Skip to main content

I was reading a post on unpacking long unused trains, and I was struck by a couple of guys stating that their wives hated their trains.  Now my wife has mostly been indifferent. She wants me to sell them since we are in the November or December of our lives.  But I don’t think she hates them.
Now, everyone has a different story, but I’m wondering if there’s a common thread to that sentiment, and actually how prevalent it is.
Does your wife hate your trains?  If so, what  do you think is behind her feelings.  Is it the expenditure of the money, too much floor space surrendered to it or that she says you pay more attention to your trains than her?  I’m sure that there could be more reasons that I did not think of.
Maybe we should have the wives reply to this question. I bet that the husbands  and wives would give different answers if asked independently. As a doctor I’ll commonly hear a different take on issues between them. .…especially regarding their sex life.
Alan

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Interesting subject. I know that in my case I have this great hobby that I really enjoy and she has NO hobbies. I think she is a bit jealous but she says no. The funny part is that the trains are brought up on occasions when there is a new purchase and it always comes down to the fact that when she makes a purchase I never say anything and she agrees. Hate them maybe or maybe not. But I will keep going with the trains because honestly they were with me when I met her. Then again in 1987 she bought me a new locomotive and told me to build a layout and the rest is history.

My wife has always liked our trains and attending train shows. She was responsible for purchasing the most expensive set I own. She expects there to be trains under tree as much as I do. She maintains my computerized train inventory data base. When we have events at our home most of the other wives also seem to like the trains, of course it is not their husband that owns them.

When the decision was made to have a custom layout professionally built my wife was a participant in that decision. She carefully reviewed all the invoices and paid all the bills. She also made a trip to Miami to visit the shop during construction. I consider myself fortunate that my wife accepts and appreciates my toy train hobby.

Well maybe I will jump in on this. Like I said in the other thread my wife will burn all my trains when I die and I am sure that will probably happen ,but this is because I put a lot of time and hard earned money into my hobby . And for her that’s nuts and trains are for kids in her mind. That’s not her fault though it’s the way she was brought up in a house hold of hard working mom and dad with no hobbies and working every waking hour of their lives. So when she sees me and the way I grew up with a grandfather and father and uncle all with train layouts she sees this as lazy and a waste of time. She doesn’t come down on me about it to hard but there are time that there could be a comment that I could be doing something else around the house because as we all know your house always has something to be done grass cut, painting ext. . So I will say this I do what I want but at the same time a happy wife happy life.

After a couple years of marriage, my wife told me to get a hobby.  I think I went with trains because they reminded me of home and my youth.  My wife sews.   She is on her 3rd embroidery machine.   Over the years, I’m sure she’s dropped well over 20k on the machines alone.  They have minimal value after a couple years.  She knows I’m tight.  Therefore I don’t, and won’t, have a lot invested.   I build a layout, work on it a year or do, destroy it, sell everything, and do something else.   So nothing I do is permanent.  I recently sold off  almost all my o gauge and bought a little ho.  As time goes on, I have less and less money tied up in trains.  It doesn’t mean I’m not having fun.

My spouse was pretty supportive of my hobby. I have met more than a few who were not . Most of these meetings were after the husband had passed and the spouse, children or both were coming into the shop to sell the collection. I don’t some people realize how much they neglect their family while pursuing this hobby and the strong negative feelings that causes

My Darling Wife drug me into the hobby by insisting we have a train around the Christmas tree.  I never had that as a kid.

Then when we had Kids, she told me to go to Allentown with her brother and buy trains for the kids and build them a layout.

It's been a fun time.

We used to have a local hobby shop in town.  Good ole Mr. Wagner made sure every spouse got a big giant chocolate bar for Christmas.

He used to say, your husband is not out at the bar with the guys and not chasing other women.  He's in the basement playing trains.

I'm blessed and hope others with spouces not as supportive can improve their situations.

Have Fun.

Ron

i'm still single and looking so i don't have this issue yet with a wife or gf.

but i want to know why my PARENTS hate my trains

yes my trains are a special interest along with NERF guns and Shailene Woodley and my parents hate trains and i was never allowed access at home.

Then i had a teacher who knew about autism and said taking away my trains and Nerf stuff was wrong and inhumane

she and another teacher tried to help me build a small HO layout in her room until my dad found out and told the principal to shut down all my train access

than my parents called me a baby because i had a train at school

and yet my dad was a nascar fan and spider man fan had spiderman decals all over his truck and my stepmom has a cabnet full of Santa dolls

and my whole family was against my special interests and i was like the black sheep of the family

i still have trauma from when my dad destroyed a 1500 dollar locomotive i got for christmas in 2007 from a friend

i'm always afraid its gonna happen again

Last edited by paigetrain

I think you can substitute golf, hunting, fishing, travel, etc for "trains" in this thread.  The aspects of a marriage relationship are a little more complicated than liking or disliking a hobby.

My wife is not into trains, but she helped me load, setup and sell at train and computer shows for years. 

Try to enjoy what you have while you are on the earth.

If your wife likes your trains or is at least neutral you are a very lucky person.  The entire four years my EX and I were dating she at least pretended that she liked the trains. She went to TCA meets with me and one of my train buddies and his wife. We would usually go to Atlanta meets at least a day before the meet and go out on the town.  Within a year of our marriage she refused to go to train meets with my long time friends Bill and his wife Agnes.  Bill and I never made our TCA trips only about trains we always went shopping with the girls and mostly let the girls set the agenda outside the train show.  I eventually stopped going to TCA meets though I still played with the trains with our daughter who to the chagrin of my wife loved the trains.  In November of 84 I traded some guns for a large American Flyer collection. I was unloading my third load when the wife came to the deck on the rear of the house and said.  Either the trains go or I go. We split up in Jan of 85.  In hind sight I think she felt I should be spending the train money on her or our home though the trains never took money out of our budget they in fact made a little money.            j

Last edited by JohnActon

It all comes down to respect. Some marriages are more like odd video games where the couple acts as if no one else is real. At most, they’re non-playing characters who are supposed to do as they’re told and nothing more.

By the way, I’m glad the guys got me up to see W&W#4 before I got sick, and neither of them complained about my T-shirt buying. They don’t complain when I get excited about an amazing craft score, either. Soon as I’m well enough I’m looking forward to train time at Morgan Station again.

(Should clarify, my allergies finally got me with a round of pneumonia. Glad it wasn’t worse.)

My wife bought me a Lionel starter set in the early 80s and that’s what set the wheels in motion.  A few times she has said she regrets buying that set, but in truth, she is mostly indifferent.  However, she loves to see the joy on youngsters faces when they visit the layout.  Once or twice, she complained that I spend too much money on trains, but then I reminded her how much she spends on her hair and she hasn’t complained since.

The owner of an LHS that I used to frequent told me a story about a wife that put a large HO collection on the trash shortly after her husband died.  She was bitter that he paid more attention to the trains than he did to her.

Generally, she is what I would call "neutral" on trains. She knows it's an important hobby for me and makes the occasional crack about "another package arriving." But all in fun.

I will say this...years ago I had mentioned the classic trains for Christmas of my youth and lo and behold she bought a Lionel Set that set me on the O gauge path. It was the Texas & Pacific Railsounds Passenger Set. Came with a CW-80 and track. I still have it.

My wife much prefers me playing in the basement with my trains to me playing in a bar somewhere with things I shouldn't be playing with (like darts).  She also loves going to York with me as she is a people person and loves the interaction with the other sellers and attendees.  Of course, she keeps telling me that I can't croak and leave her with the trains but I tell her that's what the kids are for!

My wife got me back into the hobby in 1994, when she bought me a beaten up Lionel steamer. So, I often remind her it is all her fault!

White Plains-20111211-00037

For several years, she also was my assistant at train shows. Luckily, she collects things too, like stuffed animals (there is a one on our table).

Tom

Attachments

Images (1)
  • White Plains-20111211-00037
Last edited by PRR8976

My wife is very supportive of my hobby and me of hers, she is a master crocheter. When we go to the Big E Train show I drive 15 miles north to Webs (her crafts version of a huge LHS), drop her off. Go back to Springfield walk the floor for about 3 hours go back and she still needs half an hour .

I got married in my early 40s. I married my best friend and that hasn't changed , 26 years and counting .

Last edited by bptBill

It is unlikely that the trains themselves are the issue.

This ^^^^ - if other things aren't working in the relationship, trains won't make it any better.

My ex-wife didn't have a problem with the trains, the time I spent on them, or the expense (which was always discussed in advance).  What soured her on the hobby was the behavior of several other folks involved with it.  A former major dealer in my area was very arrogant, which rubbed her the wrong way - she didn't shed any tears when his warehouse burned.  The biggest single event was being rudely yelled at on our first visit to York because we ran in out of a heavy rain without our badges being displayed properly.  After that, she referred to people in the hobby as "train a--holes".  Can't say that I blamed her.

My significant other loves trains and enjoys going to meets - she's an enabler.

If there's a takeaway from this, I think it's that we should all treat our fellow train folks' significant others with respect and include our wives in our decisions and interactions.

@JohnActon posted:

If your wife likes your trains or is at least neutral you are a very lucky person.  ...

In November of 84 I traded some guns for a large American Flyer collection. I was unloading my third load when the wife came to the deck on the rear of the house and said.  Either the trains go or I go. We split up in Jan of 85.  In hind sight I think she felt I should be spending the train money on her or our home though the trains never took money out of our budget they in fact made a little money.            j

Reminds me of the t-shirt / bumper sticker:  "I got a train for my wife.  Best trade I ever made."

I think based on personal observation that this is overblown. For one thing, wives tend to like to have things to roll their eyes at when it comes to spouses, you know, like leaving the toilet seat up, or rolling their eyes at obsession with sports teams, etc, they never really outgrow I think when as young girls and they get irritated at boys for doing something and say "Boys!" *lol*. They need things to complain about when talking to friends.

My wife encourages me, I am the reluctant one, I have a hard time spending money on myself while having no problem spending on others (the money I spent on my son's music education would have allowed me to buy a nice house built around a layout, and told Mike Regan and TRWX to build one heck of a layout and still have money to burn) and I am the same way with my wife (okay, at York I told people my wife encouraged me to go and find stuff I liked, but then she didn't go knowing I hate spending money on myself.....*lol*..hey, husbands play the game, too). She thinks it is great I love trains and she does like watching them.

I think given the cost of this stuff that in some cases they might resent it if money is spent on the trains and there are other things they feel need to be done, that boils down to communication and negotiation, but that is true of anything, had a guy I worked with back in the 90's lay down 40k in cash to buy a Corvette, when they had kids about ready to enter college and other things, wondered why the wife was angry at him....some, too, if they are as obsessive as some of the people I have seen at train shows, at York and on forums, might be resentful that they are spending too much time on trains, it is a hobby after all , a diversion (on the other hand, could be the person spends all their time on the trains to get away....).

Where I have seen it generally is where the spouse looks at it as a grown person 'playing with trains', that it is a waste of time and money, and more importantly, in their mind, 'what will other people think' kind of thing. The same spouse that would resent a husband 'playing with trains' wouldn't bat an eye if he belonged to a country club and played golf all the time (one thing my wife and I see eye to eye on, neither one of us understands golf or country clubs, but that is just us), they wouldn't object is hubby had season tickets to the local football team or went hunting or fishing with buds or played poker, because those are 'socially acceptable' for men to do, there is still a lot of those kind of attitudes out there, it isn't just women who get bound in stereotypes.

They are afraid of the hubby being seen as odd, or as being anti social (ok, that stereotype does have grains of truth to it, some of the people I see at train shows , well.....on the other hand, if they met Gun Runner John as I was lucky to at First Frost, blow the stereotype right out the water! *lol*) or are 'being childish'. Some may have grown up around a culture, religious or otherwise, that frowned on that kind of 'frivolous recreation', that once you 'grew up', that was that for fun and games.

IME most wives are okay or supportive of the hobby, maybe even into it themselves, as long as it is in balance with budget and with living a balanced life, met very few who were negative. I suspect that attitude was more common a long time ago, when my mom and dad were first married (1952), that first Christmas after finding out my dad never had trains as a kid she got her brother , who was buying trains for my cousin at the time (who was like 8 months old that Christmas!), to duplicate the order for my dad. He worked at Bell Labs in NYC at the time, and the other people he worked with not only thought that was a brilliant gift they were jealous bc it would cause them problems.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×