Skip to main content

I am in the process of populating, or should I say repopulating, my three rail O stack train. I have purchased the various sets of Atlas O Gunderson three car stack sets and containers but my choices for my stack train are pretty much limited to what Atlas O makes available. With each stack set release (street price about $275 per three car set), Atlas O has released containers but there are fairly limited choices, they sell quickly and they are not inexpensive. I paid an average of $25 for the 53' containers and the 40' and 45' containers are almost impossible to find. 

Lionel Husky Stack cars are a good value dollar for dollar, but they also, are fairly difficult to find or, at least, in the road/container name you want. Online auction prices get up there, too.

I think Lionel may have offered containers at one time, K-Line did and MTH may have. If you go the the online auction site, choices are almost nil. Why can't manufacturers like Menards and others offer decent containers in many "road names and numbers" at prices less than $25 per? Yes? With the recent Menards release, I am not interested in their stack car but I am interested in the containers.

Scrappy

 

Last edited by Scrapiron Scher
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You know, the OP should know better. It's July and trains are far from peoples mind as well as many hobbyists. Only the Die Hards are still out looking for trains. Come September, it will be a different story on Da bay as well as some shows. I just did a search for 40' containers and there are some K-line and MTH containers out there.

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.htm...ner&_sacat=19145

Weaver NOS 20' should be popping around in August. 

There are also Hobby shops out there that minimally use the WWW so stock is out there, the OP just need to find it in sometimes unconventional ways.

rtr12 posted:

Add a Holy Mackerel to the above. Just ask and Yee shall receive!! Now, how about that for timing?

Menards Mark must have insight into future threads...or he just sits back and holds these things until a thread pops up??

I must say.....Mark and Menard's are on the ball.......I have done product development, marketing and sales of hobby items.  These guys are good.  and no 10-12 month lead in....others might want to learn some of that. I know modern marketing is announce a product and get enough buzz you give it the green light.  A few bumps in development and your at 14 months and the buzz is gone. It's a safe method but has it's own issues. 

Originally posted by Banjoflyer:

Lionel 4-pack around $13.00/unit shipped.



Originally posted by TEXASSP:

My understanding is that those older Lionel containers with the side slots are not scale at all. Someone please
correct me if I am wrong. Also the slots in the bottom containers have always bothered me, so I pass on them.

You are correct Sir. The Lionel containers above are really S gauge in Size. The reason for the slotted bottom containers was to make those containers work with the MI-Jack inter-modal crane as Lionel couldn't figure out how to lift the bottom container out of the well with the Mi-Jack lifting mechanism.

I too void them like the Plague... ESP if you obtain the Atlas O containers! Those are hard to beat!

AMCDave posted:
rtr12 posted:

Add a Holy Mackerel to the above. Just ask and Yee shall receive!! Now, how about that for timing?

Menards Mark must have insight into future threads...or he just sits back and holds these things until a thread pops up??

I must say.....Mark and Menard's are on the ball.......I have done product development, marketing and sales of hobby items.  These guys are good.  and no 10-12 month lead in....others might want to learn some of that. I know modern marketing is announce a product and get enough buzz you give it the green light.  A few bumps in development and your at 14 months and the buzz is gone. It's a safe method but has it's own issues. 

On the ball indeed! I think Mark has a crystal ball! 

I do like the fact that Menards has the stuff in stock when they announce it. That is a nice touch. It would be nice if the other folks could at least do some of that too, but I guess they are geared more towards a catalog type distribution system and that is just the way it goes.

Could someone who owns MTH, Lionel, Atlas, K-Line and Menards 40' "scale" containers post pictures and/or dimensions of the various manufacturers' containers.  I am having trouble understanding which, if any, containers are interchangeable between the different manufacturers' stack cars or which can be stacked on other manufacturers' containers.

I would be very appreciative.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×