So if I were looking for a K4, in semi-scale ( A whole 'mother subject already discussed elsewhere ) what would I look for. Basically, I would like to find one, manufacturer doesn't matter, that looks right with Lionel's GG1, the semi-scale or traditional version, whichever you prefer.
It doesn't have to be new. It has to be able to run on a conventional layout. And last but not least, it can't break the bank.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
You have to be careful with this choice there are some locomotives in semi-scale that are called k4 and some that actually look and correctly labeled k4.
The Railking K4 is a winner.
rex desilets posted:The Railking K4 is a winner.
I'll second that advice.
Be aware that, like other Pacifics, a K4 is not a huge locomotive. A scale K4 will look at home with some post war or traditional sized equipment like Irvington/Madison cars. You can read up on the MTH, Lionel, K-Line and K-Line derived Lionel K4s here:
Thanks Ted, that was interesting reading along with fine photography.
Weaver had done a K4 some time ago. I have a Lionel K4 from around 2003.
Ted Hikel posted:rex desilets posted:The Railking K4 is a winner.
I'll second that advice.
Be aware that, like other Pacifics, a K4 is not a huge locomotive. A scale K4 will look at home with some post war or traditional sized equipment like Irvington/Madison cars. You can read up on the MTH, Lionel, K-Line and K-Line derived Lionel K4s here:
And I will second Ted's advice. I currently have an MTH Premier K4 running on my Christmas layout pulling a non scale Christmas consist. It looks fine to me. My Premier Reading T1 looks a bit out of place with the same consist. The consist is all modern though (LTI and newer).
This photo is not the quality of some but it gets the point across.
Tony
This is the Rail King K4s, and it is a low cost great runner with PS2. Running in the conventional mode, the Rail King K4s will give you many of the PS2 / PS3 features including sounds, smoke, and remote rear coupler operation.
I had the PS2 RK Imperial K4. Sold it on the forum but wish I kept it (needed the $$$ at the time). Super nice engine.
If you can find the Imperial RK K4 from 2011/2012 or so, consider jumping on it.
If complete accuracy and extra details aren't a "must-have" for you, consider a Postwar 2025/675/etc. It is a 2-6-2 but has the K4 look. I bought one, in beautiful condition, for about $160. Runs like a Swiss watch!
For semi-scale (like the GG1), why not the postwar Lionel 675. You can get a nice one for about $150. Mine has been chugging smoke for many years, and is currently under the tree. I have it pulling the MTH Rail King Madison cars (detailed interiors that hold the passengers that I added).
Joe Hohmann posted:For semi-scale (like the GG1), why not the postwar Lionel 675. You can get a nice one for about $150. Mine has been chugging smoke for many years, and is currently under the tree. I have it pulling the MTH Rail King Madison cars (detailed interiors that hold the passengers that I added).
I'm giving that option serious consideration, Joe.
rex desilets posted:The Railking K4 is a winner.
I have two....VERY NICE.......gets my vote.
Access to this requires an OGR Forum Supporting Membership
