Skip to main content

Hi all not sure if any have had these problems with the recent Korber Roundhouse Issue, but after getting my kit last week I have found several deficiencies in the kit I received.  And was wondering if this is an anomaly or just the way it is.  Let me proceed.

 1.) The plans I received were undersized when taped along the reference lines as instructed,  the plans only equaled 24" when the plans indicated that they should measure 29".  As a result I had to go to Staples and have new plans resized and printed at my expense.  Not cool it was $40.00 and after spending nearly $300.00 for the kit it does not seem right.  My e-mail to Steve was answered promptly but he did not assume responsibility or offer any compensation for this additional cost I incurred. 

2.)  Although the castings are good, crisp and deep there was in my opinion an excessive amount of flash on several of the pieces the windows were filled in completely and required several hours of work with a razor saw to open them up.  Don't get me wrong I dont expect a shake and bake kit,  but this seemed a bit much to me especially at the price.

3.) There were missing pieces and some were broken when opening the kit.  Steve was prompt in sending me replacements and they arrived without incident.  The broken pieces happen can't control how the package gets abused during shipment,  however the missing pieces are just plain carelessness in Q.C. and are IMHO unacceptable.

4.) Some of the strip lumber included in the kit is not cut to the proper length I am very meticulous and before placing  and gluing each piece I measured every piece against the parts list length and in the case of many of the pieces they were off  by 1/16 of an inch this may not seem like a lot but it added up on a few of the structual supports to be an 1/8 or 5/16 of an inch.  This is 6"-9" in scale and would show if not corrected.  I was forced to make filler pieces to make up the gaps and keep everything true.  Again not beyond my abilities but I should not have to do this amount of extra work on a fresh kit out of the box due to someone not accounting for the blade kerf or being careless when making the cuts.  

I am not really expecting any resolution from Steve but wish to inform the Forum membership of my experience and see if anyone else has had the same issues or concerns.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

UPFAN,

I would consider this structure a "craftsman kit". The pieces require sanding and fitting and can have some warpage because they are casted using urethane plastic. The missing pieces should not be expected and you said they were replaced. Craftsman type kits do not snap together and a lot of times are not easy to put together. I have been building models for over thirty years and have had my share of problems with various kit structures I have built.

I think that after you start getting into building the model and accept a little fit up problems that you will construct a fine building.

I do not usually follow the manufacturers directions when I build these type of kits and work my way through the problems. I find it much easier that way.

Enjoy building this kit. I think you will be happy with the results.

 

Alan Graziano

I have done two of the 304 kits. and found that an accurate Complete floor was key to assembly. I also did three complete roof panels which added to the kit.   Best wishes with your project.

This model has been around for quite some time.  The original instructions, I have, date to early 1980's.  Newer kits are much improved, over the lack-of-instructions, and warped/poorly prepared, urethane panels, that were the norm, then. The mat board roof panels, that curved when glue was applied were also a sore spot.   As has been noted it is still a craftsman's kit.    Best wishes with your project.

Mike CT.

 

Last edited by Mike CT

Not my first Korber RH kit, I got one from Justrains in Delaware several years back and built it, I had issues with that kit warped walls ill fitting windows etc, but it got built none the less.  This kit is way better than that one, but  I guess that I  was expecting a more simplified build process based on the reviews I read and at least an accurate and properly scaled drawing which BTW I did get with the old kit but not with the new one.  I guess I am sayng that given the cost I expected a little more and was disappointed with the overall quality and attention to detail in the kit I received.  I am quite sure that it will build into an awesome model and I will be happy I put in the effort to get it built but it just left a bad taste in my mouth you know??

Quite frankly there was no acknowledgement of that issue at all.  Part of why I am perturbed.  

I had previously contacted Steve regarding the plans prior to purchase as I was planning on a rework of my old Korber roundhouse and wanted to purchase the plans and strip lumber to make it easier.  Unfortunately that kit was too far gone and I wound up ordering a new one, instead of attempting the reowrk.  Steve sent a copy of the plans and a materials list via pdf graciously.  So I just took that pdf file to staples and had them print it at 100pct which was the correct measurements.  As I said none of this was beyond my abilty to square away but it has taken a little bit away from the joy of building the kit.  As previouly mentioned I am confident that I can create a kit that is well built, and nicely detailed based on how it has been coming together thus far, I t was just a sense of disappointment in the overall experience, maybe Its me, and I expect to much.  Oh well.  When its done I will post pictures.  Regards, 

 

Jon

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×