Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I know Scott reads these threads - it would be nice to know why Sunset chose a tank drive for O scale.    Seems like a backwards step.   And yes, I know some C&LS tank drives run flawlessly but it still seems like a backwards step in a scale where accuracy and fidelity really can shine.

I can see keeping the space inside the carbody open for electronics but this trades off one good for another evil.

Available interior space is one reason.  Key also uses tank drives for all it's diesels.  Key does it so they can put an entire interior in each unit.  Tank drives do disallow using the tank for a speaker and the shafts are visible but they do take up the least amount of space internally.  They are also simpler and easier to maintain than internal shaft drives.  Midwestern uses an internal drive with the shafts lowered to right along the chassis as a compromise but they make it very clear if you do any maintenance or disassembly, whatsoever, of the drive the warranty is void.

Don't get me wrong I'm not a big fan of tank drives either.  My personal preference would be the Magic Carpet type drives in the trucks.  But the available motor torque and the resultant gearing down is just a maintenance trap in the making for that alternative.  I actually swore off of tank drives until I had about my 5th gear tower disintegrate in an Overland model, with very few operating hours, that I accepted tank drives as a tradeoff to the expense of a good internal drive like Midwestern,  which OBTW are about $1K each (and worth it for what you get).  If someone made a decent Weaver style drive that consistently ran smoothly that might be an good alternative but I've not seen one available yet.

Great pictures Erik, you are a wonderful artist.  You capture the realism and provide a real sense of drama what ever the subject is. Your love of the hobby and photography shines through.  Thank you so much for your advise and help through the years of making these models come to life.

Don't let some bad apples spoil your fun.  Moderator, do your moderating so the forum is free of personal snipes and insults.  My mother always told me, "If you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything at all."

I am looking forward to returning home to the Holidays with my family.  Many of us have a lot to be thankful for, and anyone vertical should feel the same. 

Happy Holiday's Everyone, even the "Bad Apples".

Scott Mann

sdmann posted:

Great pictures Erik, you are a wonderful artist.  You capture the realism and provide a real sense of drama what ever the subject is. Your love of the hobby and photography shines through. 

Happy Holiday's Everyone, even the "Bad Apples".

Scott Mann

I'll second both of those, Scott, and add my sincere thanks to both of you for your creative contributions to our hobby during 2016. 

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×