Rocky Mountaineer:
Thanks for the update on Atlas-O's 21" (85' scale) plastic CZ cars. These are beautiful cars, although I do not plan to buy any of them. I like that they are based on the Budd prototype CZ cars.
Erik C Lindgren:
Are your photos of the BLI HO CZ car & locos ?
Erik, Matt, & Hot Water:
Though the E5 units were not the CZ's primary power, there are many photos of E5s on the point of the CZ. A great example is the b&w cover photo on Rich Wilson's book "Burlington Route Through the Heartland". The Q also used the E5 units as the quintessential Zephyr power in their advertising for the entire Zephyr fleet in the 1950s & 1960s and on the timetable covers of this same period. Therefore, our O-scale CZ trains would be well served in style if anyone ever produces a model of the E5 for us. My guess is the E5 tooling costs for only one RR (CB&Q) make this prospect financially unattractive for the manufacturers.
Possible Atlas-O Trainman 60' (15-16") CZ Cars ?
After Atlas-O has completed all of the orders for the whole scale 85' (21") CZ cars, will they decide to offer a TrainMan semi-scale 60' (15-16") or 70' (18") CZ cars. Although I love the CZ & all things Zephyr, my shelves are too full for the 21" Atlas-O CZ cars. I also remember that John Shankland only ran the 70' scale (18") CZ cars on his Chicago layout because he felt that the 85' cars looked unprototypical due to the large amount of overhang on his 120" O-gauge curves. My eventual layout will be limited to either O-72 or O-84, so I plan to stay with the semi-scale 60' (15-16") aluminum model CZ cars. However, I would consider buying Trainman 60' CZ cars if offered in select car-types (diners, sleepers, baggage, extra domes, etc) to fill out my 60' CZ fleet.
I already have Lionel's three six-car aluminum 60' (15-16") CZ sets [for D&RGW, WP, and CB&Q], Lionel's six-car aluminum 60' (15-16") CB&Q Texas Zephyr set, K-Line's six-car aluminum 60' (15-16") CZ set (mix from all three roads), MTH's Premier seven-car 70' (18") aluminum CZ set (CB&Q). To me, the chromed aluminum really has the prototypical Zephyr consist look more than any plastic model. The chromed aluminum looks like Zephyr stainless steel to me & these models appear to be based generically on the Budd prototype cars.
I am aware of Lionel's recent six car 70' scale (18") aluminum CZ cars (D&RGW and WP) but have not bought any of them.
I did buy an MTH 70' plastic CZ CB&Q full-length vista dome car (yes, I know that CB&Q only had one full-length dome but it was in GN's Empire Builder livery) to go with the MTH 70' aluminum CZ cars. The model does appear to be based on the Budd prototype.
I do not like the MTH plastic 60' & 70plastic streamlined cars Pullman-Standard or ACF prototype (instead of the Budd prototypes). This is most noticeable to me on the roof details (width-wise joints instead of Budd's length-wise corrugations) and the dome shape (flat window glass instead of Budd's curved window glass). The silver paint also does not replicate stainless steel to me.
We are fortunate to have all of these choices for O-scale & O-gauge CZ equipment. Collect & operate what you like & enjoy !
CBQ&Q Bill