The new SS F-7's are beautiful models, but like many of the brass models of years past they have some incorrect detailing and the issues brought up on the 3 rail side are legit. KEY has been producing E and F units for 30+ years in O scale and the more experience they gain the better the models have become. Their models in the past 10 years or so, are absolutely stunning and have set the bar for covered wagon diesel models that I don't see anyone surpassing.
The biggest issue on the current run of SS "F" units is the Santa Fe units have the lifting lugs down by the pilot instead of up by the number boards. Regardless of how beautiful the rest of the model is or how nice the other details look, the lifting lugs are hard to ignore if you're a SF modeler. And to ignore it and say nothing doesn't do anyone any good, including the importer. So, I think saying the 3R guys are nit picking and the 2R guys are thrilled is a misnomer.
One of the nice things about modern factory locos is the fantastic paint jobs. For the non-painting modeler, a paint job like this is hard to come by and can cost $200-300 alone. So anything that might screw up the beautiful factory paint (moving the lifting lugs) is a legitimate concern.
One of the other issues being discussed is the vent window treatment. On the earlier E-7's, SS did as Athearn and many quality HO importers have done and do, which is etch the vent pillar in the cab side window which mimics a scale size pillar. On this model, instead of etching the pillar in one piece of plastic, an out of scale side window with silver trim was overlayed onto the side window glazing which put the side window much deeper in the car body than on the E-7's which are close to flush. The trim is out of scale and it really doesn't improve the window at all. Scott reported he is checking into having some side windows made up with etched pillar to replace the one that came on the model. So, I believe this says Scott is not happy with it either.
Overall, it is a remarkable and beautiful model and one of the best looking and I'm told running (haven't run mine yet) plastic F units produced to date. It has some incredible detailing, mechanics and paint as you can see in Austin Bills photos, but not to mention the mistakes or areas that could be improved on the next run is wrong.
Scott is the kind of person who appreciates hearing the good and the bad on his models or he wouldn't be arguably on of the most successful importers of model trains since Max Gray and Levon K. (sorry didn't want to butcher the spelling of his last name) and right up there with Tom March, Dave Davita (Sp), George Kohs and a few others. So being politically correct and biting ones tongue is not what Scott wants and not in the cards for me either.
Butch