Skip to main content

Good evening guys, my next door neighbor brought me over the other night to look at some trains that a guy was thinking about selling.  They were his Uncle's trains and he has no interest in them what-so-ever.  He was asking me if I could maybe give him some kind of value or what I thought they would be worth.  Tucked away in a briefcase, was a 4-6-4 #322 which seems to be in fair condition.  It is however, missing a wheel set on the tender.  I've never seen one of these, don't have any idea if it runs or not.  Would some of you that are very knowledgeable about the AF line of trains, can you give me some kind of an idea as to what it might be worth and maybe a little background as to when it might possibly have been made or when it came out.  There was also an Audio Engineer in the box with it.  Have no clue what that is or how it works.

 

Any help you all can give me will be most appreciated.  You can contact me direct if you like, sptrainnut@att.net, just make sure you mention AF 322 in the subject line.  I can supply photos if necessary.

 

Thanks for your help, it is greatly appreciated.

 

J. Motts

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I am not an AF expert but have had experience rebuilding some old clunkers. First, the engine gets its electricity through the tender wheels then through a tether from the tender in to the engine.Both weak points but you can touch wires to the engine to see i it runs. If it runs, it will need cleaned and lubed like a Lionel, if not then there is a problem, probably in your power supply. If it doesn't run, not worth much except if someone wants to fool with it.

Jim is right.

First off confirm which variant you have:

I restored my Dad's collection and the 322 is a nice locomotive. It smokes nice, pulls well, and is a great operating locomotive. There is a smoke in tender version and a diaphragm box for the chuff this variant has a link coupler.

The other variant has the chuff piston in the tender and the smoke unit with a "standard coupler" and it is usually marked 322AC

 

 

2029829_1_l

 

322AC-tender

 

The smoke in tender variant tends to catch less money and this is my feeling why:

1) The diaphragm tends to tear and the chuff is lost and no parts to repair but you can still fix it by fabricating up a new diaphragm.

2) the smoke unit is not as robust as smoke unit in the engine and it tends to squeal sometimes.

3) The smoke unit transfer holes between the tender and the locomotive comes off during running and it tends to have a smoke out the cab malfunction.

4) Production numbers on the link coupler 322 where higher than its variants

5) Link couplers can be upgraded, but I tend to shy away from them

6) the smoke fluid fill sticks up out of the coal bunker.

 

If you find the 326, or the 5 digit Hudson, call me. They are the most sought after. '

They have the pullmore motor and the 326 had a noise in the tender that was so called a "whistle". They are harder to find.

 

BTW, test the E unit, sticking E units are easily fixed but you have to know the secret...

 

 

 

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 2029829_1_l
  • 322AC-tender
Last edited by J Daddy

BTW some 326 Hudson's  had small motors as well. No rhyme or reason here... you have to flip them over and confirm they have a larger housing and magnet length.

If you have the 5 digit locomotive in good shape they tend to be worth allot more because of the numbers produced and the being the last ones made before American Flyer went out of business.

 

 

K335-large-motor

 

 

AF21130-NYC-AFL-Hudson

Attachments

Images (2)
  • K335-large-motor
  • AF21130-NYC-AFL-Hudson

Gilbert made several versions of the 4-6-4 Hudson, starting with the 320 released in 1946.  Since you mentioned the 322 specifically, it appears to have had three variants - two of which had the smoke and choo-choo mechanism in the tender and the last variant had the smoke and choo-choo in the boiler, with the reversing unit moved to the tender.  This has some effect on price - though I'd guess that condition is at least as important.

 

You can get some feel for the kinds of prices these engines command by looking at eBay - which has a reasonable search engine.  So by searching on 322 (within the S scale section of the Model Railroads and Trains category), you get:

 

http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html...322&_sacat=19143

 

There aren't too many current listings for this engine.  Although the picture taking capabilities of the eBay posters vary widely (leading you to wonder if some of them ever look at the pictures they post), you can get a sense of the condition of the engines being sold.

Originally Posted by J Daddy:

The other variant has the chuff piston in the tender and the smoke unit with a "standard coupler" and it is usually marked 322AC

 

 

322AC-tender

 


 

I'm not quite sure what you mean when you refer to the 322AC. This version had the smoke and choo-choo in the boiler and the reverse unit in the tender (as did all the Hudsons until the 5-digit versions). The coupler would have been of the link variety, typically with a black weight.

Last edited by Craig Donath
Originally Posted by J Daddy:

Here is the 1946 version:

 

 

05-American Flyer - 322 Hudson - Reverse In Cab - New York Central on tender - No Logo - Link Coupler - 1946

Not to pick nits, but the 322 in the photo, while beautiful, is not exactly how a "stock" 322 from 1946 would appear. Most likely the one depicted has been nicely refinished and "updated" with later generation parts. The 1946 version would have come with blackened handrails and an unweighted link coupler (typically with a black pin). The crosshead guides would have been of the "two-prong" style. The L-shaped version on this example was not introduced until some time in the 1948 model run. To my eye the lettering on the tender doesn't look quite original (maybe a tad too tall?), but I can't say for sure. Otherwise, this is a lovely unit.

 

EDIT: I found the source of the above photo on:

 

http://www.americanflyerexpres...press-hudsons-01.htm

 

It appears that the same locomotive is used to show variations through the years with couplers, lettering, and other features overlayed on the unit to illustrate the differences. The illustrations are pretty slick, although stuff like the broken step on the tender is a giveaway.

 

[/end thread hijack]

Last edited by Craig Donath

Evening Guys,

 

I want to thank all of you for all of your help and comments.  They were exactly what I was hoping for and I passed the info along to the guy to whom it belongs to.  I tried earlier to post a couple of pics of the loco and tender but for some reason it wasn't happening.  However, the last pic posted of the 1946 version looks exactly like the one I was describing but not in as good a condition as that one.  It was also missing the rear coupler on the tender too.  I really don't think it is worth very much.

 

Again, I thank you all very much for your help.  Have a good one and happy modeling.

 

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×