Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I see and know that.  I was actually confused by Steve's question.  Is that all he wanted to know or was he trying for a more specific identification?  That's why I asked.

But here is the thing that is somewhat confusing.  I think the photo may have been taken in late September 1948 at a Whistle Stop on Truman's campaign train.  The fore mentioned first car I think may have said Back Truman!  Now as you pointed out the lettering change was authorized in June 1946 and most sources say that the GS's were re-lettered within a year?  If we dig deep enough might be able to find what SP Loco actually pulled his train on what days or vice versa.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...residential_campaign

Last edited by MainLine Steam

This is the question I received

Steve

Do you know anyone in TCA or TTOS or wherever that is an SP fan and could help me identify an engine in a newsreel (dated September, 1943), pulling a huge consist of passenger cars from San Francisco into Los Angeles...
It does not appear to me to be one of the big 4-8-4 GS locomotives... One person I asked suggested it might be a 4-8-2 with the skyline casing (which makes it look like a GS locomotive... These engines apparently received the daylight decoration in 1940, so the time frame would be correct... And he noted that the locomotive has the pre-1947 lettering scheme, so that, too, fits the time period...
The film is too dim for me to make out the number on the engine... Looks like 4345 -- which WAS a 4-8-2, but again, just a guess...

I have a 40" monitor and it is really hard to make out the 2nd and 3rd digit of the number.  The second number could be a 3 or a 4 and the 3rd number looks like a 4 or a 5, but this is a tough one.  I am going to suggest that is indeed a GS-4 and the perspective of the image makes it look shorter than it actually is.

Last edited by GG1 4877

Steve - Thanks for clearing that up.  Does he know the title of the news real?  Sometimes you can back-track that to decipher more information, plus there may be other "frames" which could confirm or deny what we think.  BTW make sure the date was Sept 1943 NOT 1948.  A hand written 8 could look like a 3 this many years later.

I am with Jonathan and Hot Water it is a GS-4 largely because of the all-weather cab.

The large crowd made me think of the Truman Campaign Train.  And they all seemed focused toward the back of the train.  Actually I am going to start a post to gather information on those Tours.  It is an interesting point in America History, definitely train related!

This is the question I received

Steve

Do you know anyone in TCA or TTOS or wherever that is an SP fan and could help me identify an engine in a newsreel (dated September, 1943), pulling a huge consist of passenger cars from San Francisco into Los Angeles...
It does not appear to me to be one of the big 4-8-4 GS locomotives... One person I asked suggested it might be a 4-8-2 with the skyline casing (which makes it look like a GS locomotive... These engines apparently received the daylight decoration in 1940, so the time frame would be correct... And he noted that the locomotive has the pre-1947 lettering scheme, so that, too, fits the time period...
The film is too dim for me to make out the number on the engine... Looks like 4345 -- which WAS a 4-8-2, but again, just a guess...

Please remember:

1) The SP 4300 MT class locomotives did NOT have all-weather cabs.

2) The SP 4300 MT class locomotives did NOT have a huge tender as shown in the photo.

3) I don't recall that the SP 4300 MT class locomotives were equipped with boosters on the trailing truck.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×