Skip to main content

So after so many years of other priorities with a house and a kid, the slow process of fixing up the basement, I finally am out of the dreaming phase and getting close. I have benchwork built and I finally figured out how to use a design program. Even though my space is relatively small (9' wide, 13.5 left leg, to 12.5 feet right leg in length thanks to a door), I wanted to have an O72 outer loop (I have a scale Williams Brass Hudson).

I also wanted a two track main line (love watching two trains pass each other), wanted a small dock area, an engine house area and some industrial trackage.  I managed to achieve this, with some tradeoffs. Because I didn't want to have to use access panels, I made the layout the squared off U shape to allow easy access rather than a solid table, which among other thing didn't allow for a reversing loop. Track is all Ross Custom track and switches, for the straight track I'll likely use Gargraves flex track and cut it to size, the curves I'll use standard Ross pieces and cut to fit. One thing this doesn't show, on the right hand table there are  4" diameter support poles at 56" and 133" from the top of the table right next to the aisle (I don't know why they don't show, this was done in rail modeler).  Other than the table, which is built, I am not constrained with this design, curious what others think.  I suspect when I actually build this I'll end up changing things, it is inevitable but this design allows me to actually identify what I'll need to build it (unfortunately, likely will mean delaying buying the track for the foreseeable future, given the not insignificant cost and current circumstances, another example of unfortunate timing; as others have said, it is otherwise a great time to be working on a layout 

The dock area is on the bottom left, the 4 track switch on the right side feeds the engine house and storage tracks.

layout2 picture 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • layout2 picture
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

It looks like a nice plan for running two trains as you say.  So the little yard is for engines and not cars.  Would you want car storage yard on the other side of the open space?  Does this plan fit up against any walls?  If so, you may be tight on clearance on the two sides.

It is actually similar to the plan I am building except mine is continuous twice around with the track crossing over top of itself on the second go round.

I am not planning on a car storage yard as such, though I could decide to add it later, I debated having a car storage yard on the left side of the layout, but I kind of figured that having open space there would leave room for a town with structures, so I didn't try to execute it. There is a wall on the right side of the right leg, and that could cause problems with clearence (on the left side, that is all open). I suspect I'll be doing some jiggling with track, probably will need to shorten the straight segments in the loops to bring the track away from the edges, given my inexperience with using design software it is inevitable I'll find those gotchas. 

I think at this point it is about building the layout, seeing what works and what doesn't, and changing things as needed. I may try to build an elevated section above the main tracks on the right side and have a mostly background cityscape with a train station in the foreground with stairs to the tracks underneath, as one possibility. The table features like 4" of foam over plywood, so I can easily create sub track level features, too, to make it interesting, it won't be the flat landscape this looks like at the moment either.

Unless you’re using a computer display that is taller than it is wide, you’ll get more useable workspace by rotating the layout 90° so the longer section is on the X axis.

With all the rails being displayed I can’t make out the text and the image is too blurry to zoom. I can’t tell what size curves are going to the 4-way storage yard on the right or what size the curved switch is, but I’d try to move that whole section up to allow for longer storage tracks. Right now you’ve got 24” for the switches and maybe only around 36” for storage.

On the left side, you might get a little more siding length by relocating the upper switch on the curve. I can’t really tell what is planned for the space between the siding and the main track, it’s quite a large space.

I don’t know how you plan to operate, but if you pull a train off toward the yard, you have to pull far enough into the yard to be able to back across to the siding on the left and the train has to be short enough to clear the curved switch. I don’t know how reliable the curved switches are for backing a train through them. If you back into the yard, you have pretty much the same limitations. Not sure there’s any way to do things differently, but I’d try a regular switch near where the curved switch is to see if I could get more room on the yard side. The curves up there might be too wide for that though.

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×