Skip to main content

Howdy, all

 

I have been seeing the ads for Modelcrafters military trains in the mags for awhile now.  And I see that they even had a little feature blurb in the January issue.

 

I searched the forum to see if anyone else has any experience with this vendor, but I didn't find anything (other than another member asking this same exact question, but with no responses).

 

Has anyone purchased one of these? They are pricey.  But they really look amazing on the website.  Are they worth it?

 

Are they diecast models? Or just painted plastic hobby store models? Are they 1/48?

 

I am tempted to purchase, but I'd love to hear from someone first before I shell out so much of my precious green stuff.

 

- timbo

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Thank, Allan.
 
That's actually my concern, as well.  I have painted a couple of flats and added hobby store plastic models that I have attempted to make authentic looking (my painting and weathering skills are juvenile at best).  These will certainly outshine anything I have now if the pictures in the magazine do them justice.
 
I am glad to have your positive review.
 
Now which one(s) to buy... holy cow they have a lot of beautiful stock.
 
- timbo

I had a couple of their older cars that I purchased on ebay about 8 years ago.  The tank and truck on my flatcar were weathered Corgi die-cast models.  The boxcar was a traditional sized Lionel boxcar.

 

I will say that the paint and weathering on the cars were excellent.   If you have the cash, they are beautiful models.  Other alternatives would be to make your own flatcars.   Both Corgi and Solido make very nice diecast models and there are several manufacturers of 1/48 plastic models.

 

While the army flatcars are cool, I believe that most equipment would have been transported on regular railroad flatcars.

 

Jim

Originally Posted by jd-train:

I had a couple of their older cars that I purchased on ebay about 8 years ago.  The tank and truck on my flatcar were weathered Corgi die-cast models.  The boxcar was a traditional sized Lionel boxcar.

 

I will say that the paint and weathering on the cars were excellent.   If you have the cash, they are beautiful models.  Other alternatives would be to make your own flatcars.   Both Corgi and Solido make very nice diecast models and there are several manufacturers of 1/48 plastic models.

 

While the army flatcars are cool, I believe that most equipment would have been transported on regular railroad flatcars.

 

Jim

Yep, the Military grabbed whatever is flat and rolls.

 

World War two had this, flats of all kinds, all road names and all conditions.

 

I personally witnessed hundreds of empty flats in 2003 prior to and during the Invasion of Iraq screeching and squealing at top speed through town. Some were nothing more than rust buckets. Others were new and a few DOD flats dug up from who knows where too.

 

Flats were only part of the puzzle the military used.

 

They used Volume above the deck as well. Stuffing it with say.. a 3 axle truck and 6 single axle trailers stacked on top of each other. As much as they could get it to fit their bridges and tunnels.

I made all but three of the 18 flatcars I used on my military train, buying Corgi and such diecast tanks, artillery and vehicles.  I bought 36 Atlas trucks with couplers in bulk at a big discount and mounted them on flatcar "bodies" I cut from 1/4" plywood planked with wood strips meant for model sailing ship models, etc., and detailed.  They looked good but definately not weathered and as accurately detailed as some of their that I've seen. 

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×