OK guys , this is the last challenge and its going to be a tough one... What year did Menards produce their own flatcars and what were they.. hint.. there were three of them with a load.. A nice prize will be sent to the winner!
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
2014
Larry
I would guess, but I won the last one! Share the wealth!
2012
Last one ? I was hoping to win the caboose trivia 
Just throwing it out there! Fall of 2011
I have a few Menards flats with loads dated 2010
Bill
mike g. posted:I would guess, but I won the last one! Share the wealth!
Same here fellow winner! Got mine yesterday!
some very close guesses here.. but I need the date and the flatcar load..
2014............flat cars Soo Line, Pennsy, BNSF, Wisconsin Central, UP, BN..........Paul
paul 2 posted:2014............flat cars Soo Line, Pennsy, BNSF, Wisconsin Central, UP, BN..........Paul
sorry son, too high...
Throwing my guess into the ring:
2011 - flatcar with concrete mixing truck
2010 Menards flat with Menards tractor
2010 Menards flat with Menards trailer.
Bill
Bill: You are SOOOOO close
2011 flatcar with tractor!
JD2035RR posted:2011 flatcar with tractor!
remember, we are looking for 3 flatcars with what loads and the correct year..
2010 Menards flat with Menards Tractor
2010 Menards flat with Menards steel roofing script trailer
2010 Menards flat with Menards concrete block script trailer
Bill
Ah, I skipped over the part where we had to state the car type. lol. One had a tractor and the other two were two items in which I have no idea what they are....
We have a Winner! Congrats Bill ! Please send me your address, and I'll get a nice prize out to you.
Attachments
Images (4)
Hi Bob, Thank You, address sent via e-mail.
Thanks for the contest, don't see those early Menards flats to often .
Bill
Good Job Bill! But I have a whole fleet of military flat cars that say build my Menards in 1941! LOL
I am Happy for you Bill, this is a great thing Bob and Mark from Menards are doing!
I think Bob has every Menard's product on the planet.
John, I think you are right about Bob's collection!!!
Congratulations, Bill! That one was earlier than I thought. I didn't know "Menards Trains Corporation" dated back to 2010!
Congratulations, Bill! That one was earlier than I thought. I didn't know "Menards Trains Corporation" dated back to 2010!
Mark Boyce
Hi Mark, I started accumulating Menards rolling stock when they first started releasing them. Pretty sure that I have most if not all of the early ones.
Bill
