Can shabby, delapidated structures on a layout be a good thing?
Yes!
Do you agree?
Take a look at this beat up Plasticville switch tower:
This switch tower was in a junk box, and I nearly threw it out. It is missing a door and looks like it has broken windows. Here is a close up photo of it:
Here is a pristine version of the same structure at another place on my layout:
Which switch tower do you like better?
I like the shabby one at least as much as the pristine one, and submit that the shabby one is a more realistic model than the pristine one. That is because many RR rights of way are loaded with structures that are abandoned, filthy and falling apart.
If you have any shabby, delapidated structures on your layout, you can post photos of them here and explain why you have them on your layout.
Arnold