Skip to main content

So I have several accessories that I plan to set up on my future layout and most of them didn't come with the original switch.  I have been using on/off toggle switches for these accessories, but am contemplating using momentary push button switches for some or all of them.  The accessories I am talking about are the 397 coal loader, an oil barrel loader, the culvert loader and unloader, the 364 log loader, and the 362 barrel loader.  I also have a 97 coal tower, the 164 log loader, and a 497 loader, but I do have original switches for them and plan to still use the original on those items.  The reason I am thinking about using momentary switches is because of kids.  For example, my oil barrel loader sometimes drops a barrel, or it sticks on the chute mechanism.  If you aren't paying attention and don't stop it immediately, it could cause the forklift to jamb into or over a barrel causing possible damage.  With a momentary switch, it would be easy to stop the forklift as you have to hold the button.  Same goes for the other accessories, kids sometimes tend to not pay attention and they end up forgetting to stop an accessory as it spills coal or logs onto the track or somewhere else.  So what is you opinion... momentary vs. on/off switches?  Advantages/Disadvantages?

Thanks

Last edited by c.demille
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I think you are correct - a momentary contact switch fits the use of some accessories - any loader, etc. would be one and would put it on - nothing else in fact.  If you've setting it up for kids to operate (push button on the side of layout where they can reach it, etc.,  it may be a good idea to install a master toggle switch that controls the power to all the accessories there, so you can shut them all off if you need to. 

I like the master toggle switch idea.  My layout won't be real big though so it may be just as quick to reach for the transformer.  So anyone have experience with different types of momentary switches?  I could go for the lionel no. 90 switches and pay a lot, but I was just thinking about using one from Radio Shack.

I use an old Lionel #90 control with the 362 barrel loader.  Definitely gives you finer control over what can be a troublesome accessory. I don't have a oil drum loader but that would be a another perfect candidate.

 

I have a PW style layout so I like to use the #90 and 364c switches to enhance the overall "look." I try to grab them on ebay when I can  get them at decent prices.

 

 

 

 

My Run Room Trackside Industries area has been set up for "kids" for several years with all those accessories.  Most need the on/off toggle switches because the action takes a while.  Holding down a momentary switch for a complete cycle is beyond the attention span.

Protect the accessories from damage with circuit protection sized correctly so they trip on overload.  When "kids" are loading and unloading coal, logs, milk cans, cattle, horses, barrels, etc. you're going to find all the products in very unusual places when you reset everything after the play session.  You will also have a short "Bad Order" list for repairs.  Mothers will run around behind kids picking up pieces of coal.  Fathers don't worry about it.  My Run Room rule is "Divert kids to something else instead of saying No".

The 164 log loader and 97 coal elevator need one on/off toggle and one mom toggle or button. The 362 barrel loader needs 2 on/off toggles or 1 spdt.  The 364 conveyor log loader needs an on/off toggle plus mom dump toggle/button.  For the 497 loader you will probably want to use the 497 controller.

 

364 Conveyor Log Loader dump track and controls

 

wmadvrcsplate

Attachments

Images (1)
  • wmadvrcsplate
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×