Skip to main content

I recall old-time model railroaders used this years ago. I used it (its a very light machine oil) for my old layout on train tracks - it both cleaned and prevented oxidation in a semi-humid basement. I understand it also helps with electrical conductivity. My existing basement is fairly dry but does get humid in summer - dehumidifier helps initially but since it puts out warm air there's a diminishing return factor (warmer air will hold more moisture).

I read that the black grime that develops on tracks is due to the electrochemical reaction between the type of metal rails and type of metal wheels (I had always thought it was from smoke fluid and rubber tire residues - but that's not the case apparently) ~ thus it is a corrosion process that leaves the black crud - which if allowed to build up becomes a cake and prevents conductivity. I am wondering if that's the reason old-time railroaders used Wahl clipper oil - kind of an old remedy that was forgotten by mainstream? Thus, the tracks still need to be cleaned but left bone dry - rather a final application of the oil? I am not sure of all this, and wanted to learn what some wise old timers thought?

Last edited by Paul Kallus
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I still have a couple bottles of the stuff from back in the day. I even used it on my current layout for a short time years ago. I always thought that the crud was due to the oil picking up dust and dirt and caking it onto the wheels. I quit using it, in favor of a track cleaning car with Scotchbrite pads. I use no liquids on my rails anymore.

If I'm not mistaken, the whole Wahl oil thing got started back in the earliest days of command control, early 80's. The system back then was called CTC-16, well before modern DCC. The idea was to help the engines get better command signal through the track, by smoothing out the imperfections with the conductive oil. In addition, the guys I knew, who we would now call "beta testers", were going to the trouble of having the wheels of their engines nickel plated, to go along with the nickel silver rail they were using.

It makes me wonder if this practice has any value for steel rails and wheels.

Last edited by Big_Boy_4005

I have to agree with HotWater's comments, especially since oil and traction tires create a slippery slope of sorts.

 

Wahl Clipper oil became "of age" back in the '60s when a lot of us were 'growing up' and testing the waters in HO gauge equipment. The track of the day was usually Atlas SanpTrack which had rails made of brass. The Wahl clipper oil was an aid in keeping electrical conductivity with the brass rails at an acceptable level for the day until nickel silver rail became the defacto standard and eliminated the need for the clipper oil.

Well, to be more specific, I NEVER applied the "light oil" to the outside rails. The idea of "better electrical conductivity" and associated DCS signal strength, was to ONLY apply the oil to the center/power rail. I was using the Atlas "Electro-Lube" product, which I still use on the shaft of locomotive pick-up rollers (NOT the roller itself, only the shaft through the center of the roller).

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×