Skip to main content

Hi,

I just started in s scale and bought a UP SD70ace. The electro couplers don't open enough to uncouple from the cars. Is there any mods to fix this or am I just out of luck. The loco is so nice, I hope this can be fixed. I got out of o scale because of the size and s is perfect for the room I have.

 

Mike

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The "O" Gauge guys have more experience with this than we do. You might look for discussions of similar problems in the "O" forum, or in the TMCC/Legacy forum.

 

Here's one thread that might be worth a read:

 

https://ogrforum.com/t...66#18605835807329166

 

Also, a similar question was posed in an earlier issue of CTT:

 

http://cs.trains.com/ctt/f/95/p/32801/421110.aspx

 

And, if there's any question about your power source, a quick view of the wave form discussion (which addresses electro coupler operation) might be of value:

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMR25JoCZiU

 

Good luck with your problem. Be sure to post any resolution so the rest of us can leverage off of your pain.

Last edited by Craig Donath
Originally Posted by MikeMos:

Hi,

I just started in s scale and bought a UP SD70ace. The electro couplers don't open enough to uncouple from the cars. Is there any mods to fix this or am I just out of luck. The loco is so nice, I hope this can be fixed. I got out of o scale because of the size and s is perfect for the room I have.

 

Mike,

You might try contacting Carl Tuveson, very knowledgeable in S and a very helpful person. If you don't find it with Carl it may not exist. I believe you can find his email in the members info, if not put "Carl's S gauge empire" into your browser.

Ray 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Mike

 

Just my opinion here, but this isn't an electrical issue to me. I have an SD70ACe, + the scale Mikado and two scale Pacifics + one U33C of "Modern" vintage. None of these couplers open as far as A. C. Gilbert production couplers; i.e. the knuckle travel arc is smaller than Postwar Gilbert's. 

This really should be addressed by Lionel as the locomotive and rolling stock couplers are all afflicted with this issue -again "in my opinion".

A word of warning for you MSTJ Ham; I elected to install Kadees on my SD70ACe, when I went to remove the electro-couplers, I found I could not get the front one to budge. Yes, I do have the correct screwdriver head for these screws, but to date I have not been able to budge the screw without worrying about buggering up the screw-head completely. At least I was able to remove the rear one which allows operation with my rolling stock.

For some reason, the Chinese insist on installing some screws at 400 foot #s of torque or using thread locker where it is not needed or using the wrong type for the intended application. I wish Lionel would address that issue as well.

Lionel always recommends puffing some dry graphite into the coupler mechanism and on the knuckle hinge. Don't know if it helps.

It could be paint or minor fitment issues with the knuckle or the locking armature.

 

banjoflyer is on to some solutions.

 

It may be a simple fix. if you are moving the engine away at 1mph restricted speed, like a real train has to do, it may be enough when you fire the coupler to separate. It needs room to swing. Opposite of moving in to force it to close, pull it open.

Hello,

I followed banjoflyer's suggestion and filed the coupler. I used a small file and took off about a 1/32 to a 1/16 off of the operating part of coupler. I did a little at a time and tested. The coupler works as good as my o gauge couplers. I'm so happy with it now. i'm using american models freight cars. I noticed the couplers on these cars are not as open as american flyer cars. I used some needle nose pliers and opened them a little. I can uncouple one car anywhere on the layout now, even on the fly. All I will say is, be really careful with the couplers. They are not very forgiving. If you put to much force on them they will break. I'm not going to pay for your couplers, LOL. I might start selling my o gauge trains now and buy more s. Thank you all for your suggestions.

 

Happy Holidays,

Mike

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×