Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Very disappointing, can you say been there done that.  NYC Mohawks again when I'm trying to sell mine(thanks MTH), and they don't even bother to do one with roller bearings.  And before Hot Water comments, they only did the Mohawk with roller bearings in scale wheels from the last run in 2009.  Plus more challengers, didn't they just do one not to long ago?

Guess they will sell but with a seen that before, nothing new for me. the Wallet is safe until the next catalog.

superwarp1 posted:

Very disappointing, can you say been there done that.  NYC Mohawks again when I'm trying to sell mine(thanks MTH), and they don't even bother to do one with roller bearings.  And before Hot Water comments, they only did the Mohawk with roller bearings in scale wheels from the last run in 2009.  Plus more challengers, didn't they just do one not to long ago?

Guess they will sell but with a seen that before, nothing new for me. the Wallet is safe until the next catalog.

The New York Central had only two Mohawks with roller bearing rods. How many models of #3144 and #3148 do you think MTH can sell?

For me, I did a few items interesting. The Railking First Responders Action Car, the GN R-2, maybe BL-2, SF or Citirail ES44AC, maybe the U50C, some premiere First Responders Cars, maybe the depressed flatcar with Crane. Defentiely the NS Intermodal with 2 20' Containers - 20-95224. Also maybe the TTX Flat with 3 Maersk Containers. Also I do like the LED Christmas Lights on some the buildings. Anyway, I probably will not buy all of it. But actually this catalog in my opinion is the best in a few years.

I understand that MTH has a business to run and they should absolutely do what's best for their success, but as a customer it is really hard not to wonder what is going on.  This catalog brings nothing that moves the needle for me personally. I purchase O, S, and HO from MTH and unfortunately they have disappointed me in all 3 scales.

I wish I could say otherwise.

Thank you for the link

Not much for me either.  Mel's diner sign is a "must have" for those that have the Mel's diner. 

the different 44T phase bodies is a unique twist

Looks like MTH invested in a 2 rail scaletrax. I wonder how many 2 railers will go for that.

MTH is rehashing the autorack but with the same old paint schemes already done.... man there are a LOT more schemes out there to be done!

 

Interesting catalog...

My thoughts: Great news here: I can pic up a Aux. Tender that I missed out on... WTW? 250?

 

TENDER

These are cool- can add them to my Shay consist!

OLD CARS

Ha- Ha... these are funny...

CROSS

I like these...

CAB FORW

Nice F3's but another war bonnet? !!

F3

These will sell.

44TON

And these too... very cool!

 

BL2

I always liked the GN R-2...

 

GN 2882

These are nice ... me likey!

 

MOHAWK

Now here shows some initiative! Give them your room dimensions and they have a layout already designed... with a complete track package!

 

TRAX PACKAGE

AH NUTS! Where where was this track when I needed it! Well I am not tearing out the Atlas, Gargraves, and Ross!

 

SCALE TRAX

WOW! Now this is cool... Being a slobbering Milwaukee freak! Nice!

 

EF MIL

No. No. No... no more UP U50C's or UP Sperry track inspection cars... I have them already! I guess if you don't have one they are very cool.

U50C

 

Not a bad catalog. Something for everyone... I wonder what the Cab forwards sound like?

Attachments

Images (13)
  • TENDER
  • OLD CARS
  • CROSS
  • CAB FORW
  • F3
  • 44TON
  • BL2
  • GN 2882
  • MOHAWK
  • TRAX PACKAGE
  • SCALE TRAX
  • EF MIL
  • U50C
prrhorseshoecurve posted:

Thank you for the link

Not much for me either.  Mel's diner sign is a "must have" for those that have the Mel's diner. 

the different 44T phase bodies is a unique twist

Looks like MTH invested in a 2 rail scaletrax. I wonder how many 2 railers will go for that.

MTH is rehashing the autorack but with the same old paint schemes already done.... man there are a LOT more schemes out there to be done!

 

Just FYI... They announced 2 rail Scaletrax a couple years ago. They also said they won't be doing turnouts. So my guess is not many 2 railers (including me) are interested.

Welp, I think I have to sell the house...

I hope to get: 

2 Amtrak Wave P42 and the Veterans, CitiRail ES44, Amtrak Phase 3 Mail Car, ALL the husky stacks,  CSX TTX flat car to go with the safety train, A bunch of the amtrak corrugated autoracks, for an auto train, a gondola, 4 pack of amtrak passenger cars, and maybe the MTBA Genset. Probably the best MTH catalogue I have ever seen. 

Also, did anyone else notice the missing number board in the veterans SD60E?Screen Shot 2016-10-19 at 12.02.59 PM

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Screen Shot 2016-10-19 at 12.02.59 PM

MTH listens!  I'm not going to say it was all me, but when Mike Wolfe was at my LHS I stopped in.  They were basically trying to sell the Wi-Fi stuff, not my cup of tea so I was chatting up the LHS owner.  I noticed his K-Line SP bay window caboose and remember that MTH has never made one in the brown and yellow.  So I went up to Mr. Wolfe and pointed that out to him.  He took paper out of his pocket and wrote that down.  Now there is one in the latest catalog!!  I'll be stopping by the LHS to order one for sure this week.

NJCJOE posted:

Do the 44 tonners come with smoke? The picture shows smoke but there is mo mention of it in the description.

Hi Joe,

I'm pretty sure they do not have smoke due to space limitations.   I have one on pre-order from my LHS and will get next week after I return from York.   My LHS is at York so I'll found out them when I can take delivery     My point is that if no one confirms with you by then, hit me up via email in my profile and I'll be glad to tell you.

-Greg

 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×