Skip to main content

Hi guys, I'm thinking of getting one these loco's that was released recently, I think last year. I did a search on here and cant find any info on it. I'm just curious if any of you have one. Its Pennsy so I think one of you guys have to have one..If you have one tell me your opinions either way.. Thanks!!

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The Lionel Pennsylvania GP9 #7006 and 7048 are nice running engines. Be careful removing the engine from the cradle. They do not use ribbons for lifting because of the roof antennae. ( I carefully tilted my engines forward, out of the cradle.) The sounds are good, but the horn has a twang to it (that sounds like a single bell clang) when given a full blast on the 990 Remote.  Soft approaches to the horn do not have the bell clang sound.  Lionel says the sound file for the horn has a "chirp to it", common to the actual horn. 

I have both numbers. for the $$, IMHO it's not worth it.  For a true PRR fan, there are many incorrect details that cannot be fixed because the "crew Talk" will always refer to the original factory road number.

HEre are some of the issure I have with it:

  • incorrect "western " gp9 locomotive plate on front of loco- correct for cxb&Q, DRGW, and the other raod names but not the PRR.

Lionel_GP9-Legacy7

  • dangling air tanks by the fuel tank. This is unwarranted considering Lionel got it right with the GP7 a few years ago.

Lionel_GP9-Legacy2

  • speaking of Fuel tanks, Lionel used the incorrect Phase II fuel tank [shortened side skirts and fuel filler on opposite side of tank] with Phase 1 road numbers. The Fuel filler s/b between the air tanks and the fuel tank, not the fuel tank end underneath the loco cab! [ see pics below]

Lionel_GP9-Legacy6Lionel_GP9-Legacy4Lionel_GP9-Legacy5

  • Finally as seen above, the PRR trainphone antenna connection was on the front or long hood of the loco. Lionel made their cheapie Trainphone connection incorrectly on the High short hood [see below]
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy3Lionel_GP9-Legacy7Lionel_GP9-Legacy8

Well the choice is yours, If the above details don't bother you  for the price that you are paying [ hopefully way under MSRP or BTO pre- order price] and you love the legacy electronics the go for it. If you are paying top dollar, I would say no.

Note : MTH recently came out with similar Railking GP9's. The MTH RK versions have PS3 and the incorrect builders plate and no trainphone antenna, BUT they also don't have crew talk that announces the road number AND the CORRECT fuel tank! For the RK price, you can FIX the minor decrepencies [ add a Cal Scale brass Trainphone antenna, add marker lights, and wipe out the pad printed builders plate] to have a correct PRR GP9 for a more resonable price.

 

Attachments

Images (8)
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy7
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy2
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy6
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy4
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy5
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy3
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy7
  • Lionel_GP9-Legacy8
Last edited by prrhorseshoecurve

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×