Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

@superwarp1 posted:

Ditto, Why Lionel doesn't get it is beyond me.

Because they sell toy trains not model railroad items.  Years ago I spoke with someone at USA Trains at a garden railroad convention and he told me they did not want model railroaders coming into the garden railroad area.  They are too picky he said, they only want to sell to people who are happy with what they sell as is.

Those are some nice Geeps. The Cotton Belt and New Haven look awesome. That SP Black Widow is one of my favorite paint schemes. I'm still debating on buying one of 3rd Rail's new Amtrak Siemens ALC-42 Chargers. Those look awesome, and I want a Charger handling passenger services on my new layout (which I'll be starting sometime in the next few months).

@breezinup posted:

Oh, Lionel gets it. These Geeps with their fixed pilots require 054 curves and 072 switches. For Lionel's market (MTH, too), that dog don't hunt.

3rd rail's fixed pilots are great, and they even include conversion kits to make the pilots look even better with Kadee's.

While I do like Lionel's Kenematic Pilots as an in-between solution, why don't the big companies devise a solution that involves optional fixed pilots you can screw into the frame/chassis, similar to the conversion kits I mentioned with 3rd Rail?

@breezinup posted:

Oh, Lionel gets it. These Geeps with their fixed pilots require 054 curves and 072 switches. For Lionel's market (MTH, too), that dog don't hunt.

I agree. Some of you guys who think that a THREE RAIL locomotive not having fixed pilots is somehow supposed to be a "deal breaker" just kill me. These are MODEL TRAINS! If you want fixed pilots on all diesels, then go the 2-rail scale route. But as breeze suggests above, you'll need acres of layout space to accommodate those required wide curves.

I for one, like the way the non-fixed pilots move when they go around a curve, then straighten out again. For me, it's part of the fun of operating toy trains. The video below shows a GP7A coupled to a GP9B rounding one of my tight 036 curves and I love it. I like being able to get locomotives around tight curves and watching the pilots move a little to do it. The movement isn't that great anyway, even on 036 curves.

Attachments

Videos (1)
IMG_6305

Nothing at all wrong with toy trains, but I’m glad Scott sells locomotives with fixed pilots and proper steps, handrails and other details. I wish the MTH DL-109’s came that way.

Perhaps one day Scott will be crazy enough to offer a 3rd Rail DL-109. That would blow my budget right to Mars—I’d have to have a couple New Haven models, plus the Santa Fe pair…



Jeff C

I agree. Some of you guys who think that a THREE RAIL locomotive not having fixed pilots is somehow supposed to be a "deal breaker" just kill me. These are MODEL TRAINS! If you want fixed pilots on all diesels, then go the 2-rail scale route. But as breeze suggests above, you'll need acres of layout space to accommodate those required wide curves.

I for one, like the way the non-fixed pilots move when they go around a curve, then straighten out again. For me, it's part of the fun of operating toy trains. The video below shows a GP7A coupled to a GP9B rounding one of my tight 036 curves and I love it. I like being able to get locomotives around tight curves and watching the pilots move a little to do it. The movement isn't that great anyway, even on 036 curves.



Oh, the horror of someone wanting a more prototypical product with superior detail and scale fidelity!  Whatever is this world coming to?

@GG1 4877 posted:

Oh, the horror of someone wanting a more prototypical product with superior detail and scale fidelity!  Whatever is this world coming to?

No horror, Jonathan. What I’m hinting at is that you’re probably going to find more prototypical features in 2-rail scale stuff like fixed pilots, etc., from manufacturers like Sunset Models, than you are from manufacturers like Lionel and MTH. Since it appears that you have both, this is probably nothing new to you.

As breeze stated (for Lionel and MTH), “that dog don’t hunt.” We just can’t and don’t, get everything from all manufacturers.

Last edited by Yellowstone Special
@Cmontagna posted:

Here is a glimpse at the Conrail GP9!



After drawing this painting diagram and seeing the sample model, I really wanted one in this paint scheme in 3 rail as all my Conrail is 3 rail.  I stayed away from it for two reasons:

  1. I have 5 GP7s from Run 1 and really don't need more.  Want more?  Absolutely!  Need?  Maybe not so much so.
  2. It was nice enough that I was thinking that I would start transitioning all my east coast railroads to 2 rail.  I've been pretty good so far with sticking with 1950's PRR and CNJ in 2 rail so I don't go overboard like I do with my 3 rail collecting and modeling which now features such name trains as the "City of Everywhere", the "Broadway Unlimited", and the "Chromatic Spectrum Comet". 



More run 1 photos of one of my CNJ GP7s.  The only non-brass O scale Geep that correctly depicts the flat long hood that held lighting equipment that was an EMD option that several roads purchased including the CNJ, C&NW, and B&M.  While my CNJ unit doesn't have the unique class lights, it is a nice rendition for my fleet.  I have four of these as by 1953 CNJ had retired all but a very few of their steam locomotives and the 13 GP7Ps made up the single largest class of passenger diesels for the CNJ  until GP40Ps arrived in 1969.

GP7P3

While not Geeps, my 3 rail SD7 and 2 rail SD9 show that you don't have to compromise much to get great scale fidelity.  The 3 rail version will run on 0-54 curves.  A shameless plug for Run 2 of these awesome locomotives.  A shoutout to forum member "Hotwater" for getting me the actual EMD painting diagram on the demo SD7.  That was huge!

20161130_19130420161201_122729

Attachments

Images (3)
  • GP7P3
  • 20161130_191304
  • 20161201_122729
Last edited by GG1 4877
@Ian Munro posted:

GG1 4877

Very nice. When are we likely to see the 2nd run of SD7/9s?

Ian

Ian,

While I can't speak for Scott's business planning as it is always in flux based on factory capacity, I suspect that the 2nd run will go into production after the SD40-2s are completed near the end of this year or perhaps before depending on several factors that I'm not a party to.  Regardless, they are going to happen sooner than later. 

@leikec posted:

I would love to order the SP tiger stripe SD7. What radius curve does it require in 2-rail? Will it handle a 49.5” radius curve ok?

Jeff C.  

The answer is ......

....... maybe ......

The models are tested on a 54" radius for 2 rail operation, but that doesn't mean it won't work on a 48" radius.  It just hasn't been tested on it.  Wish I had better info.  I know the Geeps will do fine on 48" but as you know a 4 axle road switchers will do better on the tighter curves.

Last edited by GG1 4877

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×