Skip to main content

My MTH Premier model of Pennsylvania Railroad G-5s 4-6-0 Ten-Wheeler #5740 (20-3031-1, MSRP $699.95, PS1), delivered in March 1999, is one of my favorites. The first time I saw one was during a visit to the MTH offices in Columbia, MD. I thought it was beautiful and still do. It has also been a reliable runner with a BCR. Photos and video show it running on my 10’-by-5’ model railroad pulling PRR observation car Quaker City.

The first of ninety PRR G-5s Ten-Wheelers was built in 1923 for operation on the hills into the suburbs around Pittsburgh. They were referred to as “Pittsburgh commuter engines”. Thirty-one also ran on the Long Island Rail Road with the last retired in 1955. At a weight of 237,000 pounds and tractive effort of 41,330 pounds, they were the heaviest and most powerful Ten Wheelers ever built.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2023_0920_04_PRR_5740_10X5MELGAR_2023_0920_11_PRR_5740_10X5_BRIDGE_CLOSEUPMELGAR_2023_0920_18_PRR_5740_10X5_SOUTHMELGAR_2023_0920_24_PRR_5740_10X5_SS71MELGAR_2023_0920_26_PRR_5740_10X5_NE

Attachments

Images (5)
  • MELGAR_2023_0920_04_PRR_5740_10X5
  • MELGAR_2023_0920_11_PRR_5740_10X5_BRIDGE_CLOSEUP
  • MELGAR_2023_0920_18_PRR_5740_10X5_SOUTH
  • MELGAR_2023_0920_24_PRR_5740_10X5_SS71
  • MELGAR_2023_0920_26_PRR_5740_10X5_NE
Videos (1)
MELGAR_2023_0920_32V_PRR_5740_10X5_CIRCUIT_34S
Last edited by MELGAR

Mel - in real life, who made the PRR 10 Wheelers?

Mark,

G-5s Ten-Wheelers were made by the Pennsylvania Railroad's Juniata Works at Altoona, PA beginning in 1923. The PRR sold 31 to the Long Island Rail Road (its subsidiary) beginning in 1924. On Long Island, they ran until 1955.

These engines are favorites of mine. When I was a youngster, I used to fly model airplanes at Nassau County Park (Salisbury Park at the time). Long Island Rail Road G-5s #35 was parked (on exhibit) nearby.

MELGAR

MELGAR2_2023_0920_17_PRR_5740_10X5_LHFD

Attachments

Images (1)
  • MELGAR2_2023_0920_17_PRR_5740_10X5_LHFD
Last edited by MELGAR

Interesting. Figured Alco or Baldwin. Did they assemble pre-made parts into the whole, or were they built from the ground up?

I suspect that certain types of parts were outsourced but others were manufactured by the railroad. For example, air-brake components such as compressors, air pressure and water level gauges, low water alarms, feedwater heaters, relief valves, would probably have been bought from specialty manufacturers. Locomotive-specific parts, such as cylinder castings, wheels, locomotive frames, cabs, probably manufactured by the railroad. I didn't work there, so it's just conjecture on my part. The question manufacturers ask themselves is "make or buy?"

MELGAR

Good morning, and welcome to today's edition of STEAMday Sunday.

Remember to comply with the Forum rules, and only post photos and videos you have taken or others in which you have the express permission of the owner to post.

Below is a video of one of my favorite steamers: an MTH PS2 Pennsy turbine running on DCS, hauling MTH Pennsy passenger cars through My Little Town:

Now, let's see the steam engines you would like to share. Arnold

Attachments

Videos (1)
20230930_172244
Last edited by Arnold D. Cribari

Last Steamday Sunday, I posted my MTH Premier model of Pennsylvania Railroad G-5s 4-6-0 Ten-Wheeler #5740. The PRR also built 31 G-5s locomotives for its subsidiary, the Long Island Rail Road, and MTH produced a model of LIRR G-5s #21, an engine that pulled the Sunrise Special, an all-first-class extra-fare summertime train that ran between New York and Montauk during the steam era. The tender had a special herald that was reproduced on the MTH model. The MTH model of LIRR #21 (20-3068-1) was delivered in December 2001 with PS2. The videos, on my 12’-by-8’ layout, show #21 pulling K-Line models of parlor car “Jamaica” and passenger cars of the LIRR Cannonball Express, another summertime train that also ran to Montauk, as they were painted in blue during the 1960s. The last two G-5s locomotives on Long Island were retired in 1955. At a weight of 237,000 pounds and tractive effort of 41,330 pounds, the G-5s was the heaviest and most powerful Ten Wheeler ever built.

MELGAR

MELGAR_2023_0927_10_LIRR_21MELGAR_2023_0927_04_LIRR_21_ENGINEMELGAR_2023_0927_05_LIRR_21_TENDERMELGAR_2023_0927_13_LIRR_21MELGAR_2023_0927_14_LIRR_21MELGAR_2023_0927_17_LIRR_JAMAICA

Attachments

Images (6)
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_10_LIRR_21
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_04_LIRR_21_ENGINE
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_05_LIRR_21_TENDER
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_13_LIRR_21
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_14_LIRR_21
  • MELGAR_2023_0927_17_LIRR_JAMAICA
Videos (2)
MELGAR_2023_0927_18V_LIRR_21_12X8_SOUTH_21S
MELGAR_2023_0927_LIRR_21_12X8_BRIDGE_24S
Last edited by MELGAR

Here is a little gal from the very end of Hornby's production of 0 gauge.  Its the Type 51 loco including the (Post Nationalization) "Lion and Wheel" symbol tender from 1954-1961 (like most Hornby she is clockwork).  She is pulling two Type 31 coaches from around the same era, 1956 - 1965.

Hornby Type 31 coaches and 51 loco

Happy "Steam Sunday"  Hope your week goes well

Don

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Hornby Type 31 coaches and 51 loco

Good morning. To start us off with this STEAMday Sunday, here is a short video of an MTH PS1 Dreyfus Hudson hauling Madison Heavyweight passenger cars that the Babe might have taken to the house he built:

Remember to follow the Forum rules and only post photos and videos you have taken or those taken by others in which you have their express written permission to post them. Arnold

Attachments

Videos (1)
20230427_122622
Last edited by Arnold D. Cribari

Happy StDaySun!  Today l’d like to show you one of my favorite steamers, a MTH Premier B&M P3 Pacific, no. 3702.

No. 3702 isn’t an accurate model of a P3; the P3 was made by Alco, but the model is actually a Baldwin P47.  This discrepancy doesn’t bother me at all.  I still thoroughly enjoy this great looking, fine running engine.

John

12F0BB7E-D3C7-4FDD-966E-542C6FCEFB14

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 12F0BB7E-D3C7-4FDD-966E-542C6FCEFB14
Videos (1)
IMG_0396

Boston & Albany #403 is a K-Line model of a 4-6-6T Class D-1a steam locomotive of the type that was used in commuter service around Boston. The quality and detail of this model are outstanding. It has the original electronics so it runs best above 10 Volts AC and somewhat fast. The video shows it running at 42 scale miles-per-hour on my 10'-by-5' layout. As used around Boston until 1951, these locomotives did run fast. The chugging at that speed sounds very realistic to me and seems to be at four chuffs per revolution. Probably my nicest steamer...

MELGAR

Attachments

Videos (1)
MELGAR_2023_0930_03V_B&A_403_10X5_CIRCUIT_24S

Well STEAMSunday fans here is a clockwork locomotive for you.  This is the Hafner 1010 locomotive, in clockwork (Hafner never made any electric trains), which was made in a wide variety of color's and trims beginning around 1938 and continuing after the war, into the middle/late 1940's.  

Hafner 1010 Red loco front Hafner 1010 Red loco quarterHafner 1010 Red loco side

Best Wishes for your Sunday.  Hope your upcoming week goes well.

Don

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Hafner 1010 Red loco front
  • Hafner 1010 Red loco quarter
  • Hafner 1010 Red loco side
@Steam Crazy posted:

MELGAR, is the cruise control on?  My K-line engines run much faster with the cruise off (and draw a lot less current).  It should run slower with the cruise on. although I've found my engines sometimes run erratically  on cruise under conventional control.

John

@Steam Crazy,

John

The cruise control is off. The locomotive barely moves if cruise control is on.

MELGAR

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×