Skip to main content

Hi everyone. I was at a Lionel new product demonstration at the Chicago , IL Lionel club building in New Lennox, IL a few Saturdays ago. The product being demonstrated was the new IR Fastrack section (O gauge) that Lionel hopes to be the "New Thing" in Model trains. The demonstration was nice and showed how you could use your Ipad to control trains among other things. Very High Tech stuff that really didn't hold my interest very long as I'm content with TMCC.

After the presentation I approached the Lionel rep and told him I'm really interested in S gauge.

I also told him I thought most operators can appreciate new inventions but I thought Lionel could sell more product if it solves Existing problems.

In particular I told him a major hurdle for us two rail guys is reverse loops. Three railers don't have the polarity problems inherent in two rail track systems.

So...I told him "Produce a completely automatic Lionel S gauge Fastrack reverse loop system".

No toggles to throw, no added IR sensors to find and install...Just a complete system including a turnout (L or R), a healthy amount of Fastrack curves to accommodate a medium length train (whatever that is) and all the needed bells and whistles completely installed in the track to automatically reverse the track polarity in the isolated section and simultaneously throw the turnout to the other position so the train can exit WITHOUT STOPPING.


I have no idea what such a system might cost but I do know there are enough operators who forego reverse loops either because they are intimidated by the electronics or just too complacent to try. I know I'm guilty of both. The rep was very interested in the concept but couldn't offer any insight as to what the "higher-ups" might think.

I do know squeaky wheels do occasionally get oiled.

So ...what do you think? 

Would you buy such a system (assuming you use Fastrack)?

If so, how much would you pay for it?

Just thinking out loud here.

Mark

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

That would be fine as an accessory track pack. Looking at the bigger picture, I would like to see the S Fastrack selection include wide radius curves. Like S-72, etc. Various degrees of crossings, wide radius switches.   

S needs to reach out beyond the Gilbert  Flyer tight radii. We now have the wonderful engines to run, they would look great on a sweeping curve.

Originally Posted by Quick Casey:

That would be fine as an accessory track pack. Looking at the bigger picture, I would like to see the S Fastrack selection include wide radius curves. Like S-72, etc. Various degrees of crossings, wide radius switches.   

S needs to reach out beyond the Gilbert  Flyer tight radii. We now have the wonderful engines to run, they would look great on a sweeping curve.


And turnouts to match the curves.  While numbered turnouts (#4, #6, etc.)make sense in the scale world, a turnout that could be put in place of a curved section of track would probably be more attractive for our HiRail and Flyer friends.

 

One of the shortcomings of SHS S-Trax was the only turnout available was for the 20" radius and SHS was working on a #5 rather than ones to match the 24" and 27" radius curves.

 

Rusty

Originally Posted by banjoflyer:
As I understand it, in the MTH 2-rail Engines the Electronics sense the direction of DC Polarity and reverse it when necessary , so there is no need for complicated wiring of the Track system...

 

Gardner...I don't follow your posting...are you saying MTH's DCS system would automatically reverse the train motor's polarity w/o experiencing a short?

That's good news for S gauge but who throws the switch so the train won't derail?

 

Originally Posted by GARDNER:
Originally Posted by banjoflyer:
As I understand it, in the MTH 2-rail Engines the Electronics sense the direction of DC Polarity and reverse it when necessary , so there is no need for complicated wiring of the Track system...

 

Gardner...I don't follow your posting...are you saying MTH's DCS system would automatically reverse the train motor's polarity w/o experiencing a short?

That's good news for S gauge but who throws the switch so the train won't derail?

 


DCC has modules to reverse track polarity and throw turnouts, but that doesn't help folks with Legacy or DCS.

 

Rusty

Originally Posted by Rusty Traque:
Originally Posted by GARDNER:
Originally Posted by banjoflyer:
As I understand it, in the MTH 2-rail Engines the Electronics sense the direction of DC Polarity and reverse it when necessary , so there is no need for complicated wiring of the Track system...

 

Gardner...I don't follow your posting...are you saying MTH's DCS system would automatically reverse the train motor's polarity w/o experiencing a short?

That's good news for S gauge but who throws the switch so the train won't derail?

 


DCC has modules to reverse track polarity and throw turnouts, but that doesn't help folks with Legacy or DCS.

 

Rusty

I`ve read about this feature of Automatic Polarity Detecting and Reversing for years and as far as I know it`s part of the DCS System...

DCC Specialties makes a product called the PSXAR-AC which will automatically change polarity on a two rail AC layout.  You connect your mainline track power to its input.  The output goes to an isolated section of track within your reverse loop. There needs to be a gap at each end point of the reverse loop.  In my case I have three entry points to my reverse loop so three gaps are needed.  When a conductive wheel crosses a gap one of two things happen. If the polarity is the same the board does nothing.  If the polarity is opposite then the polarity of the isolated section is reversed.  This happens so fast that engines and lighted cars show no indication of it happening.  Its all electronics, no relays so we are talking about milliseconds.  An additional feature is that if there really is a short in the isolated section the power is shut off for a few seconds.  It then powers up and will continue to shut off until the short is removed.  You can also limit the amount of current required before it tries to reverse or shut down.  The link below will take you to the page that explains about this product. Please note the picture on the web site in not correct for the AC S Gauge version. When I received the unit it looked like the picture.  The MOS-FETs (black squares on the board) were not up to the demands of the application.  After multiple times sending back they upgraded these MOS-FETs and put a large heat sink on them as well. Since this was done the unit has operated flawlessly.  I am running TMCC/ Legacy on my layout and it is a pleasure just to run and not have to worry about a reverse loop.  If you order one directly from them or a vendor you must specify the AC version for S Gauge.

 

http://www.dccspecialties.com/...r_compatible_2ac.htm

Dear ekaplan,

Thank you for explaining that system.  Until your post, it seemed phantasmal.  In my own mind, I knew there had to be an isolated section like any traditional loop.

 

I have actually had pretty good luck creating an automatic loop with stock Gilbert equipment, but the train sensing is always the weak link.  It is reliable until you start introducing engines that are diverse either in weight (for pressure trips) or in current draw (for electronic trips).  I had poor results with an early light sensing trip.  The current sensing ability here is the key for simplicity.  I have had very good experience with a trip from dallee.  It just requires you to pass the feeding wire through a loop in the board.  Good stuff, although the trip itself runs on DC so requires an extra circuit there.

 

i am wondering if anyone else has had a good experience with a new production trip?  If so, where did it come from and how does it work?

 

thanks,

John

 

 

 

I have installed the PSXAR-AC polarity reverser as an option on the TURNTABLES I manufacture for 2-3 years. They work as intended! DCC Specialties have this circuit board for layouts powered by AC, DCS and DCC. If anyone would like a picture of the unit installed on the TURNTABLE, please email me at: daba@chibardun.net . I can also email you pictures of the E-Z ENGINE TURNTABLE with all the options. Sizes 12 inch thru 34 inch diameters in one inch increments. Pit depths one inch to 2-1/2 inches in 1/4 inch increments. Thanks, Dave B.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×