Skip to main content

Well, I am going to follow NWL with MY "new" American Flyer set, but its from (about) 1924 so its 8 years after the beautiful set posted by NWL above. 

Here is the Type XI engine with "A.F.-16" under the cab with embossed lettering in the casting and highlighted in gold.  It is  without the raised panel hence dating it from 1923 at the earliest.  Despite being nearly 100 years old, the CW motor works perfectly and so does both the cab brake lever and the under the frame brake trip which works with a brake rail in the track (which came with the set).

American Flyer type 11 loco 1923-26

Here is the entire train.  IAW Greenberg's AF Prewar O'Gauge the "new" 6 inch cars were introduced in 1923 or 1924.  He states that there is at least one verified set, just like this one, from 1924 so the book maintains that is the true introduction date of these new cars.  The Pullman is marked "Chicago, Milwaukee, and St. Paul" over the windows and 1206 - Seattle-1206 under the windows.  The 3-window , 6 panel door, mail / baggage is marked American Flyer Lines and 1205 on the left side of the door and "United States Mail / Railway Post Office" in two lines on the lower right side of the door.  Both have (using Greenberg's nomenclature) Type lV trucks and Type V couplers (garter slot) .  The color scheme and lettering date them from about 1924

American Flyer type 11 loco and train

Here are the Pullman and Mail/Baggage car in close up. 

American Flyer type 11 loco consist 1205 and 1206

Here is the set in the "bottom" of the set box.  Alas I don't have the cover and I can't really prove this is the bottom of this set box.  However, this one is a robust well constructed box both glued and stapled.  the dividers are the right size for the pieces and are also robust and permanently fastened into the outer box, so this clearly was a train set box, I just can't prove that it was for this set. 

American Flyer type 11 loco set box

Although I am not as familiar with early AF CW track, these pieces appear to be genuine and of the same time period as the cars.  As delivered to me, the "set" only had straight track (which of course could not be its original configuration) so I don't know if the curved sleepers are canted or flat.  The condition of the track is excellent however and consistent with the condition of the trains.

Hope you enjoy the pictures, this set was a thrill for me to find and acquire.

Don

Attachments

Images (4)
  • American Flyer type 11 loco 1923-26
  • American Flyer type 11 loco and train
  • American Flyer type 11 loco consist 1205 and 1206
  • American Flyer type 11 loco set box

Don,

The curved Flyer track would have the same ties (being sloped from one side to the other) just like the straight sections.  Your track appears to be correct for that time period.  Also your estimate of dating to 1923-1924 is certainly in the ballpark.  It could be from 1925-26, but it is difficult to date some of these items when we are c. 100 years out from their production.  I noted the baggage car does not have the Milwaukee St. Paul herald, which makes me believe this could be a later set, but like I said, it is difficult to date some of these items.  

NWL

 

 

I bought a 211 flatcar with truck from EBay, it showed up this week. I am real happy with it, the doors open, and the hood comes off. Used, but looks new to me.

 

78C44060-2461-40E1-A699-DBB50938D7E2 

0D7DDEE0-90E2-42D8-A304-1D9787F4E951 

A562887C-E5AE-4039-A322-5E6F884AC676

Attachments

Images (3)
  • A562887C-E5AE-4039-A322-5E6F884AC676
  • 0D7DDEE0-90E2-42D8-A304-1D9787F4E951
  • 78C44060-2461-40E1-A699-DBB50938D7E2
Videos (1)
F4D189CC-7CEE-4F51-ACDD-FCC558FC2EF1
Last edited by Craignor

Today my Dutchy mate has offered up a package that I just couldn't say no to ...

A Clockwork rake that unfortunately doesnt seem to wind up ( hopefully just a broken spring , or detached from the axle cage ) and is also lacking drive rods and the front steam assemblies , but in a first for me ... its GAUGE I ... and its also a Heinrich Fischer ! which kinda blows my mind a little , because I never knew Fischer did Gauge I ? Always living and learning

I know I havent come across them before in my travels, but obviously they are out there but there is bugger all on the web that I could find to increase my knowledge about them ?

Fischer in general seems to be fairly undocumented ?

This set looks very much like a "Blown Up" version of their O Gauge locos that were in British liveries for export ... but it looks  HUUUGE lol ( its still in the netherlands )

Even comes with a few lengths of Fischer track

Gauge I is a rabbt hole I never thought I could go down ( due to the $$$'s) but I suppose I now have a foot in the door lol!

Any info from our knowledgeable Euro collecting guys muchly appreciated !

( @FRENCHTRAINS @Arne ...and come back @sncf231e we miss you! )

 

 

 

Last edited by Fatman

Chris:  beautiful train.  However I was also really impressed with the hotel or station with the dome roof that was in the foreground of the video...who made that?  Oh and the 0-6-0 Tank, is that Hornby? 

  Fatman, what a find!  I have no Gauge 1 trains at all, likely because I could never afford them and they were not too popular in the US although they were made by Ives.  I even have had to give up my Standard Gauge trains at least in running, no space big enough. The color scheme on the Pullmans does seem reminiscent to my French Hornby Pullmans (shown below) although mine are from a much later era and much smaller of course.   Beautiful set Fatman thanks for posting.  Th

French Hornby Train - following view

Craiginor - I have an original Lionel 211 flat car, its my only series 200 car.  It is so big I could almost ride on it!  It does nicely hold some cool trucks (like yours) though.  I have a picture of it with a Wyandotte Tow Truck that fits, thing is huge.

Great pictures and videos all.  Hope everyone has a great week.  Stay healthy

Don

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • French Hornby Train - following view
@Fatman posted:

Today my Dutchy mate has offered up a package that I just couldn't say no to ...

A Clockwork rake that unfortunately doesnt seem to wind up ( hopefully just a broken spring , or detached from the axle cage ) and is also lacking drive rods and the front steam assemblies , but in a first for me ... its GAUGE I ... and its also a Heinrich Fischer ! which kinda blows my mind a little , because I never knew Fischer did Gauge I ? Always living and learning

I know I havent come across them before in my travels, but obviously they are out there but there is bugger all on the web that I could find to increase my knowledge about them ?

Fischer in general seems to be fairly undocumented ?



 

 

 

Fatman,

yes, Heinrich Fischer had made 1 gauge, but I think only this set. I have never seen a other.

I donΒ΄t collect 1 gauge, but I have the same in 0 gauge.

fisch-202fisch-203

fisch-02

Arne

Attachments

Images (3)
  • fisch-202
  • fisch-203
  • fisch-02

In a fortuitous "Co-inkydink! " closed the sale on another Sakai B&O battery loco for spares

Its rather nice outside , but has had batteries left in at some stage so there is some corrosion one end of interior

looks OK this end internally ...

Other end ... Not so much ... who knows it might still run , but I'ma doubting ?

Depends on how much "BlackWire" has formed with the electrolysis ...TBD!

"Happytime No.1 many good fun" running gear tho

@jhz563 I'll let you know when the boxed set gets here LOL !

They are marketed as "Standard Gauge " train sets , and seem to have a collaborative history behind the various versions with attributes to Sakai Dakin and even Alps thrown around as manufacturers .

The Sakai collectors guys are happy to call them Sakai tho ...they are def 0-ish in scale tho

All the sets came with various 2-rail track .. and I could be wrong but I "think" it is nominally smaller than O ... I think @Steve "Papa" Eastman

might be able to chime in ?

The full set is in my post a page or so back ..

 

 They take D size batteries tho .. so def of a good size !

Last edited by Fatman
@Fatman posted:

@jhz563 I'll let you know when the boxed set gets here LOL !

They are marketed as "Standard Gauge " train sets , and seem to have a collaborative history behind the various versions with attributes to Sakai Dakin and even Alps thrown around as manufacturers .

The Sakai collectors guys are happy to call them Sakai tho ...they are def 0-ish in scale tho

All the sets came with various 2-rail track .. and I could be wrong but I "think" it is nominally smaller than O ... I think @Steve "Papa" Eastman

might be able to chime in ?

The full set is in my post a page or so back ..

 

 They take D size batteries tho .. so def of a good size !

More like S Gauge 

Steve

This week i had the pleasure to buy a very nice loco from EDOBAUD in great original condition which is rare as the paint was directly put on metal without any primer. It dates from 1932-35 and is a very good runner despite his weight. Edobaud trains are more gauge one size, even if they run on o gauge three rails, particularity is they take curent from the center and forward and bacward from the inside and outside rails so all wheels are isolated  and tracks had wood sleepers.

IMG_0804IMG_0805

And here are some EDOBAUD trains and accessories in action at home,

IMG_0795IMG_0798

Have a nice weekend,  Daniel

Attachments

Images (4)
  • IMG_0804
  • IMG_0805
  • IMG_0795
  • IMG_0798

This week i had the pleasure to buy a very nice loco from EDOBAUD in great original condition which is rare as the paint was directly put on metal without any primer. It dates from 1932-35 and is a very good runner despite his weight. Edobaud trains are more gauge one size, even if they run on o gauge three rails, particularity is they take curent from the center and forward and bacward from the inside and outside rails so all wheels are isolated  and tracks had wood sleepers.

 

And here are some EDOBAUD trains and accessories in action at home,

IMG_0795IMG_0798

Have a nice weekend,  Daniel

Love that rug!

Well friends, like usual some really terrific trains.  Daniel, I admit I have never heard of EDOBAUD trains, but that is one beautiful engine and in fabulous shape.  Papa Eastman great Marx chrome fronts!  Pd a beautiful 1668.  I have had the same experience with tenders, some with some without whistles.  I believe at the time Lionel sold the engines both ways at slightly different prices and I am sure that they would have swapped out a tender (or swapped in one with a whistle) to hit a price point for one of their key customers.  I just got a pre-war 204 and according to what I could learn it came both ways, mine has a 2688 W or whistle tender but the same engine was offered in sets w/o a whistle.  See the TCA Lionel Trains book, 2nd eddition, 1989, under "Special and Unique Items".

Well a few weeks ago, Fatman offered a great engine that he described as having a bit of play wear.  My offering today is like that.  Its not that exotic, its a Hornby M3 LMS Tank Engine.  This one has had some play for sure but now that I cleaned it up it doesn't look too bad.  CW motor including manual reverse seems to work OK as well.  In the following pictures, I paired it up with some Hornby Type 1 LMS coaches and it looked pretty good.  This one came to me in its original box from a source in UK and the price was but GBP 10 or about $13 USD.  How could it pass it up!! 

Here is a front 1/4 view.  Note that the M3 was made from 1931-1941 BUT the addition of side rods and steam chests occurred with a re-design in 1936 which was the first time the M3 had cylinders / rods. This has the pre-war 8 red spoke cast drive wheels  I believe this to be the "matt" finish which further dates this engine from 1939 -1941  The trademark on the back of the bunker is most defiantly the pre-war style.  The M3 "sort of" emerged after the war in '47-48 as the 101.

Hornby M3

Here is a  side view, showing off her "LMS" livery, handrails, and chrome steam dome.

Hornby M3 side

Here is a picture with two of my Type 1 Hornby LMS coaches.

Hornby M3 with train

The full train ready to depart .

Hornby M3 and coaches

Have a great weekend everyone.

Don

Attachments

Images (4)
  • Hornby M3
  • Hornby M3 side
  • Hornby M3 with train
  • Hornby M3 and coaches

Lovely Hornby rake there @Don McErlean and an absolute bargain on the Loco !

And  terrific EDOBAUD .. Frenchy never disappoints

Don ...Here is one in my collection thats a little more minty ( Strange for me LOL! )

I had a couple of wins this week ... first coming from the UK  is a post-war Hornby LMS  wagon .. which has been fitted with a nice ( reproduction?) canvas cover ...its not a true covered wagon as they had a rail to hold up the tarp , this one has a card insert fitted to hold the tarp in shape .. still a lovely looker tho !

And coming from France via the Netherlands is an exercise in co-operative buying lol .. My Dutch friend graciously accepted to bid on my behalf for it , and have it shipped to him to combine with the next  parcel I have coming from him loaded with European goodness. A nice addition and a even nicer reduction in postal costs as NL post only has two brackets up to 2 kg and 2-5 kg .So as I have over 2kg coming , post of this is pretty much free to me as I will have to pay the 5kg rate anyway ! So I saved nearly 20Euro on post this way on this CR ... He is a goooood friend lol !

A Charles Rossignol CR-60 locomotive and tender which is I think from the early 50's ?

Hey guys, happy weekend! I hope you're all well. I ran some Marx last night and took a few vids - totally mundane compared to the beauties posted here!

Edit-as an aside, all the switches and planning is frustrating me. I think also confining myself to 4x8 hasn't helped either. I'm considering tearing down the 4x8 and doing around the wall like I planned on before. Any advice from fellow tinscale modelers? 

 

Attachments

Videos (2)
VID_20200920_085319
VID_20200919_204819
Last edited by SteamWolf

Fatman thanks for your comment AND the picture of what my loco looked like when it was β€œyoung” !!  The Rossignol is really cool, I had only seen advertising pictures before now to see one IRL is great. 

Steamwolf- you have the great debate. Width vs length. The advantage of the 4x8 format is the width unlikely in an around the wall setup. The around the wall gives you running length but normally is not near as wide (note some of our forum members have both and of course that is ideal.) My layout is 40” x17 ft and while it gives me some long straights I miss enough width for scenery or accessories.  Also unless you can go 360 deg  you still have to turn back unless you choose point to point. 

I think its really personal choice  I favor a β€œtoy train” type layout kind of circa 1950’s   And I like to watch the trains β€œgo round”  However we have in the forum others who use the around the wall idea with much more prototypical operation and beautiful β€œagainst the wall” scenery.  Currently I wish I had your 4 ft of width (room limitation) but others do a super job with more slender and longer elements. 

One last thing.  In I were going to go slender I would definitely do 360 deg as once you have to turn back you need width to make the loop which takes up a lot of floor space even at 0-31radii

Don

<SNIP>

Hey Don, thanks for the valued input. I think I'll try to make the best of both worlds. It just hasn't worked out no matter what I try with the 4x8, I'm just not all the way happy with what's coming out of SCARM. My original plan called for point to point with reversing loops. I think I'll just stick to simple and do that.

GN + Tin

Attachments

Images (1)
  • GN + Tin
Last edited by SteamWolf

I am determined not to let this thread die ( LOL!) Totally happy to see most are with me , with some amazing stuffs showing up as always .....I thought this week my own efforts might be a little boring as up until a few days ago all I had to show for my troubles was a lonely Hornby BR tender ...

Which will for now have to pair unnecessarily with a BR Hornby Type 40 Tank loco until I find the correct loco for it ( a BR 60199 loco)

Type 40 Tank loco ..

But then my day was made with another email from my great Dutchy mate telling me he had come across a wonderful Karl Bub ... and as soon as I saw it was an early Windcutter , there was no saying no!

Dutchy is now officially designated as my "Dealer" as he is forever lurking in a shadowy email back alley .. whispering " Psssst ! Wanna buy a train " when I come near

 

 

 

 

@Fatman posted:

I am determined not to let this thread die ( LOL!) Totally happy to see most are with me , with some amazing stuffs showing up as always ..... 

Your contributions are greatly appreciated and enjoyed.  A few things to keep in mind if you're feeling like the only contributor - 

1) the number of people with the discerning taste for tinplate is small.

2) the tinplate market here has become saturated and MTH isn't making any new items - the level of new stuff seems to be going down

3) limited number of train meets for finding new items

4) on this side of the world, the train season is just starting to pick up - our seasons are backwards!

Most of my tinplate is pretty basic and common, but I'll take another look to see if there's anything that might be of interest.

Keep up the good work.  

Fatman what a great loco I am an aero guy so assume the β€œ wind cutter” nomenclature refers to the nose cone on the boiler front!  Beautiful and great to see thanks for posting. 

Pd: great 248 and 629 cars. Let me relate an experience I had with my similar consist at the Ohio State Fair. In the 80’s we built a large 3rail layout for public display. If members agreed to watch and monitor the layout they were allowed to run their trains. So among the beautiful near scale trains of dozens of cars along went my little 248 and 3 cars. The most wonderful thing that day was a young boy of about 3 telling his Dad didn’t want to leave because he wanted to β€œ watch the little red train some more”. Made my day for sure!

Don

Yep The Windcutter is the reference to the Angled Front Cab Windows ... to cut thru the wind

@Mallard4468 I really dont feel alone, in fact I feel like I am in incredible company with those who pop in and/or contribute to this thread and all the previous weekly editions we have had coming before it   It was more a gentle nod of the head to all and a bit of encouragement to make this a mega thread going into the future ... Us tinplaters might be in the minority community-wise , but I reckon we have the most fun and dont take everything too uber seriously either ... there is room for the most toy-like and most scale to sit side by side , for rarities and common as muck , and they all get celebrated here ...

 

Dare I say it , Tinplate is probably the most inclusive ?

( oops I just did ! )

 

@Pete in Kansas nice lookin car. Did you use rattle can or air brush? Which brand paint and did you use a primer first? I’m getting ready to paint some STD passenger cars for a Christmas set and making final paint selections.

I used Rustoleum paint thinned with lacquer thinner and sprayed with a Passche airbrush. The red is the bright red just as it comes from the can and the gray is dark gray lightened with some white to approximate the gray Flyer used on trucks. These were sprayed over the bare metal that was stripped with ZEP oven cleaner and then cleaned in hot soapy water. The decals are O gauge from K4. I had never used this brand before but they went on very well.  

By the way Rustoleum rattle cans also work well. I painted an American Flyer caboose with Dark Hunter Green from a rattle can a few weeks ago and it also came out very nice.

DSCN6794

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN6794

Hey Art, just geave us some time to post, I just return from work...

An American SHAY made in France. It is not O gauge but I hope you will appreciate it, that loco is a live steam model , very simple and rustic and it run on G gauge track but as the wheels are large Standard gauge is also a possibility. It dates from the eighties and a small batch of pieces has been made by a French maker, N. Marcet for those of us who dream of logging railroads. Heating is made with tablets similar to the one used with British Mamod live steam engine, the boiler is a copper model covered with steel. Not a high grade model just one built in tinplate style.

IMG_8786IMG_8781IMG_8782IMG_8783IMG_8785

Have a nice weekend, Daniel

Attachments

Images (5)
  • IMG_8786
  • IMG_8781
  • IMG_8782
  • IMG_8783
  • IMG_8785

Daniel: You have aptly described it well as a tinplate live steamer! May I ask a value for such a limited run item?

I have seen one selling for  $400 but this one was "only" $200 so it returned at home with me. It is not a very common item so hard to give a price, if I well remember in 1985 they sold new for the equivalent of $350.

Last edited by FRENCHTRAINS

Great Stuff Folks !

Daniel , love that Shay and for that price it would have come home with me IF I could ever find one ! Beautiful !

Loving the 1689E too PD !

Just a couple of new ones this week .. a Karl Bub 1st 3rd carriage

And a wee Karl Bub Tender too

But in great news ... Part of the "Netherlands Collection " is on its way down south ... Items Marked with red crosses , are carryovers that didnt fit in this first 5kg shipment !

All of these have been posted before , but its a ****( <-- " H E Double Hockey Sticks! " ) of a group so reposting in the mega thread

Thank You Dutchy!

Not a bad early Christmas Box lol!

Last edited by Fatman

I had some guests visit to see the trains this weekend and before they arrived, I re-arranged my 1907-1908 shelf.  The shelf had to be lowered in order to fit the box on the right into the shelf.  The two boxes represent variations of 1908 American Flyer boxes, with the one on the right receiving a light restoration, as the tab and slot design of the corners had several missing tabs.

Here is the set that goes in the box on the right (complete with figure 8 track)

Here is the set that goes in the box on the left

NWL

Fellows, I have nothing new of my own this week but I couldn't help but comment on some of the recent posts.  Fatman ;  what a great display!  Now sure what the red "x"'s mean in some of the photo's (as the song goes..."All my X's live in Texas!") but i really liked seeing all the engines and rolling stock.  SteamWolf - What a great Seaboard set, never have been able to capture one of those but I keep trying.  NWL - what a magnificent display, fantastic.  Except for things on this post like you fellows and others share, I likely would never even see such trains.  thanks to all

Don

@Arne Bloody fantastic job !

@Don McErlean the red crosses are just the ones that couldnt fit into the first shipment from the Netherlands LOL ... I was limited costwise to 5kg ( 11lbs) per shipment and all the uncrossed ones plus packing came to 4.88 kg LOL! PostNL just has the two classes 0-2kg then 2kg to 5kg , so if there is over 2kg it just makes sense to try and get to 5 for the same price

I am already making a good start on the next 5kg and it didnt help last night when he offered up yet another 1925-ish Karl Bub loco of the type I already have 3 off! . Those 3 all have a slightly different finish with the lithography however , and this 4th loco in fact has the exact same lithography as one of my three ... However it is fitted with a factory modified motor and brake trip , as well as a fixed trip lever sticking out from the undercab ... this made it part of a special set Bub made where the loco would drive onto a clockwork turntable , rotate 180 degrees and then automatically restart !

It can be seen in operation at the 4min 40sec mark on this video

Clever Mr Bub ! ... so although this loco has issues , not running atm , it is indeed a 4th variant and even tho I tried hard not to buy it , he made me an offer no sane man would refuse ! Now all I have to do is turn over the worlds largest pile of rocking horse poo and chickens teeth to find the turntable for it !

http://www.schweja-blecheisenbahn.de/15_7.html

So also in the next box will come one of these two pictured with the tender ( other is already sold )

Underside showing the brake flap and trip lever unique to these locos

I had some guests visit to see the trains this weekend and before they arrived, I re-arranged my 1907-1908 shelf.  The shelf had to be lowered in order to fit the box on the right into the shelf.  The two boxes represent variations of 1908 American Flyer boxes, with the one on the right receiving a light restoration, as the tab and slot design of the corners had several missing tabs.

Here is the set that goes in the box on the right (complete with figure 8 track)

Here is the set that goes in the box on the left

NWL

Looks great! I just heard from who visited you on their way home to the heartland. By all accounts, it was a great visit!

George

Sorry I have been absent. Sam reminded me to post an update. Not too much train action over the Summer, but it has picked up lately. I just finished replacing the Fastrack on this side of the layout.

1F42CF4C-9C19-486E-9B92-04E366D173E8I have lots of Fastrack listed on eBay right now. Four more tubular cuts to go on the other side. I finally picked up an Ives 122. This one is a bit unusual as it has a Lionel frame and Ives trucks and couplers.

D6DA4AE7-7AB0-4EB1-90D5-80B0E28EF9C2
Here it is next to the one I made.

DFDD8569-46C6-4A2D-A354-8ED870DBFAD8Last week I remotored my John Daniels standard gauge GG1. The original motors disintegrated from the worst zinc pest I have seen.

AEC9A7B0-277D-4665-8078-8CA17791836D

In April, I picked up this Dorfan set. I don’t think I posted it here. Excuse me if I did.

Anyway, that’s probably enough for now. Stay safe.

George

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 1F42CF4C-9C19-486E-9B92-04E366D173E8
  • D6DA4AE7-7AB0-4EB1-90D5-80B0E28EF9C2
  • DFDD8569-46C6-4A2D-A354-8ED870DBFAD8
  • AEC9A7B0-277D-4665-8078-8CA17791836D
Videos (1)
trim.ABBD8A22-4D6B-412A-9CB2-A36EC8662069
@George S posted:

I finally picked up an Ives 122. This one is a bit unusual as it has a Lionel frame and Ives trucks and couplers.

D6DA4AE7-7AB0-4EB1-90D5-80B0E28EF9C2
Here it is next to the one I made.

DFDD8569-46C6-4A2D-A354-8ED870DBFAD8 

 

George

George,

I don't know a lot about Ives, but the tank car you picked up on a Lionel frame, with Ives trucks and couplers is likely a transition piece, as I believe that is a Lionel tank also.  I know that after their bankruptcy, there were a lot of transition items, with the tank cars being one of the more unusual ones.  There is also a version that comes with a Flyer frame, the Lionel tank, and Ives trucks and couplers.

NWL

George,

I don't know a lot about Ives, but the tank car you picked up on a Lionel frame, with Ives trucks and couplers is likely a transition piece, as I believe that is a Lionel tank also.  I know that after their bankruptcy, there were a lot of transition items, with the tank cars being one of the more unusual ones.  There is also a version that comes with a Flyer frame, the Lionel tank, and Ives trucks and couplers.

NWL

Yes, it is a transition piece. Most of them use Lionel tanks on Ives frames. The earliest ones had blank brass plates. This must be one of the later ones. At one point they didn’t even bother using Ives couplers or trucks. The only difference between those and a Lionel 815 was the Ives plates and the color.

George

A Prussian tinplate passenger car made by Darstaed in Switzerland around 1980. Those cars where made under supervision of Marcel Darphin, a famous collector of scale models, by the Swiss manufacturer Twerenbold. The cars are all metal and very heavy, they are of very high quality and are not easy pieces to find. They must not be confused with actual Darstaed brand who re used the name and produce British models.

IMG_8316IMG_8317IMG_8318IMG_8319DCP03348DCP03343

Have a nice weekend,  Daniel

Attachments

Images (7)
  • IMG_8316
  • IMG_8317
  • IMG_8318
  • IMG_8319
  • DCP03348
  • DCP03348
  • DCP03343

George,

I wasn't aware that there was one in green.  The only mention I have ever seen of it was on eBay where the seller wanted an astronomical amount for it.  From the photos that were posted I thought it was not a legitimate variation

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Edit:

I just checked the Ives website and there is a green variation, however the comment is that because it is all Lionel except for the plates it could very easily be put together.

There is also a special order red, white and blue variation shown.

Last edited by Greg J. Turinetti

George,

I wasn't aware that there was one in green.  The only mention I have ever seen of it was on eBay where the seller wanted an astronomical amount for it.  From the photos that were posted I thought it was not a legitimate variation

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Edit:

I just checked the Ives website and there is a green variation, however the comment is that because it is all Lionel except for the plates it could very easily be put together.

There is also a special order red, white and blue variation shown.


That’s what is strange about the whole transition era. Nobody knows for sure. Ives was slapping stuff together. That red, white (cream) and blue one is very attractive, but I don’t value one-offs to the extent that one would cost. The green one on eBay only had Ives plates on one side and Lionel on the other. Ives could have ran out of parts, but who knows. I like the green version of the caboose, but it doesn’t do me much good with Lionel couplers.

George

@George S posted:


That’s what is strange about the whole transition era. Nobody knows for sure. Ives was slapping stuff together. That red, white (cream) and blue one is very attractive, but I don’t value one-offs to the extent that one would cost. The green one on eBay only had Ives plates on one side and Lionel on the other. Ives could have ran out of parts, but who knows. I like the green version of the caboose, but it doesn’t do me much good with Lionel couplers.

George

Several years ago Bertoia auctioned a Flyer bodied 121 caboose that was yellow & brown.  Here is an image from that auction.

I recall the item selling for big money, but don't recall the details.

Steve - the window display really looks cool.  I can't make out the consist but I have a similar one made up of a Lionel 384E 2-4-0, 332 baggage/mail, 337 pullman, 338 observation...also in the red/cream color scheme.  Unfortunately its been years since I had enough space to run it.  Who knows, maybe this Christmas if the "G-scale" trains stay in the box.

OK fellows, I admit I am about to commit a "bending" of the rules.  This item is NOT tinplate, but it is clearly in support of toy trains and of European origin.  Since most of the expertise in European trains seems to post here, I am going to show it to you.  It was advertised as a "Holland" train station and it is from the region of the Netherlands where I and my wife who accompanied me, often traveled for business.  It is one of our favorite parts of the world.

As you can see its a simple trackside passenger shelter labeled for Utrecht with direction signs for Eindhoven and Amsterdam.  It is clearly a "factory" made product as far as I can tell due to the finishes and construction.  It however carries no manufacturer's label (which may have come off during its life).  It looks in finish very much like some US made wooden toy ware in terms of how its made, finished, and the materials.

Holland Train Stop 1

To get a sense of size, here is the item held in my Grandaughter's hand.  It is clearly in the range of O scale although I doubt it is "scale" at all but its about the right size for an O gauge train.  The roof clears my O gauge passenger cars and extends far enough over the tracks that it would provide shelter to boarding passengers in case of rain.  So its reasonably well sized although I doubt it has a scale prototype.

Holland Train Stop 2

Since we traveled to this area a reasonable amount, still have friends in Amsterdam, and are going back (COVID permitting) this May, I just could not resist.  If anyone has seen something like this and /or  may know when it was made or the manufacturer I would most certainly like to know.

Thanks everyone and sorry its not tinplate.

Don

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Holland Train Stop 1
  • Holland Train Stop 2

Steve - the window display really looks cool.  I can't make out the consist but I have a similar one made up of a Lionel 384E 2-4-0, 332 baggage/mail, 337 pullman, 338 observation...also in the red/cream color scheme.  Unfortunately its been years since I had enough space to run it.  Who knows, maybe this Christmas if the "G-scale" trains stay in the box.

OK fellows, I admit I am about to commit a "bending" of the rules.  This item is NOT tinplate, but it is clearly in support of toy trains and of European origin.  Since most of the expertise in European trains seems to post here, I am going to show it to you.  It was advertised as a "Holland" train station and it is from the region of the Netherlands where I and my wife who accompanied me, often traveled for business.  It is one of our favorite parts of the world.

As you can see its a simple trackside passenger shelter labeled for Utrecht with direction signs for Eindhoven and Amsterdam.  It is clearly a "factory" made product as far as I can tell due to the finishes and construction.  It however carries no manufacturer's label (which may have come off during its life).  It looks in finish very much like some US made wooden toy ware in terms of how its made, finished, and the materials.

Holland Train Stop 1

To get a sense of size, here is the item held in my Grandaughter's hand.  It is clearly in the range of O scale although I doubt it is "scale" at all but its about the right size for an O gauge train.  The roof clears my O gauge passenger cars and extends far enough over the tracks that it would provide shelter to boarding passengers in case of rain.  So its reasonably well sized although I doubt it has a scale prototype.

Holland Train Stop 2

Since we traveled to this area a reasonable amount, still have friends in Amsterdam, and are going back (COVID permitting) this May, I just could not resist.  If anyone has seen something like this and /or  may know when it was made or the manufacturer I would most certainly like to know.

Thanks everyone and sorry its not tinplate.

Don

Don

it is a 390 and the larger 300 series cars.

Steve

@George S posted:

Yes, that’s the β€œred, white and blue” special order. Big money would be expected, especially in that condition with a box.

George

I checked my Bertoia catalog and it is described as a tan car having a red roof with gray coupla roof, so not quite sure of it being a "red, white, and blue" car.  I recall seeing it in person at the auction and it was more of a yellow color than white.  The car sold for c. $3,500 at that auction in 2007.

NWL

I checked my Bertoia catalog and it is described as a tan car having a red roof with gray coupla roof, so not quite sure of it being a "red, white, and blue" car.  I recall seeing it in person at the auction and it was more of a yellow color than white.  The car sold for c. $3,500 at that auction in 2007.

NWL

Yes, that is the more accurate description of the colors. I couldn’t guess the price. That is higher than I would imagine, but it seems like it had enough authentication to it’s originality. There are only a couple of these that are known. My issue is that the color scheme is relatively easy to reproduce.

George

Hello again everyone.  I decided that to make up for my posting of a WOODEN Holland train station, I better post some tinplate !  But before that, let me say thanks to Daniel for posting the Darstaed passenger cars from Switzerland ! COVID permitting, wife and I are traveling to Bern this May so maybe I might encounter these trains.  Rich Wiemann, beautiful City of Denver train, great find.  Arne your work on the Bub elevated is really progressing beautifully.  I hope you post some pictures of it operating when you are done.  NWL, George S,  and Greg I am now as confused as ever about the infamous "Ives Transition Cars " of about 1932 or so.  I have several that ultimately transitioned into the Lionel line, but had not seen those that used Flyer bodies...Oh well at $3500 for one caboose I expect I will never have to worry about them (LOL)!!

From me today, much more modest fare.  I pulled out some Chad Valley rolling stock this week.  These tankers were new to their line in 1949 (ref  Michael Foster's book, "British Toy Trains", Book 1).  I will admit to being a "tanker fan" because of the many different liveries that were used by the various manufacturers.

Anyway here are my Chad Valley tanker wagons:

This is the 10074 Model C.V. Dairies tanker. A single dome with lithographed ladder, note two color lithography on ladder to give a "3D" appearance .

Chad Valley Milk Tanker

This is the 10075 Model Motor C.V. Spirit Tanker.  A two dome but with no ladder

Chad Valley Petrol Tanker

IAW Foster's book, both tankers were new to the Chad Valley line in 1949.  They had simple bent hook and eye couplings.  He mentions that later versions of these cars had black or nickel long link couplings.  They are obviously 4 wheel with no journal boxes, have metal wheels, and are both about 4-5" long.  I have several CV freight wagons, but am still on the lookout for a CV locomotive...oh well that is what makes us collectors...its all about the search!

Have a safe and happy week

Don

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Chad Valley Milk Tanker
  • Chad Valley Petrol Tanker

Hello Don, I hope you will find something for your collection in Switzerland.  Manufacturers from that country have realized many nice models, just be prepare to "Swiss prices" sometime they are extremely high...  Sorry about your wooden train station, I have never seen one and do not know who made it, nice piece and rare find, congrats. 

All my best wishes, Daniel

Several years ago Bertoia auctioned a Flyer bodied 121 caboose that was yellow & brown.  Here is an image from that auction.

I recall the item selling for big money, but don't recall the details.

I just bought an overpainted AF 3211 that I plan to restore. I got a good price, and it's already been messed up pretty good. So, I will try to match this color scheme. I plan to keep the AF trucks and couplers on it. It has all the trim except for the circle windows on the ends. Maybe I can find some brass eyelets that will fit those. I don't know how the plates will clean up or if they are even there. There is a heavy coat of red on them. The journal boxes and other trim all has paint on it too. Hopefully, it will clean up nice and I can share with everyone.

I am having the most trouble matching that yellow/tan/white paint color. Rustoleum has an Antique White and an Almond that seem closest. I read that this color was used on other American Flyer cars, or maybe they meant Ives cars. Anyone have any ideas? The picture on the Ives Society website makes the color look darker and more tan in color.

The roof looks like a good match to Krylon Fusion Matte Ink Blue. I used Rustoleum Colonial Red to match the red on my Ives 121. I am happy with that match.

George

@George S posted:

I just bought an overpainted AF 3211 that I plan to restore. I got a good price, and it's already been messed up pretty good. So, I will try to match this color scheme. I plan to keep the AF trucks and couplers on it. It has all the trim except for the circle windows on the ends. Maybe I can find some brass eyelets that will fit those. I don't know how the plates will clean up or if they are even there. There is a heavy coat of red on them. The journal boxes and other trim all has paint on it too. Hopefully, it will clean up nice and I can share with everyone.

I am having the most trouble matching that yellow/tan/white paint color. Rustoleum has an Antique White and an Almond that seem closest. I read that this color was used on other American Flyer cars, or maybe they meant Ives cars. Anyone have any ideas? The picture on the Ives Society website makes the color look darker and more tan in color.

The roof looks like a good match to Krylon Fusion Matte Ink Blue. I used Rustoleum Colonial Red to match the red on my Ives 121. I am happy with that match.

George

I think your color will be off, if you paint the roof blue, as the Bertoia catalog calls it a gray colored roof.  I know that gray will be a difficult color to match, as there are many variations of gray colors.

I recall the color looking more yellow/tan in person, when I viewed it at the auction and I would suspect the roof is a darker gray color.

I think your color will be off, if you paint the roof blue, as the Bertoia catalog calls it a gray colored roof.  I know that gray will be a difficult color to match, as there are many variations of gray colors.

I recall the color looking more yellow/tan in person, when I viewed it at the auction and I would suspect the roof is a darker gray color.

The roof is the same color as the regular Ives 121. It does look gray, with a blue tint. This Ink Blue is very gray. If it doesn’t match, I’ll keep trying.

I’ll keep your observation of the yellow in mind as I try to match to body. Lighting in these different photographs tends to change the color.

George

tinplate

Contemporary tinplate--especially new-in-box--is quickly becoming as scarce as hen's teeth, so I have pretty much jumped on anything I find that suits my needs, interests, and desires. I am still in the process of unpacking and setting up things following my move to a new home last month, but did manage to place a small part of my contemporary O gauge tinplate motive power collection in a couple of the recently mounted display cases down in my new OGR office/lounge/train layout room. I was too lazy to remove the Plexiglas fronts, so please forgive the reflections.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • tinplate


Contemporary tinplate--especially new-in-box--is quickly becoming as scarce as hen's teeth, so I have pretty much jumped on anything I find that suits my needs, interests, and desires. I am still in the process of unpacking and setting up things following my move to a new home last month, but did manage to place a small part of my contemporary O gauge tinplate motive power collection in a couple of the recently mounted display cases down in my new OGR office/lounge/train layout room. I was too lazy to remove the Plexiglas fronts, so please forgive the reflections.

Those are some nice ones! It feels like the contemporary tinplate era went by so fast!

George

OK, trying something new.  I created a youtube channel so I could upload video content.  The test video is about 30 seconds long, but my aim is to create longer videos in the future.  So here are a couple of prewar American Flyer items running around the track.



NWL

I must gush a little and say that I love this video!!! Watching it over and over, like on a loop. Found myself actually straining/tilting my neck to see what is coming around a corner! Well done. Looks like there is more original AF O I definitely need to get!

Added a few shelves to display up to show some of my bigger STD Gauge locos.

Steve glad you added new shelves, can never have enough display space. However, I’m not sure about your display selection choice. Maybe the β€œSorta Standard Gauge” RTR units would have been a better choice....LOL. Not really, those are some handsome units and rightfully should be admired on a daily basis. ENJOY....  

Last edited by Rich Wiemann
@George S posted:

The roof is the same color as the regular Ives 121. It does look gray, with a blue tint. This Ink Blue is very gray. If it doesn’t match, I’ll keep trying.

I’ll keep your observation of the yellow in mind as I try to match to body. Lighting in these different photographs tends to change the color.

George

I received my beat up caboose. Here are the before pictures. B112B0A4-4CAC-490A-A830-D2007892A2EEAFF6DCBC-04DC-44E0-AE97-089639054381

Good news is that it has all the trim except the plates. I agree with NWL that the roof is going to be the problem color to match. It’s much closer to charcoal gray than any blue. I am going to experiment in blending spray colors on some scrap.

I have two shades of cream for the body that I will test and share.

This shouldn’t take too long. It’s mostly a strip and repaint.

George

Attachments

Images (2)
  • B112B0A4-4CAC-490A-A830-D2007892A2EE
  • AFF6DCBC-04DC-44E0-AE97-089639054381

A favorite car, the Maerklin Transportwagen fur Flugzeuge No. 1881/1, produced 1919-1935. My example is post 1926 when buffers were added making the car a little longer. The car is all original except for the reproduction pilot.

P1240039P1240042

That car is incredibly cool. That's why I love this thread - seeing so many things that I never even knew existed.

Amazing that the car survived in that condition with almost all of the parts intact.  Of course, it's sad in a way, because it means the lucky kid who got it never really played with it.

@George S posted:

AFF6DCBC-04DC-44E0-AE97-089639054381

Good news is that it has all the trim except the plates. I agree with NWL that the roof is going to be the problem color to match. It’s much closer to charcoal gray than any blue. I am going to experiment in blending spray colors on some scrap.

I have two shades of cream for the body that I will test and share.

This shouldn’t take too long. It’s mostly a strip and repaint.

George

I have had one of these apart for about a year waiting for me to get back to it.  I intended to fabricate a replacement cupula to make look more lie a northeast wide cupula design.  the first couple tries came out poor and just never had time to get it done.  maybe next year.

@George S posted:

I received my beat up caboose. Here are the before pictures. B112B0A4-4CAC-490A-A830-D2007892A2EEAFF6DCBC-04DC-44E0-AE97-089639054381

Good news is that it has all the trim except the plates. I agree with NWL that the roof is going to be the problem color to match. It’s much closer to charcoal gray than any blue. I am going to experiment in blending spray colors on some scrap.

I have two shades of cream for the body that I will test and share.

This shouldn’t take too long. It’s mostly a strip and repaint.

George

I think I came up with the blue gray roof. I started with Ink Blue and lightly oversprayed it with Charcoal Gray.

443AC7F3-7DEB-41CD-B58D-E8EB7AA77313

Here are the color options for the cream. Antique White and Ivory White. which is closest? The Antique is a little runny.

8CBEDFF0-9B7A-4C49-BFC5-AADC9B678A0B

George

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 443AC7F3-7DEB-41CD-B58D-E8EB7AA77313
  • 8CBEDFF0-9B7A-4C49-BFC5-AADC9B678A0B

Daniel :  What a great find, thanks for posting.  You are right, the MO class of Hornby was O - gauge but a smaller scale than the rest of the line.  I have one of the first passenger series of this line from about 1930-31. It is pictured below.  Not nearly as sophisticated as yours but the MO line did get better as the years went on.

Hornby M0 - full train

Daniel, as always, thank you for posting.  I had never seen the "AD" set your pictured before.

Don

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Hornby M0 - full train

Ohhh Frenchy ! What a marvellous PLM Aerodynamique ! Thats one of my Bucket List locomotives .. C'est Magnifique Mon Frere !

Same with the Marklin Marvel from MR JKE ! glorious condition and some rocking horse poo right there !

Well this week for me has been more about "Bits and Pieces" than stunning rarity or amazingness

Starting with a simple Post War Hornby British Rail tender

Then a nice Canadian Pacific Marx found here in Aus .. ( excuse sellers photography lol )

Apparently its a "Perfect runner"

And sourced from the same fine fellow .. a lovely little double reduction Marx motor ( again perfect runner) which is quite possibly going to replace the motor in my British Marx Silverlink which has some issues !

But the absolute BARGAIN of the week was finding a lot of Vintage wheels on the Netherlands epay, and with the kind assistance of my Dutchy mate it was secured for an astounding opening bid of ......

0.99 Euro's !  with 7 euros local postage !

Thats some MAJOR treasure right there ! A lot of early pressed cut tin spoked wheels as well as some later cast versions ( and some HWN or similar plastics lol )

But the funniest thing I mentioned to Dutchy after winning it ... the Charles Gervais Cheese box the dude sent it in .... is worth 50 times the winning bid according to asking prices on epay !!!

So we started out pretty meekly but ended with a bang !

( it doesnt take much to keep me happy lol )

Here's my contribution.  I picked it up at York from a guy who specializes in European trains and frequently travels to the Czech Republic.  He threw it in when I purchased some other items.  It appears to be handmade.  I think the body is aluminum.  It has an O-gauge mechanism, but the overall size is more like standard or 1 gauge.  I have not yet dared to power it up.  Any ideas about it? IMG_1659IMG_1661IMG_1660

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_1661
  • IMG_1660
  • IMG_1659
@Fatman posted:


But the absolute BARGAIN of the week was finding a lot of Vintage wheels on .......

( it doesnt take much to keep me happy lol )

Fatman I believe your last statement on the post sums it up for most of us!

It’s the thrill of the hunt and seeing value in something that doesn’t mean much to someone else. Keep up the hunt across the globe and enjoy. i know your collecting has broaden my toy train knowledge.

Fatman...you are now defiantly the "BIG WHEEL" among our group!!  Great Marx CP loco as well.  Do you know if its pre or post war?  Is it an 0-4-0 or a 2-4-2 ? Marx made both arrangements.  Based on some details,  it could date as early as '39 but was then reissued '46-52. Marx made these as 494,495,and 3000 series engines.  The key feature separating it from the 391,396,397 series is that it only has one dome and the 39X series had two.  In addition the 39X series had a round smokestack while the 3000 and 49X series had the tear drop shaped stack like yours. This would put your engine in the 49X or 3000 series.   One key is if there is lettering on the side boards, it would typically be "Marlines" but sometimes said "Canadian Pacific" or sometimes just the number "3000" other variants have just the blank sideboard with the colored trim and no lettering at all.   Marx, unfortunately for us collectors today, made a bewildering number of variants on this great loco.  In fact he made more variants of this type loco than any other.  However, I would agree with your seller..."if its Marx, it will RUN!"

Speaking of Marx, I posted this picture on Front End Friday, but thought you all might like it.  Its kind of "pre" Marx.  It is a Joy Line loco, CW, from about 1932-35.  This followed the Joy Line, cast iron loco made from about 1927.  The manufacturer was  the Girard Model Works of Girard Pa. which had been founded in 1906 as a manufacturer of springs and was engaged in the toy business from about the 1920's.  Louis Marx & Co. became their sole toy distributor under a 5 year contract in 1929.  Subsequent financial difficulties resulted in the Girard Model Works filing for bankruptcy in 1934 and Marx (who was a major stockholder and was serving as one of the Directors of the Model Works)  acquired the assets of the company from the receivers in January 1935.   It was reorganized as the Girard Manufacturing Co and began to produce Marx toys in 1936.

Here is the "mighty" Joy Line steam locomotive pulling her Joy Line heavyweight passenger consist about 1932-1935.

Joy Line Pass engine only



Have a great weekend everyone!

Don

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Joy Line Pass engine only

I want to see one of my favorite post strings continue so here's my newest tinplate car. This started as a beat up 4018 and now is an REA express boxcar for my AF passenger train. Later I'll have some more pictures of my AF passenger train with this car in it and double headed with a 4000 and 46XX locomotives.   20201015_20374620201015_203750

I love it!!! More AF Wide Gauge please!!!

Pete in Kansas:  Beautiful restoration / customizing job.  Did you have any rust?  If so what did you do to remove it and did you then have to prepare the surface for new paint.  I have several Lionel cars that could use a restoration but they have various amounts of rust and I am not sure of a good mechanism to remove it.  Thanks

Don

Yes it had a lot of rust on the roof which was cleaned with a brass wheel on my bench grinder and then the pitting was filled with red lead. I bought a tube of red lead at walmart a few years ago and at the rate I'm using it this will probably last me for the next 10 years! After these areas are sanded and primed you'd never know the pitting was there.

It is always nice to add a couple of Marklin pieces to the collection and bring them back to life. The switch track in the first picture shows how dirty everthing was on average throughout the lot. After a day's worth of cleaning, I was able to bring the switches and crossing back to life. Just finishing up two more freight cars today. Miketg

Switch1Switches2Marklin crossing

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Switch1
  • Switches2
  • Marklin crossing

Hi @Arne that wonderful platform indicator was manufactured here in Australia by Strong ... they are pretty thin on the ground here so you did great in snapping that one up ...

Its really hard to google info on as you no doubt have found , because "Strong" simply is used soooooo many ways ... but I found an Auction listing showing one

https://www.antiquesreporter.c...on-board-with-clock/

The ones I have seen ( not in person , but on web) usually have a faint "Strong" punched into the underside of the base , but its usually very faint and in some models probably is not there at all ?

They did different versions , I have seen one for Victoria ( your model) and one for New South Wales , of course they have different names on the paper but are identical otherwise made in the late 40's to early 50's I believe , but I think @Jamie Thompson might know more?

@Don McErlean Like you , currently I have only the crappy auction pics to go on LOL!

But I did hold back the underneath shot ... its def 0-4-0 oh and auto-reversing motor

Lovely little Joyline consist too Don ... best I can come up with is my rusty old boy ...

Last edited by Fatman
@Arne posted:

A few news in the collection.

Brimtoy train 124, made 1916

bri124-01bri124-02bri124-03bri124-05bri124-06

Bub indicators from the 30s, all the same with different names.

Germany

bub-u012-01

Netherland

bub-u012-02

France

bub-u012-03

Danmark

bub-u012-04

And a unknown indicator for Australia

anz-austra01anz-austra02

With Adelaide, Mildura, Albury, Bendigo, Frankston, Geelong, Flinders St

anz-austra03

Arne

All very nice Arne- I love that that you got the same  indicator from the same company with the variance being the country/region they represent and were therefore primarily marketed in- really cool. I also like the indicators themselves, I have the German one.

Also like the strong Australian pick-up, I studied there a few years back during undergrad- centered in Brizzy, traveled up the east coast, so beautiful. Love the actually train system there, as well. Asked a guy for directions when getting off the subway when Saturday night, he turned around, said β€œoh a sepo” and just roundhouse kicked me in the middle of a busy subway exit corridor. Luckily my arm was at my side already, his wife was horrified. Regardless, Great mass transit and cool trains; I utilized their trains quite often. Traveled up the east coast. My 5:45ish Friday train ride from Brisbane to Bondi beach is possibly my favorite, most serene and peaceful trainride ive ever taken.(sure beats philly to St. Augustine!)

Last edited by StevefromPA

Just started a project today.  Making a c. 1910 American Flyer tank car.

Started with a c. 1910 3 step Chicago car frame

Measured the hole size and spacing from another freight car and drilled the holes.  Filed and sanded the rough edges of the holes.

Need to strip the paint next and find someone to make me a 1/2 dozen wooden tanks.  Not sure what color I will make the tank, but I will most likely try and match the orange tank shown on page 164 of the Greenberg's Guide to American Flyer Prewar O Gauge.

It is interesting to note that the tank shown in the Greenberg's Guide has an orange painted frame and the other 2 cars have black painted frames.  My guess is the cars with the black painted frames are slightly later cars, as my other two c. 1910 freight cars have bodies painted to match the frame and the 1912 cars (with butterfly couplers) have black painted frames.

Here is my c. 1910 gondola, note the remnants of red paint on the frame and gold painted rim at the top of the body.

Here is my c. 1910 log car.

Here is my model for the wooden tank, a c. 1914 tank on the later frame.

I am having extra wooden tanks made, because I have an extra c. 1914 frame that is already drilled for the tank, and it is good to have parts.

NWL

Last edited by Nation Wide Lines

Just started a project today.  Making a c. 1910 American Flyer tank car.

Started with a c. 1910 3 step Chicago car frame

Measured the hole size and spacing from another freight car and drilled the holes.  Filed and sanded the rough edges of the holes.

Need to strip the paint next and find someone to make me a 1/2 dozen wooden tanks.  Not sure what color I will make the tank, but I will most likely try and match the orange tank shown on page 164 of the Greenberg's Guide to American Flyer Prewar O Gauge.

It is interesting to note that the tank shown in the Greenberg's Guide has an orange painted frame and the other 2 cars have black painted frames.  My guess is the cars with the black painted frames are slightly later cars, as my other two c. 1910 freight cars have bodies painted to match the frame and the 1912 cars (with butterfly couplers) have black painted frames.

Here is my c. 1910 gondola, note the remnants of red paint on the frame and gold painted rim at the top of the body.

Here is my c. 1910 log car.

Here is my model for the wooden tank, a c. 1914 tank on the later frame.

I am having extra wooden tanks made, because I have an extra c. 1914 frame that is already drilled for the tank, and it is good to have parts.

NWL

Nice project. Were the original car tanks wooden?

George

@George S posted:

Nice project. Were the original car tanks wooden?

George

Yes, the original c. 1910 to 1914 tanks are wooden.  They appear to be two piece construction, with a larger piece for the body and then the dome being a smaller piece that is inserted into a hole drilled in the larger body.

It is my understanding that the roof on the early boxcars are also wooden, but I have never seen one in person.

NWL

Got some new tin at a train show yesterday! But The first 4 pics are of two things I’ve wanted to share but haven’t gotten  around to doing so:

I was very surprised to come across this Ives transition era Lionel 610 series Observation. Further, I like it quite a bit, besides the one rear number maker being rusty, it’s in great shape and looks great.

C7C2750B-A3EE-492A-B944-794221BD611E

The sticker that was on the bottom of these83954D06-9107-4935-A53D-1F53B59F9E0F



With a Lionel 6107E8FC842-884C-4911-8BE0-076B35E67FF5

the second one I forgot- American Model Toys Santa Fe Baggage car. I’m close to completing what I call the β€œAMT Santa Fe set lite”. I have the baggage, combine. 3160 coach, Burma Vista dome, Indian Areow Obs, just need the diner.

143C5358-4A68-4483-A3F4-34193BDF4CD5

Now, from yesterday’s show. Lead off with a car from another set I’m trying to complete- 1600 series Ives cars. Finally got the caboose. I know it’s not hard to find but I feel it’s usually unreasonably priced, yesterday it wasn’t! 9937FE89-F0D9-4DE1-A001-A3463CC75920

Karl Bub PRR 167, 4 wheel coach, smooth roof. Odd couplers.BED1288D-58E9-42EE-9EDB-263A0E8711E3D835EA4F-72D5-4D77-AD95-808E3488D63E

last, certainly not least, Bassett-Lowke LMS 91375 goods wagon. GREAT condition. Silver wheels are interestingB96C2B2C-A9D8-4425-A9E2-D63FBCC3BF70

clearly legible logo with β€œNorthampton make”750B71E6-C440-4F7D-9D1C-4BE8CE8F7843

The extent of my UK roadnames Prewar 382A9B9F-D675-4FF3-BEF7-0B28F9ABE345

Lionel 1942 catalog. Just thought it was cool104FBD0B-1868-4FF5-96CC-CF9153896BD4

it was a good day. Keep the tin coming!

Attachments

Images (11)
  • C7C2750B-A3EE-492A-B944-794221BD611E
  • 9937FE89-F0D9-4DE1-A001-A3463CC75920
  • BED1288D-58E9-42EE-9EDB-263A0E8711E3
  • D835EA4F-72D5-4D77-AD95-808E3488D63E
  • B96C2B2C-A9D8-4425-A9E2-D63FBCC3BF70
  • 750B71E6-C440-4F7D-9D1C-4BE8CE8F7843
  • 382A9B9F-D675-4FF3-BEF7-0B28F9ABE345
  • 104FBD0B-1868-4FF5-96CC-CF9153896BD4
  • 143C5358-4A68-4483-A3F4-34193BDF4CD5
  • 83954D06-9107-4935-A53D-1F53B59F9E0F
  • 7E8FC842-884C-4911-8BE0-076B35E67FF5
@StevefromPA posted:

Got some new tin at a train show yesterday! But The first 4 pics are of two things I’ve wanted to share but haven’t gotten  around to doing so:

I was very surprised to come across this Ives transition era Lionel 610 series Observation. Further, I like it quite a bit, besides the one rear number maker being rusty, it’s in great shape and looks great.



The sticker that was on the bottom of these



With a Lionel 610

the second one I forgot- American Model Toys Santa Fe Baggage car. I’m close to completing what I call the β€œAMT Santa Fe set lite”. I have the baggage, combine. 3160 coach, Burma Vista dome, Indian Areow Obs, just need the diner.

143C5358-4A68-4483-A3F4-34193BDF4CD5

Now, from yesterday’s show. Lead off with a car from another set I’m trying to complete- 1600 series Ives cars. Finally got the caboose. I know it’s not hard to find but I feel it’s usually unreasonably priced, yesterday it wasn’t!

Karl Bub PRR 167, 4 wheel coach, smooth roof. Odd couplers.

last, certainly not least, Bassett-Lowke LMS 91375 goods wagon. GREAT condition. Silver wheels are interesting

clearly legible logo with β€œNorthampton make”

The extent of my UK roadnames Prewar

Lionel 1942 catalog. Just thought it was cool

it was a good day. Keep the tin coming!

Let me check my extras. I may have a SF Diner.

Steve

StevefromPA...just want to register INSANE Jealousy...a TRAIN SHOW!  We have not had one in our entire TCA Division or in even in our area since January...all have been cancelled including those scheduled for November.  Lucky Guy!!  Nice work finding the "Ives" 610/612 from 1931-32.  My Ives reference labels them as "Irvington Production" referencing the Lionel manufacturing plant in Irvington N.J. (believe it or not, in the late 40's I lived with my parents very close to this plant).  You might like to know that IAW the same reference, the price of the 610 was $2.95 in '31 and $2.15 in '32. The 612 was slightly more expensive at $3.00 in '31 and $2.95 in '32.  Actually while this sounds incredibly cheap by today's prices, we need to remember that '32 was the depths of the Great Depression.  Anyway Great Cars and thanks for sharing.

Fatman thanks for the update...the 0-4-0 wheel designation plus 1 dome and a teardrop shaped stack sets the loco in the 3000 /494/495 series.  However variants of this loco were still made both pre and post war, starting in 1939.   When you get the loco, post some pictures of the design/colors/lettering on the side boards and I can help you date it more precisely if you desire.

By the way your cast iron, black, Joy Line loco would date from about 1930.  My data says that the CW loco with a black cast iron boiler, unpainted steel motor side frames,  8-spoke flanged wheels, no side rods, strap spring motor with fly ball governor, and ringing bell was made between 1930-31.  As best I can see in the picture, if the key is a "slip on" over a square shaft, then its 1930.  A screw - on key would be slightly later into '31.  Joy Line listed this as a type "102" loco and it predates the sheet metal boiler loco I posted which dates from about 1932-1935.

Happy Weekend

Don

Well Fatman, I can tell you that this locomotive is one of the hardest to date as Marx made many overlapping configurations.  Here is what I got from your pictures and I believe its a good match.

1949-1952, catalogue no. 495, black cab, black boiler, silver and black sideboards with red trim and crest and no lettering, silver pilot, dotted glass headlight, black headlight rim (this is the one detail I can't quite confirm from the pictures), tinned smokestack, tinned sheet metal boiler front, tinned dome, tinned marker lights, 0-4-0 wheel arrangement with Baldwin drivers.  In addition the one piece sliding shoe electrical pick up for the motor dates from 1946.

Hope this helps

Don

Help required from our fine American comrades

Pretty much whenever I see a US vintage clockwork loco here in Australia, I am gonna try and snatch it, limited budget permitting, so this fellow has to come live with me .

Much like a young Charles Darwin however, I am left to contemplate "The Origin of Species " and as you fine folk here are the Galapagos to my Darwin when it comes to early USA locos I present for your delectation, perusal, and knowledge emanation... the following ...

My mind wants to say Hafner ... but the mech having a normal shaft and key confuses me?

Mind you it is not in hand yet so its hard for me to say if its a swapped mech , but I would find that unlikely , because ..Australia... and just how many mechs are laying around in the 10-30's? not many I would guess ...

So turning it over to you wonderful gaggle of brethren with better knowledge than I !

@Fatman posted:

Help required from our fine American comrades

Pretty much whenever I see a US vintage clockwork loco here in Australia, I am gonna try and snatch it, limited budget permitting, so this fellow has to come live with me .

Much like a young Charles Darwin however, I am left to contemplate "The Origin of Species " and as you fine folk here are the Galapagos to my Darwin when it comes to early USA locos I present for your delectation, perusal, and knowledge emanation... the following ...

My mind wants to say Hafner ... but the mech having a normal shaft and key confuses me?

Mind you it is not in hand yet so its hard for me to say if its a swapped mech , but I would find that unlikely , because ..Australia... and just how many mechs are laying around in the 10-30's? not many I would guess ...

So turning it over to you wonderful gaggle of brethren with better knowledge than I !

It's an American Flyer Metzel type casting with rivet detail and 10-spoke cast iron wheels, so it dates to about 1916, possibly 1917.  It would be the tail end of the production of this motor.

NWL

Oh Wow thank you for the excellent news @Nation Wide Lines I looked at Edmonds-Metzel and while the body was good , the mech didnt look the same on the examples I could google up ... and the 10 spoke wheels were nowhere to be seen ... only on other AF versions .

So possibly the last of the Metzels cast bodies fitted with 1916-17 type wheels makes sense? 

Kinda Stoked at that and as always wonder how the heck it got here ... Loco was from a non-train seller and was part of a deceased estate they have had for years .. in fact it was advertised as "Antique 1930's Iron toy clockwork steam engine working OK " I made a cheeky offer and a price was sorted

Thank you for taking a chunk out of out my huge weak spot of early USA locos !

Last edited by Fatman
@Fatman posted:

Oh Wow thank you for the excellent news @Nation Wide Lines I looked at Edmonds-Metzel and while the body was good , the mech didnt look the same on the examples I could google up ... and the 10 spoke wheels were nowhere to be seen ... only on other AF versions .

So possibly the last of the Metzels cast bodies fitted with 1916-17 type wheels makes sense? 

Kinda Stoked at that and as always wonder how the heck it got here ... Loco was from a non-train seller and was part of a deceased estate they have had for years .. in fact it was advertised as "Antique 1930's Iron toy clockwork steam engine working OK " I made a cheeky offer and a price was sorted

Thank you for taking a chunk out of out my huge weak spot of early USA locos !

Fatman,

I actually purchased some early Flyer cars c. 1915/1916 out of Australia several years ago and wondered how they got there as well!

Here are photos of what I purchased from down-under

A c. 1915 baggage car

and a c. 1916 coach

I was most surprised by the fact that the two cars were mixed between an early wood wall pattern litho baggage and a later steel wall pattern coach.

NWL

Last edited by Nation Wide Lines

@Nation Wide Lines Wouldnt it be a hoot if your hodge podge of carriages came from the same house as my hodge podge Metzel!!! Only to be virtually reunited on the forum after 100 years !

The Metzel is obviously the shining pinnacle this week , but it is overshadowing some cool finds this week as well ...

I snapped up a fully working Davis-Electra transformer/controller manufactured for ROBILT ...max 20Vac Big Beefy Bugga ! Thanks Nick for parting with it !

And a smattering of wagons/coaches from the Dutch Connection ( cue quirky theme music !)

only marked "Made in US Zone" Beckh? although the bases look Schuhmann? perhaps from the pre-war tooling when Beckh acquired AS and produced directly after the war ?

I particularly like this one tho ... a Gas car

A little Bub tender ...

Unmarked but fairly sure its a Bub Crane car

And a little blue Issmayer

And in "Non-trainyville" I also scored a neat little Hess Dynamobil ... fascinating stored energy flywheel motor power unit that can be attached to pretty much any steam tool accessory to power it safely without handing your kids a bottle of fuel and matches !!! LOL!

Turning the handle imparts huge RPM into a large flywheel inside it and then the stored power can be transfered to the output pully with a simple on/off dog clutch.. I love it !

I acquired one locally a few years ago but it didnt have the litho top cover ...

Last edited by Fatman
@Arne posted:

A few news in the collection.

Brimtoy train 124, made 1916

Bub indicators from the 30s, all the same with different names.

Germany

Netherland

France

Danmark

And a unknown indicator for Australia

anz-austra01anz-austra02

With Adelaide, Mildura, Albury, Bendigo, Frankston, Geelong, Flinders St

anz-austra03

Arne

Hello @Arne and thanks @Fatman for notifying me of the post.

Great work finding the Bonnie Toys (F W Strong) station indicator.

As Fatman noted they are thin on the ground here in Australia. There have been a few more than usual over the last three years or so due to two large Australian collections being sold off. Once the disposal of these collections has been finalised I’m guessing that it will go back to only one or two popping up a year.

Your destination/station indicator is a good example. It is a later version with round die cast base and post. Early ones had a rectangular wooden base and a repurposed 4” timber nail as a post (rare). The Victorian/SA station names are not as common as the Victorian/NSW station names. The rarest ones are those with Queensland station names (have only seen 2 offered for sale)

These date from between 1949 - 1958ish. And follow the post war austerity era tradition of repurposing surplus army stocks into toys, hence the top of the indicator being made from a tin wax match box.

The maker of these signs, a Mr Fredrick W Strauss fled Germany in 1939 but made good use of toolmaking skills he learnt as a toolmaker in the Mercedes Benz factory to make cast hand bag fittings etc... under his new name of Fredrick W Strong.  Post war brought a shortage of imported goods , in particular toy trains were scarce on the ground in the late 40’s (as noted in the newspapers of the time) and ones like Mr Strong stepped in to help fill the toy store shelves. Your sign would have been originally packaged in a red and black cardboard box as a Bonnie Toy Product by F W Strong with a terrier logo (the family’s pet).

Bonnie Toys/F W Strong made several railway accessories including a battery powered signal (rare), crossing gates (common), road signs, power poles (rare) and a mini Sydney harbour bridge (rarer than a live Dodo). The decline of the product can be dated by the introduction of cast metal HO/00 accessories for a short period of time. This seems to indicate the late 1950’s early 1960’s when O gauge died with the importation of 00/H0 models as import restrictions eased. Either way it was all sadly wrapped up by 1966 with the passing of Mr Strong.  (Information thanks to Bruce MacDonald’s book Spring, Spark and Steam and his many articles in the HRCAA journals)

All in all a nice rare period piece to add to your collection. Enjoy!

Kind Regards

Jamie

@Fatman posted:

And a smattering of wagons/coaches from the Dutch Connection ( cue quirky theme music !)

only marked "Made in US Zone" Beckh? although the bases look Schuhmann? perhaps from the pre-war tooling when Beckh acquired AS and produced directly after the war ?

I particularly like this one tho ... a Gas car




Hello Fatman,

your right, all made by Beckh, the white and the brown car was sold under the same number 140/3. made between 1950 and 1960.

The gas car was made by Schuhmann 1935 first and later by Beckh till 1960, number is 140/8.



Arne

Fantastic find @Arne rare and in excellent condition! beautiful!

While not tinplate I did come across some cast teeny trains as well ..

Made by Crescent and Gaeity Toys in the UK

( just too cute to ignore lol )

The three larger A4 loco's and carriage are Crescent , the bottom left Maroon one is Gaeity, both from the 50's the other two bottom right are Benbros No16a locomotives C1953/4

* Interesting factoid .. two of the young fellows 'Smith & Odell' who made these Crescent trains were taught their diecast trade there ... and went on to create ... Matchbox !!! So there is a fair bet they cast at least one of those trains in their youth  lol

The Standard Gauge track got finished (two straight pieces had to be cut to fit the table size) and screwed down to the table, and then wired for the MTH Z400 transformer yesterday. A little test run video made. Loving the purple, orange & blue, and apple green cars for Halloween! The O-31 tubular track circle is expected today! Showing the 'finished' Standard Gauge area, before the track got sorted.

fullsizeoutput_b50e

Attachments

Images (1)
  • fullsizeoutput_b50e
Videos (1)
IMG_9083

Proud recipient of this very nice station.  I don't know much about the manufacturer,  Heinrich Wimmer Nurnberg, although apparently they collaborate with Karl Bub on at least one occasion.  My found this online and had it shipped from the Netherlands.

20201029_20581420201029_20572120201029_20575620201029_205900

I have to tell,  the litho for the flower boxes is so good I had to check to see if they were embossed.   They are not,  just amazing graphics.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20201029_205900
  • 20201029_205814
  • 20201029_205721
  • 20201029_205756

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×