024_1110_06_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLYMELGAR_2024_1110_07_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY

Attachments

Images (5)
  • MELGAR_2024_1110_02_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY
  • MELGAR_2024_1110_03_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY
  • MELGAR_2024_1110_04_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY
  • MELGAR_2024_1110_06_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY
  • MELGAR_2024_1110_07_B&A_403_SWSAT_REPLY
Last edited by MELGAR
@Steam Crazy posted:

MELGAR, an engine that "isn't close to prototype" can still be fun to own and run, particularly if it's really good looking and has nice features.  I offer my Lionel MEC GP7 as an example.  Just sayin...

John

John,

Undoubtedly true. But model railroaders, especially in 2-rail and HO, differ in the level of realism they expect in their models compared to O gaugers. I'm neither of those but I prefer a model that looks close to the real thing...

One of the things I do when I acquire a new model is to compare it to a photo of the prototype. Just curiosity I guess.

MELGAR

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×