Skip to main content

TMCC gurus I need the benefit of your experience!!

I've been hard at work designing a layout.  One of the features I'm considering is a hidden staging yard one level below the platform surface.  As fate would have it, it turns out that the best location for the hidden staging yard is directly below the main operational yard.  The vertical separation will only be 6 1/2" to 7" between railheads (to minimize the grade climbing out of staging.)

I've heard horror stories about poor signal reception with closely-spaced yard tracks, burying ground wires in the ballast, etc.  I've also heard that sometimes one track passing over another causes TMCC carrier signal issues.  So this could be a worst-case scenario.

To aid in your understanding, here's a SCARM 3D representation of the "stacked" yards...

stacked yards

-All of the track on both levels is in parallel alignment

-Spacing between adjacent yard tracks is at least 4" (I left plenty of "finger room.")

-Vertical spacing between the levels will be 6 1/2" to 7"  (don't want to go deeper; trying to keep the grade shallow as possible)

-It might be necessary to support the upper level with aluminum angle in this area, running perpendicular to the track.  (angle joists are not shown in the 3D rendering, and I'm not even sure if this would affect the signal, but FYI.)

So... am I setting myself up for frustration with this track configuration?  I do own one of Dale / GRJ's boosters so that option is available.  So are some radical options that might be perceived as heresy in this section of the Forum!  Please share your thoughts!!

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • stacked yards
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I helped two friends of mine build layouts with exactly that arrangement: stacked yards.  One of them has a 7-track staging yard at the lowest level, a 6-track staging yard 7 inches above that, and 4 tracks of a double folded dog bone main line 7 inches above that. 

We used aluminum window screen (buy a roll of it) laid on top of the support risers but beneath the plywood on the main line and upper staging yard levels.  This screen was attached to Earth ground (the ground wire in the house wiring).  The attachment was via a stranded Earth ground wire clamped to the screen using a screw and washer.

A locomotive on a staging track sees half of the TMCC radio signal coming from the track it is sitting on and the other half coming from the window screen directly above it.  TMCC operation is flawless.

@Bob posted:

We used aluminum window screen (buy a roll of it) laid on top of the support risers but beneath the plywood on the main line and upper staging yard levels.

Thanks so much Bob!!  I'm not 100% sure what you mean about "support risers" though...  I'm thinking that the main visible surface of the platform will be 3/4" plywood.  The main operating yard tracks will be laid directly on this surface.

Would it be sufficient to staple the window screen mesh to the underside of the main surface?  I would love to know, because it would be easier to do that BEFORE both surfaces are installed!  It might be necessary to cover much of the underside with mesh.  The lower-level track makes a meandering reverse loop before entering staging to avoid backing up the grade, so it's under the upper main line for quite some distance.  

Also, do you know whether the screen wire will prevent locos on the lower level from receiving LionChief Plus or other "direct R/C" type signals?  Thanks again,  It's encouraging to know that others have done this before!

When you have one level directly above another level, the upper level has to be supported by something (I believe you mentioned aluminum angle pieces.).  Bob is suggesting you attach aluminum window screen (connected to ground) to those supports before you attach whatever material (foam, plywood, etc.) will actually support the track.  And, yes, connected aluminum window screen anywhere you have covered track in the lower level would be appropriate.

Chuck

If you get OGR Magazine....look at my layout this month. I have 2 levels stacked on top of each other including yards. 7” minimum of separation. I do not have a problem with the TMCC signal and do not use an additional ground wire.

I also have the signal “booster” built by Gunrunner but never installed. No need. 

BTW...my TMCC signal travels nicely thru walls (2 layers of drywall and studs) on my upper level that goes thru a storage room and my HVAC room.

Donald

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×