Skip to main content

It stepped up it's game in it's war on the hobby this weekend.  First victim was my new MTH PS-1 SP Cab Forward I got as a birthday gift.  After getting it out, replacing the battery and doing a test lap and programming, it was time to lube it up for long running.  I was at the table doing so when my other new locomotive, a MTH PS-1 PRR S-2, stopped dead on the track of my carpet layout.  I jumped up to see what was wrong.  By the time I got to the S-2, I heard a loud thud.  I turned to see my Cab Forward now sitting on the floor!  Like a cat, it was sitting on it's wheels.  I quickly inspected it and placed it on the track.  It still ran as it did before, nothing binding or making sounds.  I lucked out somehow.  But when I went to put it on the shelf, I did notice something, there are now flat spots on the tires.  They are marked with a red arrow.

 

CF flat wheels

I guess it rolled off of the table, bounced off of my chair changing it's roll direction and hit the tile floor with the edge of the wheels, but with enough momentum that it completed the roll to upright.  The chair and tile came out unharmed.  Time to build a cradle it seems.

 

The next victim was my K-Line PRR caboose I got for Christmas.  My wife was trying to put books on the bookshelf without moving the trains off of it first.  Well, she knocked it off and it landed on it's front end.  Bent the cat walk, popped the ladder out and cracked the plastic stairs.  Sigh.

 

 

Caboose Marked

So this one needs some work.  The catwalk is easy to bend back, but it popped out the rivets (They look like nails.) too.  Do I just use some super glue to glue them back in?  Putting the ladder back is no biggie either, it came out of the box that way when I got it so I've done it already.  The chip missing from the steps I'll paint black and call good, but I don't know what to do about the crack.  What have the rest of you done?  Should I just fill it with super glue and paint it black?  Is there something better to do?  It still is attached and doesn't move, but I know it is weaker now, and don't want to worry about it breaking off if I try to move it more.  The wife is fine, I forgave her (It was on her birthday.) as they are just toys after all.  Costly toys, but still just toys and not worth getting upset over.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • CF flat wheels
  • Caboose Marked
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

First that brass loco, now this. Those flat spotted wheels can only be fixed by replacing the entire wheel, not an easy job and it requires a puller. I must say sinclair, you sure take these awful circumstances in stride.

 

1. Be more selective where you place your trains.

 

2. Contact this guy about that darn coffee table, maybe he can figure why stuff keeps falling off of it.

 

 

Last edited by RickO
Originally Posted by sinclair:

It stepped up it's game in it's war on the hobby this weekend.  First victim was my new MTH PS-1 SP Cab Forward I got as a birthday gift.  After getting it out, replacing the battery and doing a test lap and programming, it was time to lube it up for long running.  I was at the table doing so when my other new locomotive, a MTH PS-1 PRR S-2, stopped dead on the track of my carpet layout.  I jumped up to see what was wrong.  By the time I got to the S-2, I heard a loud thud.  I turned to see my Cab Forward now sitting on the floor!  Like a cat, it was sitting on it's wheels.  I quickly inspected it and placed it on the track.  It still ran as it did before, nothing binding or making sounds.  I lucked out somehow.  But when I went to put it on the shelf, I did notice something, there are now flat spots on the tires.  They are marked with a red arrow.

 

CF flat wheels

I guess it rolled off of the table, bounced off of my chair changing it's roll direction and hit the tile floor with the edge of the wheels, but with enough momentum that it completed the roll to upright.  The chair and tile came out unharmed.  Time to build a cradle it seems.

 

The next victim was my K-Line PRR caboose I got for Christmas.  My wife was trying to put books on the bookshelf without moving the trains off of it first.  Well, she knocked it off and it landed on it's front end.  Bent the cat walk, popped the ladder out and cracked the plastic stairs.  Sigh.

 

 

 

So this one needs some work.  The catwalk is easy to bend back, but it popped out the rivets (They look like nails.) too.  Do I just use some super glue to glue them back in?  Putting the ladder back is no biggie either, it came out of the box that way when I got it so I've done it already.  The chip missing from the steps I'll paint black and call good, but I don't know what to do about the crack.  What have the rest of you done?  Should I just fill it with super glue and paint it black?  Is there something better to do?  It still is attached and doesn't move, but I know it is weaker now, and don't want to worry about it breaking off if I try to move it more.  The wife is fine, I forgave her (It was on her birthday.) as they are just toys after all.  Costly toys, but still just toys and not worth getting upset over.


Is the wheel actually out of round and "flat spotted" or is just the flange bent?

During the summer I had staged a photo scene on my table saw out in the garage. To make a long story short, I moved the saw and my Williams brass Niagara tender fell to the concrete floor...DH'O! The only damage was that some of the real coal load loosened. I glued it back, set it on the tracks with its engine and everything was fine...Go figure!

December 05, 2013 017

Attachments

Images (1)
  • December 05, 2013 017

It's not a traction tire, but the tire if it had been a real steamer.  The traction tires are okay, and so are the flanges.  It travels without any wobble so it's only the edge of the tire.  Think of it as now having a slight chamfer in one spot.  I'm not worried about it, it's the caboose I'm worried about and would like to fix.

 

As for taking it in stride, well let's say I've had enough life experiences in my relatively short life that has taught me what is and isn't really important in life.  The trains are great toys for fun that I am passionate about (Well, trains in general.), but my relationships with my wife and children are far more important.  Trains can be replaced, repaired, or repurposed, but family can't be.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×