Skip to main content

Can shabby, delapidated structures on a layout be a good thing?

Yes!

Do you agree?

Take a look at this beat up Plasticville switch tower:

20210823_224457

This switch tower was in a junk box, and I nearly threw it out. It is missing a door and looks like it has broken windows. Here is a close up photo of it:

20210823_222729

Here is a pristine version of the same structure at another place on my layout:

20210526_214305

Which switch tower do you like better?

I like the shabby one at least as much as the pristine one, and submit that the shabby one is a more realistic model than the pristine one. That is because many RR rights of way are loaded with structures that are abandoned, filthy and falling apart.

If you have any shabby, delapidated structures on your layout, you can post photos of them here and explain why you have them on your layout.

Arnold

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 20210823_224457
  • 20210823_222729
  • 20210526_214305
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Shabby, weatherbeaten structures look more realistic.  Buildings look "showroom fresh" only at ribbon cutting.  As early as 1 year after a new coat of paint the color starts to fade and dust, smoke and smog cling to it.

Here's a picture of a couple of lionel buildings,  a switch tower and crossing shanty I repainted and aged.

20210731_12341820210731_123344

A combination of acrylic paint and then washes.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20210731_123418
  • 20210731_123344

Every downtown needs shabby, rundown and dilapidated buildings.  Not only are they fun to build, but you can never really screw up the weathering.  Here is an Ameritown building repurposed for my Bowery section -





5D9700B9-63DE-410A-A4BD-33D8180FF73576D8A711-D3B0-4F96-8976-911CCE9C7B65

Now THAT is an awesome CBGB building!
Do you have a push button accessory that plays the Ramones or the Talking Heads?

Bryce

Last edited by Oscale_Trains_Lover_

Now THAT is an awesome CBGB building!
Do you have a push button accessory that plays the Ramones or the Talking Heads?

Bryce

Definitely, Bryce.  You can even see copies of actual appearance posters for those bands attached to my model’s front wall.  Although not activated via push button, my train room stereo can often be heard playing those great bands along with others like Iggy Pop, Blondie,  Patti Smith, and David Johansen. I’m fact, on a good day, you might even hear the Police, who also made a few stops at CBGBs back in the late 70s. Would you expect anything less? LOL!

4001A50C-DCF8-44EB-9B13-410038AFED0B

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 4001A50C-DCF8-44EB-9B13-410038AFED0B

The old station didn't look so hot in its prime:

Poug-Schen 020

Then, it really went to heck:

OGRPastFut 001

Poug-Schen 092

Jim

Jim, I have that same station shown in your 1st above photo. Here is mine:

20200822_142500

Do you know what company made it?

I looked at it closely and could not find the name of the manufacturer. Arnold

PS: Jim, you did a great job weathering it.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 20200822_142500
@third rail posted:

Shabby, weatherbeaten structures look more realistic.  Buildings look "showroom fresh" only at ribbon cutting.  As early as 1 year after a new coat of paint the color starts to fade and dust, smoke and smog cling to it.

Here's a picture of a couple of lionel buildings,  a switch tower and crossing shanty I repainted and aged.

20210731_12341820210731_123344

A combination of acrylic paint and then washes.

Gorgeous, Bill.

I think its arguable that the shabby, delapidated and dirty structures have more character, are more interesting and are more realistic than the perfect, clean and neat scale models.

But, to each his own.

Arnold,

If you are looking for some gritty and shabby guidance, just Google:  Franklin and South Manchester Railroad.  It was built by George Selios, owner of Fine Scale Miniatures.

I won't even try to offer a description.  It is amazing.  Some years ago I had the good fortune to visit George and get a layout tour.

Regards,



Lou N

I'll respectfully nominate George Sellios' Franklin & South Manchester HO layout.  An absolute masterpiece of "shabby and dilapidated" modeling.    But, then again, that's what the hard times of 1935 (setting for the railroad) tended to offer...

Too bad the HO scale HDTV DIYers and Fixer Uppers hadn't left a spiffy spot anywhere the last time I looked at the layout photos.

Kudos, George!

@dkdkrd posted:

I'll respectfully nominate George Sellios' Franklin & South Manchester HO layout.  An absolute masterpiece of "shabby and dilapidated" modeling.    But, then again, that's what the hard times of 1935 (setting for the railroad) tended to offer...

Too bad the HO scale HDTV DIYers and Fixer Uppers hadn't left a spiffy spot anywhere the last time I looked at the layout photos.

Kudos, George!

Outstanding, one of the best layouts I've ever seen.

@Forty Rod posted:

Okay, I'm operating an iMac 10 and have downloaded some pics to my computer from my Nikon Coolpix camera.  How do I post them here?



Be kind.  I'm a genuine computer dinosaur, so use small words.



Thanks.

Just drag-and-drop them into the message wherever you want them to appear.

1) Move the pointer over the image.

2) Hold down the mouse/trackpad button

3) While you are holding it down, move the pointer over the desired spot in your message.

4) Relese the button.

Voilà!

Last edited by Avanti

Great posts gentlemen!

I've seen some clever use of Plasticville models on this thread. As your photos demonstrate, they respond well to weathering and complementary settings.

Here's their log cabin secluded in the mountains of my modest size layout. That fellow is keeping his eyes out for passing postwar classics.

L1020910

Attachments

Images (1)
  • L1020910
@dkdkrd posted:

I'll respectfully nominate George Sellios' Franklin & South Manchester HO layout.  An absolute masterpiece of "shabby and dilapidated" modeling.    But, then again, that's what the hard times of 1935 (setting for the railroad) tended to offer...

Too bad the HO scale HDTV DIYers and Fixer Uppers hadn't left a spiffy spot anywhere the last time I looked at the layout photos.

Kudos, George!

Outstanding! He’s even got a Lionel Factory building.  What a work of art.

Outstanding! He’s even got a Lionel Factory building.  What a work of art.

I also have a scratch built Lionel Factory (built by someone else) that I bought at a LHS during the summer, but I don't have it on my layout yet because it's so big. It will be tricky to get it on my layout in the future because it takes up so much space.

20210428_004241

20210428_173532

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20210428_004241
  • 20210428_173532
Last edited by Arnold D. Cribari

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×