Skip to main content

My knowledge of this topic is very limited. I have a number of newer engines, Lionel, Weaver and MTH that all have some sort of railsounds based on their age.I have a number of older conventional engines which have no sounds. I have looked at some of the railsound manufacturers. My question is about adding a board and speaker etc to several older conventional engines ( a 1950's generation F3 set for example) to get some realistic sounds from it. I am simply exploring this possibilities and wonder what the success rate is for this and whether someone with my limited capability should be attempting this. As usual, any advice is much appreciated, Bill

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Electric Railroad  Company (ERR by Third Rail) offers a nice selection of sound systems, and by going to their website you can listen to them on the Cloud. Their easy to follow instruction manuals are also available on the ERR website. If you can solder they are pretty straight forward installations. Carefully laying out the location of the components is key.  Diesels are usually easier than steam engines, so they can be a good place to start.

Last edited by modeltrainsparts

Bill,

If you're not into soldering or tinkering there are other choices, although they're not necessarily prototypically correct.

Lionel has made in the past:

1.) For Steam -- Tenders fitted with RailSounds to replace the one that came with your locomotive.  Two examples are Prod. No. 6-18333 (like the postwar 2426W) and Prod. No. 6-16655 (like the postwar 2046W or 2671WX).  Both of these are older (c.1990's) and have original RailSounds.  There are newer ones that have what is called TrainSounds instead as well.  The sounds are reasonably good but if you're a stickler for accuracy the chuff doesn't synchronize perfectly with the position of the running gear on the locomotive.

2,) For Diesel -- Boxcars fitted with RailSounds to pull immediately behind your engine.  Like above but with Diesel sounds.  An example would be Prod. No. 6-17214.  This specific one is not traditional-sized though, it's scale-sized, so it would look big when placed next to your postwar diesels.  There are others that have traditional sizing, and also TrainSounds versions like the steam TrainSounds version mentioned above, that are newer.

I have one of each, tender and boxcar, they were the first RailSounds equipped products I ever had, and I'm still greatly impressed with them even though RailSounds has evolved significantly since they were introduced.

These tenders and cars are much less trouble than modifying your hardware, but you may prefer to go the modification route with ERR as @modeltrainsparts has suggested, for better realism.

Mike

Last edited by Mellow Hudson Mike

I added sound to an MPC era locomotive which had SOS. The kits are available on ebay for around $100 after shipping and it was easy to install with great instructions provided. I've attached a video with the train traveling at various speeds to hear the sounds. The seller has several options for diesel or steam.

Attachments

Videos (1)
20221101_130556
Last edited by PRRick
@PRRick posted:

I added sound to an MPC era locomotive which had SOS. The kits are available on ebay for around $100 after shipping and it was easy to install with great instructions provided. I've attached a video with the train traveling at various speeds to hear the sounds. The seller has several options for diesel or steam.

Who makes/sells them?

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×