Skip to main content

Since joining this forum I've read varied complaints concerning quality control issues with model railroading products but never any mention of  products being recalled for safety issues such as electrical, etc. Woild the issues railroad enthusiasts complain about generally be in non-safety areas involving cosmetic and mechanical complaints and problems? I'd imagine with trains and accessories being electrical that if quality control was such a major problem then over the years there would have been numerous electrical problems prompting safety recalls for some of them, yet I've never heard of such recalls. Have any of you? Seems it would have been likely, especially with transformers and power sources - yet to my knowledge nadda ever mentioned. Has the government ever forced product recalls or have any of the companies ever issued them due to safety concerns? Not only with electrical, but since rtr sets are often used by children, what about other safety concerns such as lead paint hazards or possible choking problems due to small parts coming loose? I'm not talking about play trains made by toy companies to be bought for and used solely by children but rather trains, train sets and related products made by the major reputable train manufacturers. Do they ever issue recalls and how have such recalls been brought to the attenion of consumers since many folks never fill in warranty or guarantee cards? Have groups such as TCA, LOTS. LRRC, TTOS, LCCA, MTH Club or the Bachman Club ever informed their membersship of product recalls? Have the publications OGR, CTT, Railroad modeler, O Scale magazine, etc. ever passed along such information to their readers?

Have any of you ever wondered or been concerned with the recall issue? Or maybe it's a non-issue with railroad enthusiasts complaining about and sweating concerns with their models that aren't really that major in the realm of all things possible? Your thoughts and feelings welcomed! 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by RickO:

Probably not enough of the "general public" interested in trains for the government to be concerned.

Actually, if there were/are child-safety concerns the Consumer Product Commission would certianly get into the act with toy-train manufacturers, if they had a safety defect.  They have imposed recalls on some toys for lead-paint, swallowable-parts, or other safety reason from time to time.  I have never heard of any issues they have had with toy trains but I suppose it could happen - a part on a Thomas-like toy that can come off and kids might swallow thinking its candy, a hazardous electrical acessory, etc.  And I am not defending the CPC by that way - I think their "ban" on the Bucky-ball neodium magnetic executive play magent sets is ridiculous (I have about 200 of the tiny little things, and no, they are not going back).

 

Most of the toy train problems we complaiin about here are quality issues, and as Allan says, affect only a small portion of products, so a recall would probably inconveience more poeople than it helped (i.e., let those with problems figure that out and send them back for repair, dont; ask everyone to).  However, something like the "whistle issue" on the Lionel Blue comet is in a gray area where I think a manufacturer might have considered the recall - apparently, every product was affected, and it was a "design" or manufacturing error, so I could see Lionel more publically 'recalling' or at least makikng it clear there was a free upgrade to the right sound available if one sent it in.  But I personally don't hold that against them (partly, I suppose, because I like the sound of the Blue Comet "whistle/horn" despite it not being prototypically accurate.)

There have been some issues regarding lead paint for products for toddlers. Case in point, there was a big Brio recall involving the paint. Doesn't apply too much to our stuff since toddlers aren't the target users.

 

The only recent model recall I remember is when Atlas had a bad crop of B40-8's and other locomotives with drive issues. Atlas pulled them all back and repaired them. Class job.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×