Skip to main content

My answer above (ATSF Warbonnet) was made on that basis.  It does happen to be my favorite, although some of the European/British glossy lacquer-and-gold schemes are a very, very close second.  

 

But Warbonnet is certainly the most interesting paint scheme ever put on a locomotive and train for many reasons: its history with Knickerbocker and GM and the fact that it was patented, not just copyrighted, because of its style and use of color, shape, etc., because of its association with what is arguably the most iconic train of the 20th century - the Super Chief, and because, frankly, the Warbonnet F3s are maybe the iconic toy train of the post-war era in the minds of so many Americans.  

Originally Posted by Lee Willis:

My answer above (ATSF Warbonnet) was made on that basis.  It does happen to be my favorite, although some of the European/British glossy lacquer-and-gold schemes are a very, very close second.  

 

But Warbonnet is certainly the most interesting paint scheme ever put on a locomotive and train for many reasons: its history with Knickerbocker and GM and the fact that it was patented, not just copyrighted, because of its style and use of color, shape, etc., because of its association with what is arguably the most iconic train of the 20th century - the Super Chief, and because, frankly, the Warbonnet F3s are maybe the iconic toy train of the post-war era in the minds of so many Americans.  

To be fair, I did overgeneralize.  Some of the replys can make a very convincing argument that they're the most interesting.    The Rail Runner, the Warbonnet, the Seaboard E units, the Milwaukee FMs with their chrome noses, some of the Heritage units...  VERY visually interesting.

 

Some of the other responses... like a black GS4... if you tell me you think it's beautiful, I can't disagree, if you tell me it's your favorite, great, but INTERESTING?  What exactly makes a black steam locomotive more interesting that every other black steam locomotive?  It's history?  Well great, that makes it an interesting ENGINE, not an interesting paint scheme.

 

See, words are important, although I seem to be in an ever shrinking portion of the American populace who believes that.

The "Citrus" scheme Seaboard Air Line used on this E4A IMO is most interesting (although I like the scheme with the roof painted dark green better, dirt/grime wasn't as noticeable).  The pilot on this engine reminds me of a suit of armor:

 

 

sal3002

 

And as much as I love my Seaboard, the Great Northern "Glacier" paint scheme is my favorite.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • sal3002

I found Mr. Wowak’s observations regarding the use of the terms “interesting” and “favorite” and how they fit into the intended spirit of Mr. Kirkman’s thread very thought provoking. Earlier in the thread, I posted an image of a C&O SD50 painted in Chessie livery. As I mentioned in my post, I like several different schemes. As I reflected on my post after reading Mr. Wowak’s comments, I realized I had posted the Chessie image because I actually find it to be the most “interesting” of the schemes I prefer most. I find the Chessie scheme intriguing because it very cleverly combines the elements of contemporary styling of the time at which it was developed– bold graphics and flashy colors – and traditional railroad advertising – C&O’s sleeping kitten. I believe the end result was a successful portrayal of a forward thinking carrier still very much aware of its roots.

 

Here’s another of my “favorite” schemes:

 

CNJGP7

Why is it a favorite? I grew up in CNJ territory and saw these units every day. That said, do I think it’s an “interesting” scheme? Hardly.

 

Bob

Attachments

Images (1)
  • CNJGP7
Originally Posted by Wowak:
 . . . .if you tell me it's your favorite, great, but INTERESTING?  What exactly makes a black steam locomotive more interesting that every other black steam locomotive?  It's history?  Well great, that makes it an interesting ENGINE, not an interesting paint scheme.

 

See, words are important, although I seem to be in an ever shrinking portion of the American populace who believes that.

I completely agree - about the black locos and about words.  Good point, both about writing and reading - not using words correctly in either of those two activities leads to mis-communication.  

 

Edit: I'm not sure many black locos were even painted, as such - at least their owners didn't think of it as a paint scheme, I think, any more than the owners of ocean going ships used to think of the red bottom of the hull as a paint scheme.

Last edited by Lee Willis
Originally Posted by RickO:

Wow! This is indeed a nice change from "poor chinese QC" , "bringing manufacturing back to the States", and 'long product delivery delays".

 

Now its vocabulary and what your opinions should be, based on others opinions

 

Lionel! Release the **** catalog already so we can have some relavent *****ing and moaning!

Rick - I don't think asking for clear, concise use of words is imposing your opinion on others: let them say whatever they mean, but it's nice when their words mean what they are trying to say.

 

Speaking of interesting: you have a unique reason to want the Lionel catalog to be released, I must say.  Most of us are eager because we hope there is something in it we want - maybe even want to buy!

Here's the OP:
 
 
Originally Posted by Madison Kirkman:

I was wondering, what your favorite paint schemes are.  I saw a #50 gang car in the girl colors.  I thought this was interesting, so what are your favorite paint schemes?    

 

 

 

So what he's really asking is what are interesting and/or favorite color schemes for well-known models (i.e. the #50 gang car above).

 

In fairness, I don't think anyone has really responded to /that/ question.

Originally Posted by Lee Willis:
 
 

Rick - I don't think asking for clear, concise use of words is imposing your opinion on others: let them say whatever they mean, but it's nice when their words mean what they are trying to say.

 

Speaking of interesting: you have a unique reason to want the Lionel catalog to be released, I must say.  Most of us are eager because we hope there is something in it we want - maybe even want to buy!

Well Lee, it "appears" most of the responses were in regards to the first part of the OP's question. "I was wondering what your favorite paint schemes are?"

 As well as the second half of the last part of the question, "so what are your favorite paint schemes?"

 

It "appears" Wowak responded to the first half the last line of the OP's question, "I thought this was interesting,"........

 

2 favorites vs. 1 interesting.

 

Maybe the question should be correctly asked before responders are chastised for answering the question as it was worded.

 

As far as the catalog goes well,catalog the complaints are at least train related.

 

Last edited by RickO
That is what I was trying to ask, but the thread took off, from what I tried to ask.  oh well, It is an interesting post never-the-less.
 
Originally Posted by surfimp:
Here's the OP:
 
 
Originally Posted by Madison Kirkman:

I was wondering, what your favorite paint schemes are.  I saw a #50 gang car in the girl colors.  I thought this was interesting, so what are your favorite paint schemes?    

 

 

 

So what he's really asking is what are interesting and/or favorite color schemes for well-known models (i.e. the #50 gang car above).

 

In fairness, I don't think anyone has really responded to /that/ question.

 

It was suppose to be a show your favorite, or what you think is most interesting (since they are different) but I was trying to ask for favorite model train with a paint scheme that is not found any full size locomotive, and that is kinda unique.  Like the #50, which is painted in the girl colors, which is unlike even any other model I have seen.  I guess that is kind of a long question though. 

For the OP, I found an interesting locomotive theme.

 

Lionel 2012 Ready To Run Catalog, pages 30 and 31:

Hershey's O Gauge Freight Set

0-8-0 locomotive and tender in Hershey's chocolate

Various freight cars of various Hershey products, e.g., Reeses, Twizzlers, Krackel, Kisses, etc. 

 

Not recommended for those with Type 1 or 2 diabetes. 

The monopoly cars were kind of unique too. 
 
Originally Posted by TM Terry:

For the OP, I found an interesting locomotive theme.

 

Lionel 2012 Ready To Run Catalog, pages 30 and 31:

Hershey's O Gauge Freight Set

0-8-0 locomotive and tender in Hershey's chocolate

Various freight cars of various Hershey products, e.g., Reeses, Twizzlers, Krackel, Kisses, etc. 

 

Not recommended for those with Type 1 or 2 diabetes. 

 

Originally Posted by Bob Delbridge:

The "Citrus" scheme Seaboard Air Line used on this E4A IMO is most interesting (although I like the scheme with the roof painted dark green better, dirt/grime wasn't as noticeable).  The pilot on this engine reminds me of a suit of armor:

 

 

sal3002

 

And as much as I love my Seaboard, the Great Northern "Glacier" paint scheme is my favorite.


Hey bob!!My grand parents used to tell about the trains they saw.When they were younger.This is one of the locomotives they saw.And I agree with you on this one pretty slick paintjob.I also liked the one that white and red paintjob.By the time I came on to the world.It was the seaboard coast line I liked that one to the herold on the front.Of the locomotives and the orange cabosse with the black lettering.

Originally Posted by Madison Kirkman:

It was suppose to be a show your favorite, or what you think is most interesting (since they are different) but I was trying to ask for favorite model train with a paint scheme that is not found any full size locomotive, and that is kinda unique.  Like the #50, which is painted in the girl colors, which is unlike even any other model I have seen.  I guess that is kind of a long question though. 

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • $T2eC16: Tyco Fictional Roadname, interesting paint scheme HO scale had 2 of these as a kid

I am with Wowak....With Kirkman's example, interesting might apply to the girl's

train and the Marx bunny train, both "Edsel" marketing failures.   The center fold

in the 1941 Locomotive Cyclopedia has many colorful and attention getting liveries

on early cab units.  But there I would have to pick a favorite, and it might be for my

bias for a favorite railroad, and not the most striking and colorful.  Interesting might

include the Triplex, as a model of an unsuccessful locomotive.  Prototype example

might be the ancient locomotive  built with all weight on its drivers to climb the

very steep rise from the Ohio River bank up out of the valley in Madison, Ind. to connect Indianapolis with river traffic.  That loco was in the basement of the Indianapolis Children's Museum when I saw it, and the little or not used track still

in place down the grade to the Ohio's riverbank.  Interesting might apply to the question: "How many different, distinct brands of O gauge three rail trains, producing any RTR rolling stock, not a kit, have been made?"

Originally Posted by Ron045:

Love the NS Executive Office Car Special.  It's always a thrill to watch it come through our town.

 

IMG_0098 [972 x 648)

I was lucky enough to get the MTH DAP set when it was released and it's my favorite. I saw it right after getting the set a few years ago going through Gainesville but didn't have a camera with me. The other day I stopped at the bank ATM across from Lowe's in Gainesville and was halfway through the transaction when I heard the roar of a approaching diesel and a glance over my shoulder and I caught a glimpse of the NS F-7's coming through the trees at the bend. Pulled out my Blackberry and shot a short video clip. Got the shot even though as you hear someone tries to go to the ATM machine with it still open with my information in it. lol!

 

 

Originally Posted by Passenger Train Collector:

Paul:

 

What a wonderful video. You sure were Johnny-on-the-spot. This is one passenger train that I missed and I sure wish I has it.

 

 

That was my lucky day, same as when I purchased the set was a lucky one for me. The DAP sets had been delivered before I heard about them and called around and found a dealer that had a complete set. The lucky thing was the day I called. It was the store's anniversary that day and they had a sale on everything in the store, if memory serves me correct it was an additional 25% off!

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×