Skip to main content

I enjoy learning to repair old trains and accessories by simply tearing them apart and tinkering with them till they work. Beyond a VERY rudimentary understanding of the electricity principals involved and what I can read in my trusty Greenberg PW repair book, I have much to learn. So, pardon me if this is a simple/obvious issue to those with much better mechanical aptitude and train repair experience.

 

I have an original 164 whose motor just sits and hums.  I've gone through my usual troubleshooting steps with no success. Visual inspection showed one of the brushes stuck in its tube and not making contact with commutator. After loosening/cleaning that brush tube, cleaning the commutator, removing grime from grooves in commutator, nothing.  It still just hums, even when I bypass most wiring and put "juice" directly to the motor, nothing. What other troubleshooting ideas can you recommend?  New brushes?  

 

Thanks for taking time to read and make suggestions. Each of these "problems" is another great opportunity to learn more about train repair.

 

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If the armature spins freely, but the motor just hums when power is supplied, then I would suspect a short or incorrect wiring. Examine the wiring. Look to see if one of the wires is touching "ground". Take a transformer with a pair to wires (test leads) and set the voltage to around 6 volts. Apply power to the ends of the field wires only. Does the field become magnetic (attract a screwdriver)? If so, then the field is probably ok.

 

If you have a VOM, check the armature. There should be somewhere around 1-2 ohms resistance between any two commutator segments. All combinations should be tested, and all should have the same resistance.

Check for continuity between each segment and the armature shaft. There should not be a circuit (infinite ohms).

 

Back to the wiring. Generally, the power wire should go to one of the brush holders. One of the field wires should be connected to the other brush tube. The second field wire should go to ground.

There should not be any other wires.

Test the motor by applying power to the "power wire brush holder" and to ground.

Applying power any other way could cause your hum.

Thanks to all for the suggestions. 

 

CW -  I got out trusty multimeter and tried the tests you suggested. Commutator segments to armature shaft yielded infinite Ohms. Commutator segments are not behaving as well. When I test them in combination, only one adjacent pair show resistance (a little less than 1 Ohm). The other two pairs show 0 Ohms-same as if I cross the two meter leads. 

 

Long shot was the right shot!  I thought I had removed all the gunk-but there must have been some remaining. After a more careful cleaning (thanks for the mineral spirits tip), the thing runs great. Now all I need to do us find part number 164-50 - the lighting assembly that fits under the roof. Seems it was removed by the previous owner!  

 

Thanks so much for all the help. I learned a lot and managed to get the thing going. Good fun for a

holiday weekend.  

I should have mentioned this earlier.
Apparently there is more than one type of mineral spirits on the market today.

Some mineral spirits is cut with water and emusifiers.

Reportedly one such product is Klean-Strip Green 1 gallon Odorless Mineral Spirits.

I accidentally purchased some and found that it did not work well for me.

I only use pure mineral spirits.

 

 

Here is the info for Dennis Waldron. I did not check there because they don't have an online parts source. I checked Olsens, Dr.Tinker, Stan Orr,George Tbolt, Jeff Kane, and several others.

 

What is the phone number for Customer Service?

You may reach Customer Service us  1-973-702-0545.

What is your mailing address?

Just Trains
1 Ridge Circle
Sussex, New Jersey 07461

Be sure to include a stamped preaddressed envelope as well as your  telephone number as part of your communication to us!

Can I reach you from outside of the United States?

You can call us at 011-973-702-0545.

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×