Skip to main content

I think I already know the answer to this one however I though I'd ask that group with they thought. I have a Heisler Log Train Set 6-83553. I went to run it the other day and it started smoking. Taking it apart showed the motor smoking. I'm guessing that I'll have to replace the motor but I figured I'd ask you guys first.20200315_174445 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 20200315_174445
Videos (1)
20200315_174415
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

That is what Electrical Engineers call "magic smoke". You've let the magic smoke out. Time for a new motor. Before you just randomly pop a new part in there, make sure nothing else is wrong.

The first thing I would do is take the motor out and make sure everything turns smoothly and easily.  Look at the bright side. At least it wasn't a 13.2Kv 3000 HP motor with a six month lead time! That's like watching someone pushing your new Corvette off a cliff.

Last edited by Gilly@N&W

Not to be a panic merchant but about halfway through the video I thought I saw either sparking or a flame inside that motor - through the oval opening on the side. I think that the smoke volume is too much to be smoke fluid residue. I can't guess what failure would produce the effects you can see but I would rather replace the motor before it damages anything else - on the engine or anywhere else.

Hancock52 posted:

Not to be a panic merchant but about halfway through the video I thought I saw either sparking or a flame inside that motor - through the oval opening on the side. I think that the smoke volume is too much to be smoke fluid residue. I can't guess what failure would produce the effects you can see but I would rather replace the motor before it damages anything else - on the engine or anywhere else.

I plan on replacing the motor. The question is what caused it to fail? Smoke fluid, overload or just bad motor? I'll be taking the motor out to check for any binding in the drive train but it was running smooth when I parked it a couple of weeks ago.

I've seen motors smoke like this, in all cases it was the windings drawing excessive current and cooking the insulation.  One was the bearings seized up, the other one I suspect was stalled before it was sent to me.  For some odd reason, I've also had several Williams steam locomotives come to me with motors that drew amps of current with no load, clearly those had to be replaced as well.  I didn't wait for them to smoke, but I'm sure they would with extended running!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×