Skip to main content

I'm looking for comments others have had with MTH subway out and back accuracy.  This is a real neat feature, especialy with all the stop anouncements.

 

My route setup is 60' long L shaped level track with two intermediate stops (four total stations). The only concern I have is both MTH PS2 Subways travel a little further on the return trip that on outbound causing an overshhoot condition to accumulate. The BMT (100 odometer) averages 1/2" per trip or 5"total in 30 minutes. The LoV (1000 odometer) is higher than that.  I tried the following with no improvement- varying speed between 15 and 40, running only the power unit, removing the two intermediate stops.

 

Barry's Companion Manual is essential in setup and understanding how it all works. But his solution to overshooting seems to sugest just live with it (or am I reading it wrong?)

 

I can live with dragging the engine every 1/2 hour to correct for drift. But I was wondering what experience others have with addressing out and back accuracy. 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Bob,

Barry's Companion Manual is essential in setup and understanding how it all works. But his solution to overshooting seems to sugest just live with it

That's not entirely correct.

 

It is true that if the route tends to creep a bit with each successive run, attempting to eliminate the creep completely is like attempting to teach a pig to sing - it frustrates you and annoys the pig.

 

However, page 107 in The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition provides a few techniques to use to minimize the problem:

There are a few additional things that can be done to improve accuracy, however, it's unlikely that any route will run perfectly for an infinite number of loops. Accuracy can be improved by doing the following: 

• Take great care to end the loop exactly where it started 

• Go slow and brake gradually when entering each station 

• Ensure that all traction tires are in place and not overly slick or worn 

• Check the tracks carefully for any power or conductivity issue that can cause the subway or trolley to 

pause or stutter during its playback in Auto mode 

• Stop the PS2 subway or trolley and note as closely as possible exactly where the beginning of the 

engine is located in the station 

• Keep the tracks clean 

• When playing back the route, keep the speed to 20 or 25 SMPH.

 

Further, as discussed on page 108, using 2 remotes when programing a route can result in more control over speed and assist in a more accurate route playback:

Programming Subways and Trolleys Using Two Remotes

When programming a PS2 subway or trolley route, the DCS Remote does not show the speed at which the engine is traveling as it learns the route. This can make it difficult to know exactly at what speed the route was programmed so that it can be run in auto mode at the same speed. If a second DCS Remote is available while programming the route, it's possible to know the speed at which the route was programmed.

 

Utilizing the second DCS Remote during the programming process begins with selecting the PS2 subway or trolley on both remotes so that the engine is displayed in the Engine Control Screen of both DCS Remotes. Then, one remote is used as described earlier to start up and position the engine at the beginning of programming, and to press the soft keys involved in the learning process. The second DCS Remote is used to increase and decrease the speed of the PS2 subway or trolley, and to start and stop it during the route programming process. In this manner, the second DCS remote will always display the speed at which the engine is traveling.

 

This and a whole lot more is all in "The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition", now available for purchase as an eBook or a printed book from MTH's web store site! Click on the link below to go to MTH's web page for the book!

 
 

Barry,

Thanks for such a quick and complete reply. I don't think I have any page 107 issues. And I don't have a second remote. But I don 't understand how an exact recording can effect my drift issue. Is 1/2" average drift in one direction with each 60' out and 60' back reasonable?

On page 107, you suggest "reprogram and start the PS2 subway a little farther back " That suggests to me adding cushion (which i can do) instead of reducing the amount of creep.

 

i do have one switch, but don't notice stutter. 

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×