Skip to main content

I am putting together  a 11' by 19' layout using tubular track. I need to decide if my signals (three at present) are to run off track power (a MTH Z4000) or separate AC power (an old Lionel ZW).  I am leaning heavily towards separate AC power for the signals using Lionel 1531R IR controllers, since the signals would not then reduce available power to the trains.

I am electronically challenged, but from looking at the wiring diagrams for the above approach it appears to me that the two transformers would not be directly connected to each other. Under these circumstances do I need to be concerned about the two transformer being in phase with each other?  Any guidance would be most appreciated.

Bob

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Not sure I am the guy to answer your question, because I can't but I use a Prewar 1044 for accessories, a prewar ZW to run three loops and a CW-80 to run the kids loop. All U post are inner connected on track power maybe even the 1044 and it all works just fine. Not to sure about the transformer being in phase with each other but have heard of it. Would be nice to know.

As long as the signal circuits are completed separate from the track supply, and are not being operated by a shared conductor (wire) such as a trigger wire from an insulated track section, you do not need to have the transformers in phase.   However, it would be a good idea to wire them in phase in the event that you want to use other signalling schemes in the future.

Arthur P. Bloom posted:

As long as the signal circuits are completed separate from the track supply, and are not being operated by a shared conductor (wire) such as a trigger wire from an insulated track section, you do not need to have the transformers in phase.   However, it would be a good idea to wire them in phase in the event that you want to use other signalling schemes in the future.

I wold certainly phase the transformers for the above reason.  It's pretty easy and takes little time --- and you're "future proofed"!

Just because no one said it yet that I read, to phase a transformer with another put a light bulb connected to two wires and put one on each transformer, if it lights up you need to change one wire. If you don't have a light set up put a lighted caboose on a track and add one wire to middle and one to outside and slowly add power from both transformers and again if it lights up you need to change one wire. ( this is incase somehow you have a transformer that they are reversed like Arthur said. )

I joined this forum years ago because I needed help with this very issue of phasing.  My PW engines were shifting to neutral between blocks controlled by two different ZW's.  The guys told me to simply reverse one of the plugs to the power source because the transformers were out of phase.  Took at least 10 seconds to solve the problem.  

Also, I always try to separate track power from accessory power where possible.

Jerry

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×