Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

D&H Alcos from 1972 detailed:


Here's a catalog image of what they looked like originally:


The catalog shows a front coupler and cutout pilot, but they were produced with the closed pilot as you see in the top photo, so the shell is unmodified. Just paint detail and the horn swapped to a 5-chime passenger horn.

-Eric
quote:
Originally posted by EricF:
D&H Alcos from 1972 detailed:


Here's a catalog image of what they looked like originally:


The catalog shows a front coupler and cutout pilot, but they were produced with the closed pilot as you see in the top photo, so the shell is unmodified. Just paint detail and the horn swapped to a 5-chime passenger horn.

-Eric


I was hoping the D&H might appear..
Here are my namesakes:

This picture is from Christmas 2009. The yellow UP set I remember receiving for Christmas 1951. I have the original boxs/carton.

The street cars are Pacific Electric and Pittsburgh Railways. Both are PS1. I like PCC cars and found the PE at my LHS. I later found out there were Pittsburgh RR Big Reds available since I grew up in Pittsburghs south hills, Upper St Clair to be exact.

This is from 2010, I had just finished repainting the cab shells and rebuilding the locomotive and dummy as they were in bad condition. The dummy shell is actually a brand new shell purchased form Olsons as a Madison Hardware part. The engines are part of the freight set which I received the Christmas before I received the yellow set, so that would have been December 1950.



In the late '60s my sister wanted her train (a prewar 224E freight train) for her kids, so I took it from my parents' house to hers and they set it up. It quit on her, so I took the silver freight over and they ran that for a bunch of years. When I bought a house in California in 1978, my parents wanted to know if I wanted the yellow one and I said yes. My sister aksed if I wanted her train and my silver UP and I said yes. The UP arrived with a battery leaking inside, cracked shells, badly scratched, E-unit and horn relay wires corroded and inoperable. When I pulle all the parts out that I had stored in a shoe box since 1980-81 I found I had ordered parts from Madison Hardware as well as purchased some from Lee's in Oakland, CA. The above picture is soon after the first run since before 1981.

For you other Nittany Lion(el) fans, I also bleed blue and white, 69 ME. Ed G.
Anyone have photos of the numerous Williams 'Golden Memories' Alcos? These are faithful replicas of the handsome early PW Lionels before they cheapened them and (IMO) ruined the brawny look with the 'sheet metal lip' highly visible along the sides.
Even the Kusans are better models...
Ginsaw, I think one of the attractions of the Alcos is the fact that they are NOT scale size and fit in better with most Lionel equipment of that era better than the F3's, which tend to look out of place with most of the other, less-than-sacle stuff. The Marx no. 21 metal AT&SF diesels have the same problem, dwarfing all the other Marx equipment.
quote:
Originally posted by Jim Tighe:
Ginsaw, I think one of the attractions of the Alcos is the fact that they are NOT scale size and fit in better with most Lionel equipment of that era better than the F3's, which tend to look out of place with most of the other, less-than-sacle stuff. The Marx no. 21 metal AT&SF diesels have the same problem, dwarfing all the other Marx equipment.


Bingo
In the '50s Lionel was at a fork in the road on what size to make its trains. So they went both routes at the same time, with the F3s (and SWs and FMs) in one direction and the Alcos the other way as the flagship of the 027 line.

As between the F3s and the little Alcos I don't think we'll disagree on which became more popular.

They apparently thought the F3 was better looking or they would have reversed the order. Or maybe the prototype roads or manufacturers had a say. Or maybe they didn't think the F3 suitable for a slotted pilot. Who knows.

But, the one that was built to scale size in fact became the defining feature of Lionel in the '50s on through today. Largely because they WERE proper size.

Btw, there's a 1953 catalog pic showing three diesels. NYC F3 in front, Western Pacific F3 in the middle and just enough of a third one in the back to see the word "Rock" and get a look at the trucks. As a child I was very intrigued with that ad and at the time wished they had a full size CRI&P diesel. I would certainly have pressured Santa to leave one off under our tree.
quote:
Ginsaw, I think one of the attractions of the Alcos is the fact that they are NOT scale size and fit in better with most Lionel equipment of that era better than the F3's, which tend to look out of place with most of the other, less-than-scale stuff. The Marx no. 21 metal AT&SF diesels have the same problem, dwarfing all the other Marx equipment.


Spot on.
Another reason I prefer the Alcos to the F3's is that the overall shape of the Alcos is correct, even tho less than scale size. The "face" of the F3, however, does not accurately follow the contours of the real thing. The only real knock on the Alcos is the truck side frames, which are the switcher variety, with solid bearings, not rollers. But that is a minor quibble. Overall, I think those original Lionel Alcos of 1950 are still just about the nicest toy train Diesels of them all.
I have seven different Williams 0-27 Alcos:
Santa Fe
Missouri Pacific
Northern Pacific
Rock Island
Union Pacific Silver Streak
Erie
Nickel Plate Road
The addition of the MRC 1815 AC Diesel Sounder to the dummy makes them a really nice unit. Two have been installed so far. I am looking for both the Florida East AA and the Gulf Mobile & Ohio, both produced a few years ago by Williams. Will "advertise" on the ORG wanted.
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×