Skip to main content

After enjoying Andy’s thread so much I thought I would try a thread on the 5 best looking or favorite electric locomotives. My 5 picks are as follows:

1. GG1 in Brunswick green and with 5 stripes is the best looking for all-time

2. P5a has similar character of a GG1

3. EP-5 Jet in the McGinnis paint scheme

4. E-44 always amazes me how nice a box can look

5. EP-4 very elegant

So what are your top 5 electrics and why?

prr4935

tr_prr4780

NHEP5_01

5674582010_9f2d3b58de

Electrics_on_Hellgate_Bridge

 

Attachments

Images (5)
  • prr4935
  • tr_prr4780
  • NHEP5_01
  • 5674582010_9f2d3b58de
  • Electrics_on_Hellgate_Bridge
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JFo04sZavo

 

Those howling wolves look pretty good to me. I've got a real nice looking Conrail E44, wearing the blue livery.

 

Electric North American locomotives from the past had/have an Industrial thing going on, re: their looks; and are much more appealing to me than the standard definition of good looks.

 

I have the other P5a type, the PRR box cab version; another nice looking box.

 

I've got a New Haven EP3 that did the porch thing long before EMD stretched their undersized SD40's, by adding a dance floor to the front and back.

 

Big, quirky and black, looking like two back-to-back old school locomotives with a fort in-between, my EP-2 Bi-Polar.

 

I don't have one, but I like the Joe's.

 

 

Rick

 

1 - NYC P2 boxcab - elegant and classy (and scrapped - big surprise)

2 - NH streamlined EP's - freight and passenger

3 - PC (okay, PRR) E44 Bricks

4 - Because they remind me of each other so much: CMStP&P Joes; VGN

     streamlined; GN streamlined (I forget the classes)

5 - and the PRR "Big Liz" 2-C-C-2 boxcab

 

Also-rans: NYC S-1/S-2/S-3 and the PRR L-5.

 

And the rest of them; electrics are cool.

Originally Posted by Catenary Matt:

Wow!  The CNR 6710 has the GG1 beat by about 25 years, although no direct fault of the GG1 since it was the electric supply that was changed at the catenary that forced them to retire.

 

 

 

Believe, the initial reason for retiring the GG1's was due to cracked frame problems.

Someone will correct me if i am wrong

The GG-1 is just an EP-3 with a fancy body and the insides rearranged to cook the crew. So I'd go with:

 

1. EP-3 'Flat Bottom' in dark green with the gold stripes and lettering.

2. EP-5 'Jet' in the pre-McGinnis pin-stripe scheme.

3. EL-C/EF-4 in VGN or NH paint schemes.

4. Class 373 'Eurostar' power car/loco

5. "Little Joe" EF-4

 

1. EP5 Jet 

2. GG1

3. EP4

I assume we are talking heavy mainline electrification beyond 600V DC..I don't care for going to five inasmuch as the rest don't seem to have much styling outside of what was dictated by their functionality or more brute appearance. There are lovable ugly ducklings and unremarkable "box cabs on a raft". Perhaps a Class D steeplecab would fit in there. My criteria is what denotes speed in their styling not uniqueness etc. Probably the craziest and ugliest thing I ever saw was an electrified "bobber" caboose used for switching...talk about low budget projects.. 

Last edited by electroliner

I'm sorry to be anything but my usual Pollyanna self here, but except for the TGV and similar modern 'superfast' locos, which look like rockets on rails, the terms "beautiful" and "electric locomotive" are mutually exclusive.  This is particuarly true when a catenary is involved.  Many electrics are just plain ugly, if quite interesting to look at and intriguingly novel of design, but I can't think of anything with a catenary cage on top (the locomotive equivalent of Alfred E Newman's ears) that is anywhere close to beautiful. 

Originally Posted by N.Q.D.Y.:

 ......I especially like the early models in TEE colours with full skirting ........

Screen Shot 2013-01-18 at 17.58.38

Nicole, by "full skirting", do you mean below the buffers, like this.... [ Taken in '73 ] 

Euro011

 

I admit I especially liked the first four from '65, with the silver roof, single row of vents, trim band, etc. -- and no  computer number, either. This shot taken in '66, when two had single arm pans.  I really liked the original 120's in the TEE scheme, though.

Euro010

 

The original E10's and E40's were somehow 'just right':

Euro004

 

And one can't discuss good looking electrics without at least a few examples from Paul Arzens;  here's one

Euro008

 

So many favs.......

 

Best rgds, SZ

 

PS  Amazing no Pennsy fans nominated the E2c's or their E3b siblings;  an "electric Shark" -- what's not to like ??!?

 

PPS  No need for photo credits;  I took all these.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • Euro011
  • Euro010
  • Euro004
  • Euro008

Tsk - no mention of the first U.S. railroad to purchase 3 of the electrics originally destined for the Soviet Union?  From a website across the Atlantic:  http://www.ashmore1952.freeserve.co.uk/page9.html  let me add the Chicago, South Shore and South Bend's most handsome 800 series in classic Traction Orange and Maroon to the list (not Little Joe's to a South Shore man):

 

800

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 800
Last edited by MTN
Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×